Peer Review #2 of "Cloning and evaluation of reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR analysis in Amorphophallus (v0.1)"

Kai Wang, Yi Niu, Qijun Wang, Haili Liu, Yi Jin, Shenglin Zhang, C Andersen, J Jensen, T Orntoft, D Thompson, A Regev, S Roy, A Untergasser, H Nijveen, X Rao, T Bisseling, R Geurts, J Leunissen, J Vandesompele, De Preter, K Pattyn, F Poppe, B Van Roy, N, De Paepe, A Speleman, F, J Vermeulen, K Lefever, S Nuytens, J, De Vloed, F Derveaux, S Hellemans, J Speleman, F Vandesompele, M Wang, B Zhang, H Wan, Z Zhao, C Qian, Y Sui, A Malik, J Chen, W Wu, H Chen, W Xia, A Mason, Y Xiao, Z Liu, Y Yang, X Lei, X Wu, Z Ma, M Peng, H Yang, J Liu, S Huang, T Guo, L Deng, W Hua, Y Zhang, B Xie, X Gan, X Zheng, C Pan, Y Diao, Y You, C Yang, Z Hu, A Zmienko, A Samelak-Czajka, M Goralski, E Sobieszczuk-Nowicka, P Kozlowski, M FiglerowiczOpenalex Unknown 2017 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR (RT-qPCR) is a cornerstone of modern molecular biology, offering high sensitivity and reproducibility for gene expression analysis. However, its accuracy hinges on the use of stable reference genes for transcript normalization. Amorphophallus, a genus of perennial plants valued for its high konjac glucomannan (KGM) content, has historically lacked validated reference genes. This study addresses this gap by cloning and evaluating nine candidate reference genes across various tissues and abiotic stresses in Amorphophallus albus and A. konjac. Using three distinct statistical algorithms, we identified EF1-α and EIF4A as the most stable reference genes overall. These findings provide a robust framework for future gene expression studies in this economically significant crop.

Introduction

Amorphophallus species are widely cultivated in Asia for their corms, which are rich in glucomannan—a polysaccharide used extensively in food, medicine, and industrial applications. Despite its importance, molecular research into the genus has been hindered by a lack of genomic resources. Specifically, the absence of validated reference genes has made it difficult to accurately quantify gene expression changes in response to environmental stressors or during different developmental stages.

In RT-qPCR experiments, reference genes (often called "housekeeping genes") serve as internal controls to account for variations in RNA quality, reverse transcription efficiency, and sample loading. However, no gene is universally stable across all species and conditions. This study aimed to identify the most reliable reference genes for Amorphophallus under heat and waterlogging stress, as well as across different tissue types.

Materials and Methods

Due to the limited genomic data available for Amorphophallus, the researchers selected nine candidate reference genes commonly used in other monocots: GAPDH, ACTB, EF1-α, EIF4A, TUB, RP, H3, UBQ, and CYP. Putative sequences for these genes were cloned from A. albus and A. konjac using degenerate primers designed from conserved regions in related species.

The stability of these candidates was tested in a dataset of 78 cDNA samples representing:

  1. Tissue Types: Leaves, roots, and corms.
  2. Abiotic Stresses: Heat stress (40°C) and waterlogging stress.

Gene expression stability was evaluated using three widely accepted statistical algorithms: geNorm, NormFinder, and BestKeeper. To validate the results, the researchers measured the expression of a target gene, SHSP (a small heat shock protein), normalizing it against both the most stable and the least stable identified reference genes.

Results and Discussion

Identification of Stable Reference Genes

The analysis revealed that traditional housekeeping genes like ACTB (beta-actin) and GAPDH performed poorly in Amorphophallus, showing significant variation across conditions. In contrast, EF1-α and EIF4A emerged as the most consistently stable genes across all tested tissues and treatments.

Stability rankings varied slightly depending on the specific stressor:

  • Heat Stress: EF1-α, EIF4A, H3, and UBQ were the top performers.
  • Waterlogging: EF1-α, EIF4A, TUB, and RP showed the highest stability.
  • Tissue Comparison: EF1-α, EIF4A, and CYP were the most reliable across leaves, roots, and corms.

