On Some Endogenous Probability-Migration Models

Manuel Philippe Émile Garçon, Josselin Garnier, Amina Omrane, Abdennebi OmraneSPIRE 2014 · OpenAlex

Abstract: International audience

Introduction

In classical economic theory, international migration is frequently characterized as a "brain drain"—a net loss of human capital for the country of origin. However, contemporary "Brain Gain" theories suggest a more complex dynamic: the mere opportunity to migrate can incentivize individuals to invest more heavily in their own education. This paper, originally presented at the 2011 colloquium of the Association de Science Régionale De Langue Française, seeks to refine these theories by moving beyond models that treat migration probability as a fixed, exogenous factor. Instead, it proposes an "endogenous" framework where the likelihood of moving abroad is a variable determined by the level of human capital within the population.

Modeling Endogenous Migration

The authors employ a no-growth overlapping generations (OLG) model to analyze how different perceptions of migration risk influence long-term economic stability. In this two-period framework, individuals decide during their youth how to allocate time between leisure and education ($e_t$). In adulthood, they either work domestically or migrate with a probability ($p_{t+1}$).

The study contrasts two primary migration processes:

  1. The Traditional Model: Migration probability is determined by the human capital inherited from the previous generation.
  2. The Anticipative Model: Migration probability depends on the human capital the individual currently acquires, creating a feedback loop between individual effort and perceived opportunity.

Selection Mechanisms and Indeterminacy

A significant challenge in the anticipative model is "indeterminacy"—situations where multiple mathematical outcomes are possible from the same starting conditions. To address how a society might navigate these multiple paths, the authors introduce three selection mechanisms:

  • Pessimistic: The society converges toward the lowest possible human capital outcome.
  • Optimistic: The society pursues the highest possible growth outcome.
  • Conservative: The outcome is determined by the state closest to the current status quo.

Results and Stability Analysis

The mathematical analysis demonstrates that human capital sequences typically converge toward one of two fixed points: a low-growth trap ($h_1$) or a high-growth steady state ($h_2$). The transition between these states is often governed by threshold effects.

Figure 5: Transition functions for human capital (hT+1 vs hT) showing the threshold effects and potential for multiple equilibria in endogenous migration models.

As illustrated in the phase dynamics, the economy is highly sensitive to collective beliefs. In the anticipative model, if agents believe a high probability of migration exists, their increased investment in education can become a self-fulfilling prophecy, raising the country's average human capital and justifying the initial belief. The "Optimistic" mechanism is particularly powerful, as it effectively lowers the threshold of initial human capital required for a nation to escape a low-development trap.

Conclusion

This theoretical study highlights that the long-term economic trajectory of a developing nation is not solely dictated by its current resources, but also by the "mood" or collective expectations of its citizens regarding future opportunities. While the model uses a simplified step function for migration probability, it provides a robust mathematical basis for understanding "club convergence," where similar countries diverge into vastly different wealth levels based on their internal selection mechanisms. Future work remains to empirically validate these behavioral selection mechanisms against real-world migration and education data.

Summary updated

Abstract

International audience
BibTeX
@inproceedings{garcon2014some,
  author = {Manuel Philippe Émile Garçon and Josselin Garnier and Amina Omrane and Abdennebi Omrane},
  title = {{On Some Endogenous Probability-Migration Models}},
  booktitle = {SPIRE},
  year = {2014},
}

Loading related content...

Figure