Food Reservoir forEscherichia coliCausing Urinary Tract Infections

Maria Giufrè, Caterina Graziani, Marisa Accogli, Marina CerquettiEmerging 2010 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

The potential for retail meat to serve as a reservoir for Escherichia coli strains causing extraintestinal infections, such as urinary tract infections (UTIs), is a subject of ongoing scientific debate. Traditionally, UTIs were thought to arise primarily from an individual's own intestinal flora. However, recent research has investigated the hypothesis that specific lineages of Extraintestinal Pathogenic E. coli (ExPEC) may be foodborne, particularly originating from retail poultry. This paper examines the findings of a study by Vincent et al., which compared E. coli isolates from human UTIs, retail meat, and ready-to-eat foods, and the subsequent academic discourse regarding the strength of its conclusions.

Methodology

To investigate the genetic relationship between E. coli from different sources, researchers employed several molecular typing techniques with varying levels of resolution:

  • Multilocus Sequence Typing (MLST): Categorizes isolates into broad lineages based on conserved housekeeping genes.
  • MLVA and ERIC-2: Higher-resolution methods that analyze repetitive DNA patterns to identify clonal groups.
  • Pulsed-Field Gel Electrophoresis (PFGE): Often considered the forensic "gold standard," this method determines if isolates are truly indistinguishable by comparing whole-genome banding patterns.

The study analyzed a total of 844 E. coli isolates collected over three years from two Canadian provinces, sourced from human UTIs, retail meat (chicken and pork), and restaurant/ready-to-eat foods.

Results and Discussion

The analysis revealed a high degree of genetic heterogeneity among the isolates. Only 8.6% (73/844) of the isolates belonged to clonal groups that included members from more than one source. Within the retail meat category, 2.9% (12/417) of isolates shared MLVA, ERIC-2, and MLST patterns with human UTI isolates.

A critical point of contention is the level of identity required to suggest a transmission route. Critics argue that the low percentage of overlapping clonal groups suggests that meat and human UTI populations are largely distinct. Furthermore, only a single meat isolate (strain EC01DT06–1737–01) was found to be indistinguishable from a human isolate (strain MSHS 161) by the high-resolution PFGE method.

Conversely, proponents of the foodborne hypothesis argue that in such a diverse bacterial population, finding even one perfect match across different geographical locations and timeframes is statistically significant and represents a "smoking gun." A particularly noteworthy finding was the identification of an ST131 isolate of avian origin. ST131 is a globally disseminated, multi-drug resistant lineage frequently associated with human extraintestinal disease, suggesting a potential bridge between animal reservoirs and human infection.

Conclusion

While the study provides evidence of a partial overlap between E. coli isolates from retail meat and human UTIs, the extent to which food transmission contributes to community-acquired UTIs remains a topic of debate. The findings highlight the importance of further research using larger sample sizes and even higher-resolution techniques, such as Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS), to definitively map transmission pathways from food reservoirs to human clinical cases.

Summary updated

Abstract

To the Editor: We read with interest the article by Vincent et al. that compared Escherichia coli isolates from 3 sources (human urinary tract infections [UTIs], retail meat, and restaurant/ready-to-eat foods) by multiple molecular typing methods (1). This study has to be considered in the context of the larger debate about the possible animal origin of E. coli isolates that cause extraintestinal infections in humans (2–5), and the same authors (Vincent et al.) have declared, in the introduction, that their efforts were directed toward investigating the hypothesis that retail chicken is the main reservoir for extraintestinal E. coli. We strongly appreciate the amount of the experimental data and some interesting findings, but we are not totally convinced of the authors’ conclusions, particularly the assumption that the study strongly supports the preliminary hypothesis. First, the observation that only a low proportion (73/844, 8.6%) of the E. coli isolates analyzed belonged to clonal groups (defined as >2 E. coli isolates that had indistinguishable multilocus variable number tandem repeats and enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus 2 patterns), including members from >1 source, suggests an overall high degree of genetic heterogeneity among isolates from different sources. Second, looking at the single isolates within clonal groups reported in, twelve (2.9%) of the 417 isolates from retail meat shared multilocus variable number tandem repeats, enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus 2, and multilocus sequence types with some human UTI isolates; however, only 1 isolate (strain EC01DT06–1737–01) was also found to be indistinguishable from a human isolate (strain MSHS 161) by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis , indicating that identical genotypes (between isolates from retail meat and human infections) were observed only once. Although we agree that the finding of a partial overlap between multilocus sequence types of isolates from retail meat and from human UTI isolates is noteworthy (especially recovery of an ST131 isolate of avian origin), the emphasis posed for the role of food transmission in the dissemination of the E. coli strains that cause community-acquired UTIs, in our opinion, does not seem strongly supported by the experimental data. Nevertheless, the topic is relevant, and we would highlight the importance of further research on this issue.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{giufre2010food,
  author = {Maria Giufrè and Caterina Graziani and Marisa Accogli and Marina Cerquetti},
  title = {{Food Reservoir for<i>Escherichia coli</i>Causing Urinary Tract Infections}},
  booktitle = {Emerging},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.3201/eid1606.100158},
}
Figure