Grand Challenges in Neurotechnology and System Neuroergonomics

Stephen Fairclough, Fabien LotteFrontiers in Neuroergonomics 2020 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract This perspective piece outlines a strategic roadmap for transitioning neurotechnology from controlled laboratory environments into everyday real-world applications. By identifying three "Grand Challenges"—signal robustness, user experience, and systems integration—the authors define the emerging field of Systems Neuroergonomics, bridging the gap between engineering, neuroscience, and human factors.

Introduction

Neuroergonomics aims to study the human brain in action during real-world tasks. However, most current neurotechnologies, such as Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs), remain "demonstrator systems" that function reliably only in sterile, controlled lab settings. In the "wild" of everyday life, these systems face a significant reliability gap. Brain signals are inherently weak and easily obscured by physiological noise (muscle movements, eye blinks) and environmental interference. This paper proposes a conceptual framework to overcome these hurdles and make neuroergonomics a practical reality for work and leisure.

The Three Pillars of Systems Neuroergonomics

To bridge the gap between lab prototypes and real-world utility, the authors propose three distinct levels of challenge that must be addressed simultaneously.

Figure 1: The three grand challenges mapping the interaction between user, technology, and the broader system.

Grand Challenge 1: Robustness and Reliability (Machine Level)

The primary technical bottleneck is the low Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) of current sensors. Achieving robustness requires moving beyond simple filters toward sophisticated computational modeling. Designers must create detailed models of noise and artifacts to "clean" signals effectively in real-time.

Figure 2: Conceptual representation of signal classification and adaptive machine learning required for robust neurotechnology.

Furthermore, the use of Adaptive Machine Learning is essential. Because brain signals are "non-stationary"—meaning they change throughout the day or vary significantly between individuals—algorithms must be able to update their parameters dynamically to maintain accuracy.

Grand Challenge 2: User Experience and Evaluation (User Level)

A system may be technically accurate but fail if it is uncomfortable, stigmatizing, or if the user feels a loss of personal agency. The field must adopt Participatory Design, involving end-users early in the development process to ensure technologies are usable and acceptable. There is also a critical need for longitudinal studies to understand how user trust and behavior evolve over months or years of sustained use.

Grand Challenge 3: The Systems Perspective (Overall Level)

Neurotechnology does not operate in a vacuum; it exists within a "sociotechnical hierarchy" of organizational protocols, legal regulations, and ethical standards. This level incorporates the Darkness Principle from systems engineering, which posits that no complex system can be known completely. Designers must therefore account for unanticipated human-machine interactions and the risks associated with "implicit interaction," where systems trigger functions automatically based on detected brain states without explicit user confirmation.

Methodological Innovations

The paper advocates for several key shifts in how neuroergonomic research is conducted:

  • Hybrid BCIs: Combining multiple data streams—such as EEG (electrical activity), fNIRS (blood oxygenation), and heart rate (ECG)—to create a more holistic and robust picture of the user's cognitive state.
  • Large-Scale Databases: The authors call for the creation and sharing of massive datasets recorded in operational environments (e.g., cockpits, hospitals) to train the next generation of robust algorithms.

Ethical Considerations and Future Work

As neurotechnology requires "privileged access" to sensitive neural data, standards for governance and data privacy must evolve alongside the technology. Future work must focus on "future-proofing" prototypes against the constraints of real-world environments and investigating the long-term effects of neurofeedback on brain plasticity and psychology. By addressing these three grand challenges, the field can move toward a future where neurotechnology seamlessly enhances human performance and well-being.

Summary updated

Abstract

International audience
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fairclough2020grand,
  author = {Stephen Fairclough and Fabien Lotte},
  title = {{Grand Challenges in Neurotechnology and System Neuroergonomics}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroergonomics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fnrgo.2020.602504},
}
Figure