Flow of Information Underlying a Tactile Decision in Mice

Nuo Li, Zengcai V. Guo, Tsai‐Wen Chen, Karel SvobodaResearch 2016 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Motor planning allows us to conceive, plan, and initiate skilled motor behaviors. Motor planning involves activity distributed widely across the cortex. How this activity dynamically comes together to guide movement remains an unsolved problem. We study motor planning in mice performing a tactile decision behavior. Head-fixed mice discriminate object locations with their whiskers and report their choice by directional licking ("lick left"/"lick right"). A short-term memory component separates tactile "sensation" and "action" into distinct epochs. Using loss-of-function experiments, cell-type specific electrophysiology, and cellular imaging, we delineate when and how activity in specific brain areas and cell types drives motor planning in mice. Our results suggest that information flows serially from sensory to motor areas during motor planning. The motor cortex circuit maintains the motor plan during short-term memory and translates the motor plan into motor commands that drive the upcoming directional licking.

The Challenge of Motor Planning

Motor planning is the cognitive "bridge" between sensing the world and taking action. While we know that activity is distributed across the cortex during this process, understanding how these signals dynamically converge to guide movement has remained an unsolved problem in neuroscience. The challenge lies in the timing: there is often a delay between a sensation (like feeling an object) and the subsequent action (like moving toward it). This study investigates the neural circuitry that sustains a "motor plan" during that delay, identifying which brain regions are responsible for sensation versus planning and how specific cell types convert a mental plan into a physical command.

Experimental Approach

The researchers employed a sophisticated toolkit to dissect the mouse brain's activity. Head-fixed mice were trained to use their whiskers to determine the position of a pole (anterior or posterior). They then had to wait through a 1.3-second "delay epoch" before licking a left or right port to report their choice.

Experimental setup and cortex-wide optogenetic mapping. (a) Behavioral task. (b) Trial timeline. (c) Mapping of cortical areas required during Sample and Delay epochs.

To map the functional roles of different brain regions, the team used cortex-wide optogenetic mapping. By silencing 55 different cortical locations at specific times (e.g., during sensation vs. during planning), they could determine which areas were essential for each phase of the task. This was complemented by single-neuron electrophysiology in the primary somatosensory cortex (vS1) and the anterior lateral motor cortex (ALM).

Mapping the Flow of Information

The results revealed a serial relay of information across the cortex. The vS1 (barrel cortex) was found to be required only during the "sample" phase to collect sensory data. Once the sensory information is processed, the "plan" is handed off to the ALM. Inactivating the ALM during the delay period—after the mouse had already felt the pole—caused the mouse to fail. This demonstrates that the ALM acts as a critical memory buffer, essential for maintaining the motor plan in short-term memory.

Neural Dynamics of the Motor Plan

Electrophysiological recordings in the ALM showed that over 70% of neurons significantly distinguished between "lick left" and "lick right" trials. While individual neurons showed varied activity patterns, the population-level selectivity ramped up steadily throughout the delay, peaking exactly when the movement was triggered.

Single-neuron activity and population selectivity in the ALM. Selectivity for the upcoming lick direction ramps up during the delay period (between -1.7s and 0s).

The study also highlighted a transformation within the ALM circuit. Intratelencephalic (IT) neurons showed "mixed" activity representing an abstract plan. In contrast, Pyramidal Tract (PT) neurons—the output cells sending commands to the brainstem—showed late-stage activity specifically tuned for the upcoming movement. Remarkably, by weakly stimulating PT neurons during the planning phase, researchers could "write" a motor plan into the brain, biasing the mouse's choice.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work delineates a clear cortical pathway from sensation to action. However, several questions remain. The exact circuit mechanism that allows the ALM to maintain a stable plan despite fluctuating individual neuron activity is still unknown. Furthermore, the role of subcortical structures like the basal ganglia and motor thalamus in interacting with the ALM during planning requires further investigation. Future research will also need to explore whether these principles of serial information flow and motor planning hold for more complex, non-binary motor sequences.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motor planning allows us to conceive, plan, and initiate skilled motor behaviors. Motor planning involves activity distributed widely across the cortex. How this activity dynamically comes together to guide movement remains an unsolved problem. We study motor planning in mice performing a tactile decision behavior. Head-fixed mice discriminate object locations with their whiskers and report their choice by directional licking ("lick left"/"lick right"). A short-term memory component separates tactile "sensation" and "action" into distinct epochs. Using loss-of-function experiments, cell-type specific electrophysiology, and cellular imaging, we delineate when and how activity in specific brain areas and cell types drives motor planning in mice. Our results suggest that information flows serially from sensory to motor areas during motor planning. The motor cortex circuit maintains the motor plan during short-term memory and translates the motor plan into motor commands that drive the upcoming directional licking.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2016flow,
  author = {Nuo Li and Zengcai V. Guo and Tsai‐Wen Chen and Karel Svoboda},
  title = {{Flow of Information Underlying a Tactile Decision in Mice}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-28802-4\_3},
}
Figure