Peer Review #2 of "Changes in nutrients and decay rate of Ginkgo biloba leaf litter exposed to elevated O3 concentration in urban area (v0.1)"

Wei Fu, Xingyuan He, Sheng Xu, Wei Chen, Yan Li, Bo Li, Lili Su, Weiping Qin, H Akimotoa, Y Morib, K Sasaki, Y Itano, A Austin, L Vivanco, D Baldantoni, M Fagnano, A Alfani, G Bonanomi, G Incerti, V Antignani, M Capodilupo, S Mazzoleni, F Giannino, A Mingo, V Lanzotti, F Booker, S Prior, H Torbert, S Hu, V Calatayud, J Cerver, E Calvo, F Garcia, J Armiriana, J Cao, H Shang, Z Chen, Y Tian, H Yu, A Chappelka, L Samuelson, Mdl De Bauer, T Hernndez-Tejeda, M Dubois, K Gilles, J Hamilton, P Rebers, F Smith, A Fioretto, Di Nardo, C Papa, S Fuggi, A, W Xu, C Liu, W Zhu, Y Jin, Y Zhang, Y Huang, H Wen, W Huang, Chen Dong, T Liu, C Chen, Z Xu, S Ruan, Y, R Julkunen-Tiitto, P Kainulainen, T Holopainen, J Holopainen, A Lavola, E Paakkonen, X Li, L Zhang, L Ma, Q Chen, L Wang, R Lindroth, B Kopper, Wfj Parsons, J Bockheim, Dfk Karnosky, G Hendrey, K Pregitzer, J Isebrands, J SoberOpenalex Unknown 2018 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Ground-level ozone ($O_3$) pollution is a growing concern in Asian cities, potentially influencing tree growth and nutrient cycling. This study investigated the impact of elevated $O_3$ (120 ppb) on the decomposition of Ginkgo biloba leaf litter in an urban environment. Results showed that elevated $O_3$ significantly increased potassium (K) content while decreasing total phenols and soluble sugars in the foliage. Although the overall mass loss after 150 days was similar between ambient and elevated $O_3$ treatments (56.0% vs. 52.8%), the decomposition rate was initially slower and later accelerated under high $O_3$ conditions. These findings suggest that ozone pollution alters the chemical signature and temporal dynamics of urban leaf litter decomposition, potentially impacting broader biogeochemical cycles.

Introduction

Tropospheric ozone ($O_3$) is a potent oxidative stressor known to stunt tree growth and damage foliage. While its impacts on living vegetation are well-documented, its influence on the "afterlife" of leaves—the decomposition of leaf litter—remains poorly understood, particularly in urban forests. In cities like Shenyang, China, where $O_3$ levels frequently spike during summer, Ginkgo biloba is a dominant tree species. Understanding how ozone-induced changes in leaf chemistry affect decomposition is crucial for predicting shifts in urban soil nutrient cycling and carbon storage.

Methodology

The study employed Open-Top Chambers (OTCs) at the Shenyang Arboretum to grow five-year-old Ginkgo biloba saplings under two conditions: Ambient Air (AA, ~40 ppb) and Elevated Ozone (EO, 120 ppb). Naturally senesced yellow leaves were collected to simulate actual urban leaf litter.

The decomposition process was monitored using the standard litterbag method. Dried leaf samples (8g) were placed in nylon mesh bags on the soil surface and sampled monthly over a 150-day period. Researchers analyzed the litter for mass loss and chemical composition, including Carbon (C), Nitrogen (N), Phosphorus (P), Potassium (K), lignin, total phenols, condensed tannins, and soluble sugars. Decay constants were modeled using Olson’s exponential decay equation ($Y = e^{-kt}$).

Key Findings

Chemical Alterations in Leaf Litter

Exposure to elevated $O_3$ significantly altered the nutrient and secondary metabolite profile of Ginkgo leaves compared to ambient conditions:

  • Potassium Spike: K content increased by approximately 184% ($6.31 \pm 0.29$ mg/g in AA vs. $17.93 \pm 0.40$ mg/g in EO). This is likely a physiological stress response, as trees may ramp up K absorption to facilitate protein synthesis and maintain cellular stability under oxidative stress.
  • Depleted Antioxidant Defenses: Total phenols ($2.82 \pm 0.93$ vs $1.60 \pm 0.44$ mg/g) and soluble sugars significantly decreased. This suggests that the tree "uses up" its carbon-based antioxidant defenses and energy stores to combat ozone damage while the leaf is still alive.
  • Stable Structural Components: No significant changes were observed in the contents of C, N, P, lignin, or condensed tannins.