The Importance of Multi-Gene Normalization

A key finding of the study was that using a combination of reference genes significantly improves normalization accuracy. The "Sum of Squares" (SS) values for combinations of the top three genes (e.g., EF1-α + EIF4A + H3) were lower than those for any single gene. This suggests that for high-precision studies in Amorphophallus, researchers should use at least two validated reference genes.

Validation with SHSP

The suitability of the identified genes was confirmed by analyzing the expression of SHSP. When normalized with the stable genes EF1-α and EIF4A, SHSP showed the expected sharp increase in expression under heat stress. However, when normalized with the unstable ACTB, the resulting expression pattern was erratic and likely inaccurate, highlighting the critical importance of proper reference gene selection.

Conclusion

This study provides the first systematic validation of reference genes for Amorphophallus, establishing EF1-α and EIF4A as the "gold standard" for RT-qPCR normalization in the genus. While these results offer a reliable toolkit for studying heat and waterlogging responses, future work should expand this validation to other stressors such as drought, salinity, and soft rot infection. As genomic data for Amorphophallus continues to grow, these findings will serve as a vital benchmark for advancing our understanding of this unique and valuable crop.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR (RT-qPCR) has been widely used in the detectionand quantification of gene expression levels because of its high accuracy, sensitivity, and reproducibility as well as its large dynamic range.However, the reliability and accuracy of RT-qPCR depends on accurate transcript normalization using stably expressed reference genes.Amorphophallus is a perennial plant with a high content of konjac glucomannan (KGM) in its corm.This crop has been used as a food source and as a traditional medicine for thousands of years.Without adequate knowledge of gene expression profiles, there has been no report of validated reference genes in Amorphophallus.In this study, nine genes that are usually used as reference genes in other crops were selected as candidate reference genes.These putative sequences of these genes Amorphophallus were cloned by the use of degenerate primers.The expression stability of each gene was assessed in different tissues and under two abiotic stresses (heat and waterlogging) in A. albus and A. konjac.Three distinct algorithms were used to evaluate the expression stability of the candidate reference genes.The results demonstrated that EF1-a, EIF4A, H3 and UBQ were the best reference genes under heat stress in Amorphophallus.Furthermore, EF1-a, EIF4A, TUB, and RP were the best reference genes in waterlogged conditions.By comparing different tissues from all samples, we determined that EF1-α, EIF4A, and CYP were stable in these sets.In addition, the suitability of these reference genes was confirmed by validating the expression of a gene encoding the small heat shock protein SHSP, which is related to heat stress in Amorphophallus.In sum, EF1-α and EIF4A were the two best reference genes for normalizing mRNA levels in different tissues and under various stress treatments, and we suggest using one of these genes in combination with 1 or 2 reference genes associated with different biological processes to normalize gene expression.Our results will provide researchers with appropriate reference genes for further gene expression quantification using RT-qPCR in
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2017peer,
  author = {Kai Wang and Yi Niu and Qijun Wang and Haili Liu and Yi Jin and Shenglin Zhang and C Andersen and J Jensen and T Orntoft and D Thompson and A Regev and S Roy and A Untergasser and H Nijveen and X Rao and T Bisseling and R Geurts and J Leunissen and J Vandesompele and De Preter and K Pattyn and F Poppe and B Van Roy and N and De Paepe and A Speleman and F and J Vermeulen and De Preter and K Lefever and S Nuytens and J and De Vloed and F Derveaux and S Hellemans and J Speleman and F Vandesompele and J and M Wang and Q Wang and B Zhang and H Wan and Z Zhao and C Qian and Y Sui and A Malik and J Chen and W Wu and H Chen and W Xia and A Mason and Y Xiao and Z Liu and Y Yang and X Lei and X Wu and Z Ma and M Peng and H Yang and J Liu and S Huang and T Guo and L Deng and W Hua and Y Zhang and B Xie and X Gan and X Zheng and C Pan and Y Diao and Y You and C Yang and Z Hu and A Zmienko and A Samelak-Czajka and M Goralski and E Sobieszczuk-Nowicka and P Kozlowski and M Figlerowicz},
  title = {{Peer Review \#2 of "Cloning and evaluation of reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR analysis in Amorphophallus (v0.1)"}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7287/peerj.3260v0.1/reviews/2},
}
Figure