Phase or Amplitude? The Relationship between Ongoing and Evoked Neural Activity

Chunqi Qian, Xin DiJournal of Neuroscience 2011 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Whether performing a task or resting, our brains exhibit continuous neural activity, which at any instant comprises the evoked response to a given task and ongoing activity. There is increased interest in this ongoing activity because accumulating evidence has shown that it can influence perception. This paper explores the relationship between ongoing alpha oscillations and evoked hemodynamic responses, specifically investigating whether the phase or the amplitude of these oscillations dictates the brain's response to visual stimuli.

Introduction

Our brains are never truly "off." Even in a state of rest, they exhibit continuous, ongoing neural activity. When an external stimulus—such as a flash of light—is presented, the resulting "evoked" response is layered upon this background activity. For decades, neuroscientists have sought to understand how this background noise influences perception. Specifically, two major questions have persisted: First, is the brain's response governed by the amplitude (the power or strength) or the phase (the specific timing within the cycle) of ongoing oscillations? Second, how can we methodologically distinguish between the background activity and the stimulus-driven response?

While Electroencephalography (EEG) offers high temporal resolution, it lacks the spatial precision to pinpoint where activity occurs. Conversely, functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) provides excellent spatial localization but is too slow to capture the rapid timing of brain waves. By reviewing the landmark work of Scheeringa et al. (2011b), this paper examines how simultaneous EEG-fMRI can decouple these factors to reveal the mechanics of visual processing.

Methodology

The study utilized simultaneous EEG and fMRI recordings to monitor human subjects during a visual task.

The Experimental Task

Subjects were presented with a brief (17 ms) wedge-shaped stimulus in their peripheral vision. To ensure consistent attention, they performed a simultaneous distractor task, which involved detecting color changes at a central fixation point.

Signal Analysis

To isolate the relevant neural signals, researchers employed Independent Component Analysis (ICA) on the EEG data to extract the "alpha band" (8–12 Hz) signal originating specifically from the visual cortex. They then calculated the exact amplitude and phase of this signal at the precise moment of stimulus onset.

Decoupling Ongoing and Evoked Activity

A critical innovation in this study was the use of "pseudo-trials." These were moments where no stimulus was delivered, allowing researchers to record the "ongoing" baseline activity. By subtracting this baseline from the stimulus-driven trials, they could isolate the "net" evoked response (the Blood Oxygen Level Dependent, or BOLD, signal) and determine how it was modulated by the pre-stimulus alpha state.

Key Insights

Functional Dissociation of Phase and Amplitude

The research revealed a clear functional dissociation between the phase and amplitude of alpha oscillations. While both appear to influence the BOLD signal, they do so in fundamentally different ways. Phase directly modulates the magnitude of the net evoked response, whereas amplitude primarily shifts the baseline activity level.

The "Trough" Advantage

One of the most significant findings was that stimuli arriving during the "trough" of an alpha cycle induced a significantly stronger BOLD response in the primary visual cortex than those arriving at the "peak." This suggests that the trough of the alpha oscillation represents a state of higher neuronal excitability, making the cortex more receptive to incoming sensory information.

The Importance of Baseline Correction

Previous research often suggested that high alpha power (amplitude) leads to smaller evoked responses. However, this study demonstrated that once the lower BOLD baseline associated with high alpha power is accounted for, the actual "net" response added by the stimulus remains relatively consistent regardless of the starting power. This highlights the necessity of accounting for ongoing activity when measuring evoked responses.

Spatial Specificity

The modulation effects of the alpha phase were not uniform across the brain. They were most prominent in Brodmann’s area 17 (the primary visual cortex). As the signal progressed into higher-order visual areas (BA 18 and 19), these phase-modulation effects weakened, suggesting that the timing of ongoing oscillations is most critical during the initial stages of sensory registration.

Discussion and Limitations

The Latency Paradox

A notable challenge in interpreting these results is the "latency paradox." It typically takes 34–100 ms for a visual signal to travel from the retina to the visual cortex. Therefore, the alpha phase at the exact moment of stimulus onset is not technically the phase that processes the signal. The authors suggest that the phase at onset serves as a reliable proxy for the phase one cycle (~100 ms) later, when the signal actually arrives at the cortex.

Additive vs. Phase-Resetting Models

The study operates on the assumption that ongoing and evoked activities are additive. However, alternative theories suggest that a stimulus might "reset" the phase of ongoing oscillations rather than simply adding to them. The extent to which phase-resetting contributes to the observed BOLD response remains a subject of ongoing debate in the field.

Stimulus Intensity

The stimuli used in this study were "above-threshold," meaning they were easily visible. This likely captured feed-forward (bottom-up) processing. Future research is needed to explore how these dynamics change with "near-threshold" stimuli, where top-down factors like attention and expectation play a more dominant role in perception.

Conclusion

By integrating the temporal precision of EEG with the spatial mapping of fMRI, this research provides a direct link between the millisecond-scale structure of brain waves and localized hemodynamic responses. The discovery that the alpha phase dictates the strength of the visual response in V1 advances our understanding of the brain as a dynamic system where the timing of ongoing activity is just as critical as the stimulus itself.

Summary updated

Abstract

Whether performing a task or resting, our brains exhibit continuous neural activity, which at any instant comprises the evoked response to a given task and ongoing activity. There is increased interest in this ongoing activity because accumulating evidence has shown that it can influence perception
BibTeX
@article{qian2011phase,
  author = {Chunqi Qian and Xin Di},
  title = {{Phase or Amplitude? The Relationship between Ongoing and Evoked Neural Activity}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.2197-11.2011},
}

Loading related content...

Figure