Biphasic Decomposition Dynamics

While the total mass remaining after 150 days was statistically similar between treatments, the temporal pattern of decomposition shifted:

  • Temporal Shift: Decomposition was slower in ozone-exposed litter during the first 60 days but slightly accelerated after the 120-day mark.
  • Decay Constant: The EO treatment showed a slightly higher overall decay constant ($K = 1.39$) compared to AA ($K = 1.17$), though the difference was not statistically significant over the 150-day window.
  • Nutrient Loss: Nutrient loss followed strong seasonal patterns regardless of treatment, though ozone specifically accelerated the loss of Carbon from the litter in the late stage (after 120 days).

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research demonstrates that ground-level ozone pollution fundamentally changes the chemical composition and decomposition patterns of Ginkgo biloba leaf litter. The observed shift toward a biphasic decay process—starting slow but accelerating later—highlights the complexity of urban biogeochemical cycles under environmental stress.

Future research should extend the observation period beyond 150 days to determine if the late-stage acceleration persists. Additionally, investigating the response of soil microbial communities to ozone-altered litter will be essential for a holistic understanding of urban ecosystem health and carbon sequestration capacity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ground-level ozone (O 3 ) pollution has been widely concerned in the world, particularly in the cities of Asia, including China.Elevated O 3 concentrations have potentially influenced growth and nutrient cycling of trees in urban forest.The decomposition characteristics of urban tree litters under O 3 exposure are still poorly known.Ginkgo biloba is commonly planted in the cities of northern China and is one of the main tree species in the urban forest of Shenyang, where concentrations of ground-level O 3 are very high in summer.Here, we hypothesized that O 3 exposure at high concentrations would alter the decomposition rate of urban tree litter.In open-top cambers (OTCs), 5-year-old G. biloba saplings were planted to investigate the impact of elevated O 3 concentration (120 ppb) on changes in nutrient contents and decomposition rate of leaf litters.The results showed that elevated O 3 concentration significantly increased K content (6.31 ± 0.29 vs 17.93 ± 0.40, P<0.01) in leaves of G. biloba, significantly decreased the contents of total phenols ( 2.82 ± 0.93 vs 1.60 ± 0.44, P<0.05) and soluble sugars (86.51 ± 19.57vs 53.76 ± 2.40, P<0.05), but did not significantly alter the contents of C, N, P, lignin and condensed tannins, compared with that in ambient air.Furthermore, percent mass remaining in litterbags after 150 days under ambient air and elevated O 3 concentration was 56.0% and 52.8%, respectively.No significant difference between treatments was observed in mass remaining at any sampling date during decomposition.The losses of the nutrients in leaf litters of G. biloba showed significant seasonal differences regardless of O 3 treatment.However, we found that elevated O 3 concentration slowed down the leaf litter decomposition only at the early decomposition stage, but slightly accelerated the litter decomposition at the late stage (after 120 days).This study provides our understanding of the ecological processes regulating biogeochemical cycles from deciduous tree species in high-O 3 urban area.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fu2018peer,
  author = {Wei Fu and Xingyuan He and Sheng Xu and Wei Chen and Yan Li and Bo Li and Lili Su and Weiping Qin and H Akimotoa and Y Morib and K Sasaki and Y Itano and A Austin and L Vivanco and D Baldantoni and M Fagnano and A Alfani and G Bonanomi and G Incerti and V Antignani and M Capodilupo and S Mazzoleni and G Bonanomi and G Incerti and F Giannino and A Mingo and V Lanzotti and S Mazzoleni and F Booker and S Prior and H Torbert and S Hu and V Calatayud and J Cerver and E Calvo and F Garcia and J Armiriana and J Cao and H Shang and Z Chen and Y Tian and H Yu and A Chappelka and L Samuelson and Mdl De Bauer and T Hernndez-Tejeda and M Dubois and K Gilles and J Hamilton and P Rebers and F Smith and A Fioretto and Di Nardo and C Papa and S Fuggi and A and X He and W Chen and W Xu and C Liu and W Zhu and Y Jin and Y Zhang and X He and S Xu and W Xu and W Chen and Y Huang and H Wen and X He and W Huang and Chen Dong and T Liu and C Chen and Z Xu and S Ruan and Y and R Julkunen-Tiitto and P Kainulainen and T Holopainen and J Holopainen and A Lavola and R Julkunen-Tiitto and E Paakkonen and X Li and L Zhang and Y Li and L Ma and Q Chen and L Wang and X He and R Lindroth and B Kopper and Wfj Parsons and J Bockheim and Dfk Karnosky and G Hendrey and K Pregitzer and J Isebrands and J Sober},
  title = {{Peer Review \#2 of "Changes in nutrients and decay rate of Ginkgo biloba leaf litter exposed to elevated O3 concentration in urban area (v0.1)"}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7287/peerj.4453v0.1/reviews/2},
}
Figure