Abstract
The mini-temporal approach can effectively shorten the time of craniotomy and closure, decrease the size of bony removal, increase the restoration of temporalis during closure, and lower the chance of facial nerve injury. Therefore, it improves cosmetic outcomes and reduces the risk of unintentional extra-temporal cortical injury, which fully embodies the minimally invasive principle in neurosurgery.
Introduction
For decades, the pterional craniotomy has served as the "workhorse" of neurosurgery, providing a wide view of the frontal and temporal lobes, the circle of Willis, and the optic nerves. However, this accessibility often comes at a significant cosmetic and functional cost. The classical approach requires extensive dissection of the temporalis muscle and risks damaging the temporal branch of the facial nerve. This frequently results in postoperative temporal hollows—permanent indentations on the side of the head—and "brow drop," where patients lose the ability to raise an eyebrow or wrinkle their forehead. Furthermore, large openings expose healthy brain tissue to unnecessary air and retraction, increasing the risk of minor cortical injuries.
The Mini-Temporal Technique
To address these issues, researchers at Huashan Hospital have refined a "mini-temporal" approach over the past eight years. This technique prioritizes minimal invasiveness through several key modifications:
- Incision Design: The incision is curved and kept entirely behind the hairline, avoiding the temporal line at the forehead to ensure better cosmetic results.
- The One-Layer Flap: Instead of the traditional multi-stage separation of skin, galea, and muscle, surgeons peel these layers back as a single "skin-galea-muscle" unit. This keeps the facial nerve branches safely protected within the tissue layers.
- Reduced Bone Window: The skull opening is significantly smaller than in a standard pterional approach and is positioned so that the temporalis muscle completely covers it upon closure.
- Microscopic Precision: To compensate for the smaller surgical window, surgeons utilize neuronavigation and adjust the angle of the surgical microscope to visualize structures "around the corners" of the opening.
Clinical Evaluation and Results
The efficacy of this approach was evaluated through eight years of clinical practice and detailed case reports of five patients with various pathologies, including meningioma, glioblastoma (WHO grade IV), chordoma, and astrocytoma.
Key results include:
- Surgical Efficiency: For experienced surgeons, the craniotomy procedure takes approximately 20 minutes, significantly faster than the classical approach.
- Resection Success: In all featured cases, complete tumor resection was confirmed via post-operative MRI, demonstrating that the smaller window does not compromise surgical goals.
- Complication Avoidance: No patients experienced temporal muscle atrophy or facial nerve injury. The preservation of the "envelope" (muscle and skin unit) ensured that blood supply and innervation remained intact.
- Cosmetic Integrity: Because the incision is hidden and the bone window is covered by muscle, the patients' craniofacial contours remained unchanged.
Discussion
The mini-temporal approach demonstrates that "less is more" in neurosurgical geometry. By tilting the patient and the microscope, a small opening provides sufficient line-of-sight to reach deep structures while avoiding the frontal sinuses, which reduces the risk of cerebrospinal fluid leaks and infections. This technique shifts the surgical focus from merely "saving the brain" to preserving the patient's quality of life by maintaining facial function and appearance.
Limitations
While effective for many temporal region surgeries, the mini-temporal approach is not a universal solution. It may be unsuitable for patients with severe brain swelling or massive hematomas where a small window provides insufficient room for brain expansion. Additionally, it is less ideal for surgeries requiring extensive drilling of the skull base or complex vascular procedures, such as certain aneurysms that require extensive dissection of the Sylvian fissure.
Conclusion
The mini-temporal approach offers a viable, minimally invasive alternative to the classical pterional craniotomy for resective surgeries in the temporal region. By reducing surgical time and preserving anatomical structures, it improves both functional and cosmetic outcomes for patients.
Summary updated