Non-Bloch PT Symmetry: Universal Threshold and Dimensional Surprise

Fei Song, Hongyi Wang, Zhong WangWORLD 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

In the presence of the non-Hermitian skin effect (NHSE), non-Hermitian lattices can exhibit non-Bloch Parity-Time (PT) symmetry, resulting in entirely real eigenenergies under open boundary conditions. While this phenomenon is well-understood in one dimension, new research reveals a "dimensional surprise": in two and three dimensions, the threshold for PT symmetry breaking universally approaches zero as the system size increases. This study demonstrates that higher-dimensional non-Hermitian systems are fundamentally more fragile, with the PT-breaking threshold scaling as $1/L$. This discovery highlights a profound interplay between spatial dimensionality, symmetry, and the non-Hermitian skin effect.

Introduction

Quantum mechanics traditionally mandates Hermitian Hamiltonians to ensure real energy values. However, real-world "open" systems—those that exchange energy or particles with their environment—are better described by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. While these usually result in complex energies representing gain and loss, systems possessing Parity-Time (PT) symmetry can maintain entirely real energy spectra.

A recent study by Fei Song, Hong-Yi Wang, and Zhong Wang, published in Physical Review Letters, uncovers a startling "dimensional surprise": in two and three dimensions, this stability is far more fragile than previously thought.

The Dimensional Surprise

The study identifies a fundamental divergence between 1D and higher-dimensional systems. In 1D, the threshold for PT symmetry breaking—the point where energies transition from real to complex—remains finite even in the thermodynamic limit (as the system size $L \to \infty$). However, in 2D and 3D, this threshold vanishes, approaching zero as the system size increases.

Dimensional contrast: The PT-breaking threshold $\gamma$ remains finite in 1D (a) but approaches zero as $1/L$ in 3D (b).

This means that in large higher-dimensional systems, even an infinitesimal amount of non-Hermiticity (gain or loss) can break the PT symmetry, a behavior fundamentally different from the 1D case.

Mechanism: NHSE and the Breakdown of Perturbation Theory

The researchers attribute this sensitivity to the interplay between PT symmetry and the Non-Hermitian Skin Effect (NHSE). The NHSE is a phenomenon where a vast majority of a system's eigenstates collapse toward the boundaries rather than spreading through the bulk.

In higher dimensions, the NHSE forces adjacent energy states to become increasingly parallel as the system size grows. The authors introduced a quantitative "overlap measure" ($\bar{\eta}$) to track this tendency. They found that the effective strength of non-Hermiticity is not just determined by the parameter $\gamma$, but by the product $\gamma L$. As $L$ increases, this product grows, causing the breakdown of standard perturbation theory and triggering the transition to complex energies at lower and lower values of $\gamma$.

Key Results and Robustness

Numerical simulations on various geometries, including square and disk-shaped lattices, confirm the universal $1/L$ scaling of the PT-breaking threshold. Notably, this behavior persists even in the presence of random onsite disorder ($W$), proving it is a robust feature of the system's dimensionality rather than an artifact of a clean lattice.

Phase diagrams of the proportion of complex energies $P$ and state overlap $\bar{\eta}$ in 2D. The vanishing threshold (dashed lines) is observed only in the presence of NHSE (a, b, d, e).

The researchers also demonstrated that without the NHSE, the threshold remains finite regardless of dimensionality, confirming that the NHSE is the essential catalyst for this dimensional surprise.

Conclusion and Experimental Outlook

The discovery of a vanishing PT threshold in higher dimensions indicates an unexpected interplay among PT symmetry, the non-Hermitian skin effect, and spatial dimensionality. These findings have significant implications for the development of non-Hermitian sensors, lasers, and topological insulators.

The authors suggest that these predictions can be tested on experimentally accessible platforms, such as topolectrical circuits or coupled optical ring resonators. As researchers scale up these devices, they must account for this inherent instability to maintain the desired real-energy operation.

Reference: Song, F., Wang, H. Y., & Wang, Z. (2021). Non-Bloch PT symmetry breaking: Universal threshold and dimensional surprise. Physical Review Letters, 126(16), 165701.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the presence of non-Hermitian skin effect, non-Hermitian lattices generally have complex-valued eigenenergies under periodic boundary condition, but they can have non-Bloch PT symmetry and therefore completely real eigenenergies under open boundary condition. This novel PT symmetry and its breaking have been experimentally observed in one dimension. Here, we find that non-Bloch PT symmetry in two and higher dimensions exhibits drastically different behaviors compared to its one-dimensional counterpart. Whereas Bloch PT breaking and one-dimensional non-Bloch PT breaking generally have nonzero thresholds in the large-size limit, the threshold of two and higher-dimensional non-Bloch PT breaking universally approaches zero as the system size increases. A product measure, namely the product of bare non-Hermiticity and system size, is introduced to quantify the PT breaking tendency. This product being small is required for the perturbation theory to be valid, thus its growth with system size causes the breakdown of perturbation theory, which underlies the universal threshold. That the universal behaviors emerge only in two and higher dimensions indicates an unexpected interplay among PT symmetry, non-Hermitian skin effect, and spatial dimensionality. Our predictions can be confirmed on experimentally accessible platforms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2022non,
  author = {Fei Song and Hongyi Wang and Zhong Wang and Hong-Yi Wang},
  title = {{Non-Bloch PT Symmetry: Universal Threshold and Dimensional Surprise}},
  booktitle = {WORLD},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1142/9789811264153\_0017},
}

Loading related content...

Figure