Location-Specific Advantages: Modified Application of the Arm’s Length Principle in a Knowledge-Based Economy

Xin PengWU 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

TL;DR

This research addresses the growing "tax gap" in the digital age, where multinational enterprises (MNEs) exploit Location-Specific Advantages (LSAs)—like cheap labor in India or massive consumer markets in China—while paying minimal local taxes. The author proposes a modified framework for the traditional Arm’s Length Principle (ALP) to ensure host countries receive a fairer share of global profits in an increasingly knowledge-based, "asset-light" economy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In traditional international tax law, profits are allocated based on where "functions" are performed and "risks" are assumed. However, modern MNEs often use a "central entrepreneur" model: they keep high-value functions (like R&D and branding) in a home country (e.g., Germany) while setting up "low-functionality" subsidiaries (like contract manufacturers in India or limited-risk distributors in China) in host countries.

The problem is that these host countries provide massive advantages—location savings (lower costs) and market premiums (higher demand)—that significantly boost the MNE's total profit. Under current rules, because the local subsidiary has "low functionality," it is only entitled to a tiny, routine profit. The "excess" profit generated by the location itself is funneled back to the home country. This creates a conflict of interest between emerging and developed nations and threatens to render the Arm’s Length Principle obsolete.

Methods

The author employs a multi-disciplinary approach combining legal analysis, economic theory, and policy critique:

  • Economic Theory of the Firm: The book utilizes the OLI (Ownership, Locational, Internalization) framework to analyze why MNEs choose specific locations and how they internalize local advantages.
  • Comparative Legal Analysis: It examines the diverging transfer pricing practices and domestic laws of the US, Germany, China, and India, alongside guidelines from the OECD and the United Nations.
  • Framework Proposal: The core contribution is a "New Framework" (Chapter 7) that suggests amending the ALP. Instead of abandoning the principle, the author proposes revised transfer pricing methods, such as "one-sided methods with adjustments" and a "revised residual profit split method," specifically designed to capture LSA value when local functionality is low.

Datasets

While this is primarily a legal and policy-oriented work, it draws on several key economic datasets to illustrate the shift toward a knowledge-based economy:

  • US Bureau of Labor Statistics: Used to compare hourly compensation costs in manufacturing across 30+ countries (Figure 1.1).
  • World Bank & UNCTAD Data: Used to track Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) net inflows, particularly within the BRICS nations (Figures 1.3 and 1.4).
  • OECD Knowledge-Based Capital (KBC) Reports: Used to demonstrate the decoupling of profit from physical assets, showing that US investment in "intangibles" (software, R&D, branding) has outpaced tangible capital since the mid-1990s (Figure 1.5).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LSAs as "Comparability Factors": The author argues that LSAs are not just "bonuses" but fundamental factors that should change how we compare transactions. If a company operates in a high-LSA environment, its "comparable" shouldn't be a generic firm in a different region.
  • The "Asset-Light" Paradox: Digitalization allows MNEs to generate massive sales in a country with almost zero physical footprint. The paper highlights that as "internet intensity" increases, MNEs tend to generate more foreign sales with fewer foreign assets.
  • Modification over Abandonment: While the OECD’s "Pillar One" suggests moving away from the Arm’s Length Principle for digital giants, this book argues that the ALP can be "saved" and made fairer by explicitly integrating LSA valuations into the math.
  • The "Flash-Title" Problem: The author points out extreme cases where local distributors only hold "flash-title" to goods (owning them for a split second during a transaction) to minimize their risk profile and, consequently, their taxable profit in that country.

Key Results

  • Quantifying the Shift: The research highlights that by 2001, US investment in Knowledge-Based Capital (KBC) was nearly 16% of adjusted GDP, almost double the investment in tangible assets.
  • The LSA Framework: The book provides a structured proposal for tax authorities to identify and price LSAs. It categorizes them into Location Savings (cost-side) and Market Premiums (revenue-side).
  • Scenario-Based Solutions: The author outlines specific scenarios for applying modified tax methods, providing a roadmap for host countries to strengthen their taxing rights without triggering immediate trade wars or massive double taxation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Weak International Consensus: The author acknowledges that current international guidance on LSAs is "as weak as it is illusive." Without a global agreement on how to quantify a "market premium," individual countries may implement aggressive, inconsistent rules.
  • Double Taxation Risks: If a host country (like India) claims a profit share based on LSAs, but the home country (like the US) doesn't recognize that adjustment, the MNE will be taxed twice on the same dollar.
  • Implementation Complexity: The proposed "revised residual profit split" requires high-quality data and sophisticated economic modeling, which may be difficult for tax administrations in some developing nations to execute effectively.

Summary updated

Abstract

Why this book? The term “location-specific advantages” (LSAs), including location savings and market premiums, is a novel concept originating from the transfer pricing practice in China and India. The term refers to the general features of a specific geographical location that may (positively) influence the profitability of a multinational enterprise (MNE). International consensus has been reached that LSAs are comparability factors and that local comparables can capture the value of LSAs. Following such rule, countries with LSAs (i.e. host countries) are entitled to tax only a very limited amount of MNEs’ business profits when only low-functionality nexuses exist locally. Modern MNEs increasingly use the principal/central entrepreneur structure and digitalization in their operating business models, strategically arrange low-functionality nexuses in host countries and therefore pay reduced or minimized taxes in those countries, while continuing to exploit their LSAs. This practice will eventually disrupt the allocation of global taxing rights to host countries vis-à-vis home countries (where the entrepreneur entity resides). Doubt therefore arises as to whether the arm’s length principle is still an appropriate or the preferred approach for global profit allocation. Notably, the OECD has proposed a profit allocation system that partially departs from the arm’s length principle under BEPS 2.0 Pillar One to address the tax challenges arising from digitalization. Against such background, this book focuses on how to amend the profit allocation rules based on the arm’s length principle when there is only a low-functionality nexus in the host country, acknowledging that the current guidance and practical rules in respect of applying the arm’s length principle have not sufficiently recognized the LSAs of host countries. It aims to strengthen the taxing rights of host countries and to restore confidence in the arm’s length principle in transfer pricing. This book is part of the WU Institute for Austrian and International Tax Law - Tax Law and Policy Series View other titles in the series Downloads Sample excerpt, including table of contents Author(s) Dr Claire (Xue) Peng is a transfer pricing practitioner based in London, currently with KPMG. In addition to this book, she has published various articles on transfer pricing and other international tax law topics. She was a research associate and lecturer at the WU Transfer Pricing Center, established at the Institute for Austrian and International Tax Law of the Vienna University of Economics and Business (WU), from 2016 to 2019. This book is based on her doctoral thesis, submitted in fulfilment of the requirements of the doctoral programme in business law at WU.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peng2021location,
  author = {Xin Peng},
  title = {{Location-Specific Advantages: Modified Application of the Arm’s Length Principle in a Knowledge-Based Economy}},
  booktitle = {WU},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.59403/20k2nsd},
}

Loading related content...

Figure