Limitation of life-sustaining treatments in Asian ICUs: theory versus practice

Lowell Ling, Andrew Li, Jason Phua, Utkalika Mallick, Motiul Islam, Tarequl Hamid, A. K. M. Shirazul Islam, Rabiul Halim, Md. Arifur Rahman Khan, Mohammad Asaduzzaman, Md Rezaul Karim, Nahim Sarwar, Shamsul Hoque Milon, Rashed Mahmud, A. K. M. Sirajul Islam Hirok, Ashraful Haque, Amina Sultana, Mir Atiqur Rahman Shajal, Farha Andalib, Rashedul Hasan, Khalid Mahmood Khan Nafees, Shah Sudhirchandra Dhansukhlal, Ning Li, Xiaowei Liu, Haiwei Yang, Ming Hou, Ying Li, Jian Zhang, Lifeng Huang, Wenxiong Li, Meili Duan, Taotao Liu, Wei He, Fangyu Ning, Xiaozhi Wang, Xiaoyan Zhou, Sun Yu, Xiang Xiang, Pan Liang, Feihu Zhou, Yaoli Wang, Jian Zhou, Tao Wang, Xuefei Yang, Yu Ma, Xuan Song, Haiying Wu, Chuanyun Qian, Lixin Zhou, Zuohang Xu, Kun Zhang, Zhenjie Hu, Xingsheng Lin, Songjing Shi, Xiaoguang Zhang, Rongguo Yu, Liqin Zhang, Yuan Yuan, Huiru Zhou, Xiandong Wang, Zhonghua Wang, Tiehe Qin, Xianqing Shi, Rui Li, Zhenyang He, Xiangrong Zuo, Quan Cao, Tao He, Yuanda Sui, Tiejun Wu, Ying Xu, Qin Gu, Weizheng Shuai, Hanyu Qin, Bin Du, Hong Qiao, Shuangling Li, Guiying Dong, Xiujuan Zhao, Fengxue Zhu, Junshi Wang, Lei Huang, Tianchang Wang, Hao Wang, Siqing Ma, Zhengping Yang, Yuan Gao, Ruoming Tan, Yun Xie, Ruilan Wang, Jia Jia, Bin Zang, Ling Lin, Yuwen Wu, Yunfu Wu, Penglin Ma, Yanfang Li, Wai Haung Yu, Rui GuoCritical 2025 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In the high-stakes environment of the Intensive Care Unit (ICU), physicians frequently encounter patients with no meaningful prospect of recovery. In such cases, the ethical and clinical decision to limit or withdraw life-sustaining treatments (LST) becomes paramount. While Western medical literature has extensively documented these practices, the landscape in Asia is significantly more complex, shaped by a unique confluence of legal, cultural, and socio-economic factors. This article examines a critical disconnect between the theoretical willingness of Asian ICU physicians to limit treatment and the actual clinical reality observed at the bedside.

The Problem: Perception vs. Reality

Previous survey-based research, such as the ACME study, suggested that Asian ICU physicians were generally open to the idea of limiting or withdrawing therapies for terminal patients. However, these findings were recently challenged by researchers who hypothesized that actual end-of-life practices might be far more conservative than self-reported attitudes suggest. This discrepancy is not merely academic; it has profound implications for clinical research. For instance, if physicians prematurely withdraw care, it could bias the results of studies evaluating prognostic tools like the quick Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (qSOFA) score in sepsis patients.

Methodology: Analyzing the MOSAICS II Cohort

To investigate this "theory versus practice" gap, authors conducted a secondary analysis of previously unpublished data from the MOSAICS II study. MOSAICS II is a large-scale, multi-center observational study focused on sepsis management across Asian ICUs.

The researchers analyzed a cohort of 4,826 patients to determine the exact frequency of withholding (deciding not to start a new treatment) and withdrawing (stopping an ongoing treatment) life-sustaining therapies. These real-world clinical actions were then compared against the historical benchmarks provided by the ACME survey, which captured physician attitudes.

Key Insights: The Massive Disconnect

The analysis revealed a stark contrast between what physicians say they would do and what they actually perform in practice.

1. Real-World Limitation is Rare

Despite the perceived openness to limiting care in surveys, the MOSAICS II data showed that only 5.9% of the total patient population had treatments withdrawn, and an identical 5.9% had treatments withheld. Even among the 1,271 patients who died within 28 days—a group where treatment limitation would be most expected—the rates remained surprisingly low: only 11.2% underwent treatment withdrawal and 10.8% had treatments withheld prior to death.

