Game Theory as Psychological Investigation

Ayan PaulInTech 2013 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract: Over the course of history, mathematics and science have become increasingly entangled. This has been especially true in the physical sciences, where mathematical derivations have resulted in subsequent experimental pursuits. While the social sciences have relied on mathematical descriptions in recent generations, it was not until the more general employment of game theory that mathematical modeling became a directive tool for subsequent evaluation, similar to its role in high-energy physics. This paper explores how game theory forced new avenues of investigation upon the social sciences and how these investigations, in turn, forced new considerations on the practice of game theory modeling. This "boot-strapping" dynamic represents a novel turn in the relationship between the two disciplines, bringing them into parallel alignment with the long-standing relationship between physical science and mathematics.

Introduction: The Directive Power of Mathematics

Historically, the social sciences were primarily descriptive, while the physical sciences used mathematics as a directive tool to predict and discover new phenomena. A classic example is Paul Dirac’s mathematical prediction of the positron before its physical discovery. For a long time, social science lacked this predictive, directive capacity. The emergence of game theory changed this landscape by providing a rigid mathematical framework for decision-making that could be tested against actual human behavior.

The Prisoner’s Dilemma and the Limits of Rationality

A central challenge in classical game theory is the gap between "pure" mathematical models—which assume humans are perfectly rational, self-interested actors—and the actual behavior of human beings. This tension is most famously illustrated in the Prisoner’s Dilemma (PD).

A classic payoff matrix illustrating the Prisoner's Dilemma, where individual rational choices (Defect) lead to a sub-optimal collective outcome (5,5) compared to mutual cooperation (2,2).

In the matrix shown above, if the numbers represent costs (such as years in prison), the dominant strategy for an individual is to defect. If both players follow this "rational" self-interest, they end up in Quadrant I with a cost of 5 each. However, if they both cooperated (Quadrant IV), they would only face a cost of 2. When experimental subjects frequently choose to cooperate despite the mathematical pressure to defect, it suggests that the classical model of self-interest is incomplete.

The "Boot-Strapping" Dynamic

The paper argues that this discrepancy drives scientific progress through a "boot-strapping" dynamic. Game theory forced social scientists to investigate why humans deviate from predicted paths, leading to the discovery of "social preferences" like honor, altruism, and reputation. These psychological findings, in turn, forced mathematicians to revise their models to include weighted preferences for personal dignity or the well-being of others.

This process has evolved decision theory from the foundational work of von Neumann and Morgenstern into a more nuanced "preference theory." It acknowledges that human preferences are not always transitive or linear; external shocks or moral commitments can completely reorder a person's values, making previously low-priority items leapfrog over others.

Key Insights and Results

  • The Poverty of Self-Interest: Assuming humans only care about personal gain is a "prescriptive poverty." Integrating moral and social values into formal models resolves many of the "paradoxes" of cooperation.
  • Pareto Optimality vs. Nash Equilibrium: The paper advocates for moving toward Pareto optimality—where no one can be made better off without making someone else worse off—as a more robust goal for social coordination than the often sub-optimal Nash equilibrium.
  • Quantifying the Intangible: Game theory has transitioned from an esoteric mathematical study into a vital tool for "excavating" the human mind, demonstrating that even subjective moral commitments can be heuristically quantified.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While game theory has successfully moved the social sciences toward a directive alignment with the physical sciences, the ambition to render all human activity transparent remains unfulfilled. Human nature and the environment are in constant evolutionary flux, making any model inherently incomplete. Future work must continue to bridge the gap between intuitive, fast "System 1" thinking and the formal, deliberative "System 2" models to better understand how humans frame complex problems in the real world.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over the course of history mathematics and science have become increasingly entangled with one another. This has been especially true in the physical science wherein mathematical derivations have resulted in subsequent experimental pursuits. While the social sciences have relied on mathematical descriptions in recent generations it was not until the more general employment of game theory that mathematical modeling became itself a directive tool for subsequent evaluation as it had so become in the physical sciences, most prominently perhaps in high energy physics. This chapter shows how game theory forced upon the social sciences new avenues of investigation. It also shows that once those investigations were fully underway they in turn forced new considerations on the practice of game theory modeling. This boot-strapping dynamic between mathematical game theory and social science represents a novel turn in the relationship between the two disciplines bringing their relationship more into parallel alignment with what has long existed between physical science and mathematics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{paul2013game,
  author = {Ayan Paul},
  title = {{Game Theory as Psychological Investigation}},
  booktitle = {InTech},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5772/53932},
}
Figure