Publisher Correction: Personalized structural image analysis in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy

Christian Rummel, Nedelina Slavova, Andrea Seiler, Eugenio Abela, Martinus Hauf, Yuliya Burren, Christian Weisstanner, Serge Vulliémoz, Margitta Seeck, Kaspar Schindler, Roland WiestScientific 2018 · DOI · OpenAlex

Scientific Reports Journal Logo

Overview

In September 2017, Scientific Reports published a study titled "Personalized structural image analysis in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy." Following publication, a systemic error was identified regarding the bibliography and in-text citations. This publisher correction serves to rectify these errors, ensuring that the scientific claims are properly attributed and that the research remains verifiable within the neuroimaging community.

The Nature of the Bibliographic Errors

The primary issue addressed in this correction is a significant misalignment within the reference list. A systemic shift occurred where references 18–21 were swapped with 53–56, and references 22–56 were swapped with 18–52. Such errors are critical in academic publishing as they prevent readers from accurately tracing the foundational work and data sources upon which the study's conclusions are built.

In addition to the list shift, the correction fixes typographical errors in citations across the Introduction, Conclusion, and Materials and Methods sections. It also corrects an incorrect title and journal destination for a related "under review" paper cited in the original text.

Methodological Clarifications

While the core experimental results of the original study remain unchanged, the correction clarifies the technical framework and software versions used. The study employed Voxel-Based Morphometry (VBM) to analyze brain structures in epilepsy patients. Specifically, the "Automated image processing and quality control" phase utilized the FSL software suite (version 5.0). This pipeline was essential for estimating the total volumes of Cerebrospinal Fluid (CSF), Grey Matter (GM), and White Matter (WM).

Updated Scientific Context

The correction provides "now reads" versions of several key passages to align the text with the correct supporting literature:

  • VBM Yield: The original text cited a limited range of papers regarding the diagnostic yield of VBM. The corrected version expands this to a broader set of evidence (References 18–24).
  • Methodological Precedent: Passages describing VBM volume estimation, previously misattributed, now correctly point to the work of Huppertz et al. and related foundational texts (References 18 and 19).
  • Reference 32 Update: A notable correction was made to Reference 32. Originally listed as a related work by Rummel et al. regarding "surface-based morphometry," the corrected entry identifies the actual paper as "A fully automated pipeline for normative atrophy in patients with neurodegenerative disease," published in Frontiers in Neurology.

Conclusion

This correction restores the bibliographic integrity of the original research. By ensuring that quantitative claims—such as those involving automated volume estimation via FSL—are linked to the correct methodologies and software versions, the authors maintain the transparency and reproducibility required for clinical neuroimaging research.

Creative Commons Attribution License

Summary updated

Abstract

A correction to this article has been published and is linked from the HTML version of this paper. The error has been fixed in the paper.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rummel2018publisher,
  author = {Christian Rummel and Nedelina Slavova and Andrea Seiler and Eugenio Abela and Martinus Hauf and Yuliya Burren and Christian Weisstanner and Serge Vulliémoz and Margitta Seeck and Kaspar Schindler and Roland Wiest},
  title = {{Publisher Correction: Personalized structural image analysis in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-017-16213-8},
}

Loading related content...

Figure