2. The Survey Contrast

These figures stand in sharp relief against the ACME survey data. In that study, 70.2% of Asian ICU physicians reported that they would "almost always or often" withhold treatments for patients with no chance of meaningful recovery, and 20.7% stated they would withdraw them. The clinical reality is several orders of magnitude lower than these theoretical responses.

Drivers of Conservative Practice

The authors suggest several reasons for this discrepancy, highlighting that medical decisions in Asia are rarely made in a vacuum:

  • Legal Fears: A primary driver is the fear of legal repercussions. Physicians may continue futile treatments to protect themselves from potential litigation, even when they believe the care is no longer beneficial to the patient.
  • Socio-Economic Pressures: In many Asian regions, including China, the financial burden on the family is a significant factor. Ironically, while financial constraints might lead to treatment cessation in some contexts, the pressure to "do everything" for a loved one can also lead to prolonged, futile interventions.
  • Cultural and Religious Context: End-of-life care is deeply influenced by local traditions and family dynamics, which often prioritize the preservation of life at all costs over the Western concept of individual autonomy.

Implications for Clinical Research

One significant takeaway from this study is the validation of previous sepsis research. Because the actual rate of therapy limitation in Asian ICUs is so low, the authors conclude that their earlier findings regarding the prognostic value of the qSOFA score were likely not skewed by premature treatment withdrawal. This provides greater confidence in the applicability of such scoring systems within the Asian context.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The findings from the MOSAICS II analysis underscore the necessity of moving beyond survey data to understand clinical behavior. There is a clear need for prospective data collection specifically designed to explore the nuanced cultural, religious, and financial factors that shape end-of-life decisions across different Asian regions. Understanding these local variations is essential for improving both the quality of end-of-life care and the integrity of critical care research in Asia.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{ling2025limitation,
  author = {Lowell Ling and Andrew Li and Jason Phua and Utkalika Mallick and Motiul Islam and Tarequl Hamid and A. K. M. Shirazul Islam and Rabiul Halim and Md. Arifur Rahman Khan and Mohammad Asaduzzaman and Md Rezaul Karim and Nahim Sarwar and Shamsul Hoque Milon and Rashed Mahmud and A. K. M. Sirajul Islam Hirok and Ashraful Haque and Amina Sultana and Mir Atiqur Rahman Shajal and Farha Andalib and Rashedul Hasan and Khalid Mahmood Khan Nafees and Shah Sudhirchandra Dhansukhlal and Ning Li and Xiaowei Liu and Haiwei Yang and Ming Hou and Ying Li and Jian Zhang and Lifeng Huang and Wenxiong Li and Meili Duan and Taotao Liu and Wei He and Fangyu Ning and Xiaozhi Wang and Xiaoyan Zhou and Sun Yu and Xiang Xiang and Pan Liang and Feihu Zhou and Yaoli Wang and Jian Zhou and Tao Wang and Xuefei Yang and Yu Ma and Xuan Song and Haiying Wu and Chuanyun Qian and Lixin Zhou and Zuohang Xu and Kun Zhang and Zhenjie Hu and Xingsheng Lin and Songjing Shi and Xiaoguang Zhang and Rongguo Yu and Liqin Zhang and Yuan Yuan and Huiru Zhou and Xiandong Wang and Zhonghua Wang and Tiehe Qin and Xianqing Shi and Rui Li and Zhenyang He and Xiangrong Zuo and Quan Cao and Tao He and Yuanda Sui and Tiejun Wu and Ying Xu and Qin Gu and Weizheng Shuai and Hanyu Qin and Bin Du and Hong Qiao and Shuangling Li and Guiying Dong and Xiujuan Zhao and Fengxue Zhu and Junshi Wang and Lei Huang and Tianchang Wang and Hao Wang and Siqing Ma and Zhengping Yang and Yuan Gao and Ruoming Tan and Yun Xie and Ruilan Wang and Jia Jia and Bin Zang and Jun Wang and Ling Lin and Yuwen Wu and Yunfu Wu and Penglin Ma and Yanfang Li and Wai Haung Yu and Rui Guo},
  title = {{Limitation of life-sustaining treatments in Asian ICUs: theory versus practice}},
  booktitle = {Critical},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s13054-024-05241-2},
}
Figure