Insanity Defenses
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
Many infamous cases create the impression that political assassins can get off just by pleading insanity. That impression, however, is inaccurate, because many insanity pleas are not successful. Still, successful insanity defenses are often controversial. On the one hand, when a defendant is known to have intentionally caused a death, it strikes many as unjust to find that person not guilty. On the other hand, it strikes many as unfair to find someone guilty of committing an offense for which he was not morally responsible. This chapter examines whether insanity is medical or legal; the M'Naghten Rule; irresistible impulse and loss of control; the model penal code; insanity as irrationality; and arguments for and against an insanity defense.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sinnottarmstrong2011insanity,
author = {Walter Sinnott-Armstrong and Ken Levy},
title = {{Insanity Defenses}},
booktitle = {Oxford},
year = {2011},
doi = {10.1093/oxfordhb/9780195314854.003.0012},
}Loading related content...