Learning Artificial Intelligence Through Open Educational Resources

Frédéric Alexandre, Marie-Hélène Comte, Aurélie Lagarrigue, Thierry ViévillePalgrave 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This paper discusses the development and impact of the Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) "Artificial Intelligence with Intelligence (IAI)." The initiative aims to foster a culture of AI understanding and ethical participation in societal debates. By addressing the rationale behind citizen training in AI, the authors emphasize the importance of understanding algorithmic decision-making and the transformative nature of AI across various domains. The paper outlines three perspectives on AI in education: as an adaptive learning tool, a scientific instrument for studying human learning, and a subject for critical examination.

Introduction: Demystifying the Black Box

As Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies become ubiquitous, a significant gap has emerged between the complexity of these systems and the public's ability to understand or critique them. AI is frequently perceived as a "black box," leading to a dichotomy of blind trust or unfounded fear. To address this, there is an urgent need for "citizen education"—equipping non-experts, particularly educators and students, with the conceptual tools to understand algorithmic decision-making, data ethics, and the shifting boundary between human and machine intelligence.

A Tripartite Framework for AI in Education

The integration of AI into educational contexts can be viewed through three parallel perspectives:

  1. Adaptive Learning Tools: Algorithms analyze student learning analytics—such as clicks, quiz results, and sensor data—to modify task difficulty in real-time. This approach is grounded in Vygotsky’s "Zone of Proximal Development" (ZPD), ensuring that educational tasks remain challenging yet achievable, preventing both boredom and discouragement.
  2. Computational Education Science: AI serves as a formalization tool to model human learning. By treating learning as a series of information-processing mechanisms, researchers utilize reinforcement learning models to gain deeper insights into how humans acquire knowledge.
  3. "Unplugged" Pedagogy: This novel approach teaches AI concepts without requiring a computer. By using physical objects to simulate algorithms, learners can grasp the underlying logic of AI before dealing with technical syntax or hardware constraints.

Case Study: The IAI MOOC and Unplugged Learning

The primary vehicle for this educational mission is the MOOC Artificial Intelligence with Intelligence (IAI). Designed for non-technical audiences, the course bridges the gap between technical research and classroom practice.

A standout feature of this curriculum is the use of "unplugged" tools. For instance, a minimalist physical machine using blue and red balls is employed to simulate reinforcement learning. This allows students to visualize how an agent "learns" from rewards and penalties in a tangible way.

A physical "machine" using colored balls to simulate reinforcement learning algorithms, allowing students to grasp AI logic without a computer.

Key Insights and Ethical Considerations

The research highlights several transformative aspects of AI in the classroom:

  • The Non-Judging Machine: AI tutors do not "judge" students. This lack of social pressure can reduce anxiety and maintain engagement when learners make mistakes.
  • The Chain of Responsibility: Unlike traditional machines, AI outcomes are heavily dependent on the data provided. This creates a complex "chain of responsibility" involving designers, installers, and users.
  • Mechanizable Intelligence: By delegating "mechanizable" tasks to AI, humans can focus on higher-level, creative, and socially significant goals.

Challenges and Future Directions

Despite the potential benefits, the authors identify critical risks:

  • Data Misuse and Privacy: Pervasive tracking of learners could lead to new forms of categorization and discrimination.
  • Staffing Concerns: AI should not be used as a justification for reducing school staff. Instead, it should empower teachers to provide more personalized attention to students in need.
  • Digital Inequality: There is a persistent danger that AI tools could exacerbate existing inequalities due to varying levels of digital literacy.

Future work advocates for a transdisciplinary approach, merging digital sciences with cognitive neuroscience to further explore "computational education science." Continued development of "unplugged" tools remains essential to keep pace with the rapid evolution of AI technologies and ensure inclusive access to AI literacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract This chapter discusses the creation and impact of a Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) titled ‘Artificial Intelligence with Intelligence (IAI)’ aimed at fostering a culture of AI understanding and participation in ethical debates. The chapter first addresses the rationale behind developing the MOOC and the importance of citizen training in AI, particularly concerning ethical considerations surrounding algorithmic decision-making. This chapter also emphasises the need to reevaluate human intelligence in the broader context of AI advancements and probes the transformative nature of AI across various domains of life. Three perspectives are considered concerning the integration of AI in education: adapting the learning experience, using AI as a scientific tool for studying human learning, and critically examining its problems. Citizen education is crucial to understanding the scientific and technical elements of AI, especially in the context of algorithmic decision-making ethics. The chapter's focus on AI and citizen education is key. It emphasises the need for critical thinking to understand how AI technologies affect daily life. The chapter advocates AI training to help people understand how AI works and generate informed opinions about its potential and limitations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alexandre2024learning,
  author = {Frédéric Alexandre and Marie-Hélène Comte and Aurélie Lagarrigue and Thierry Viéville},
  title = {{Learning Artificial Intelligence Through Open Educational Resources}},
  booktitle = {Palgrave},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-55272-4\_3},
}
Figure