Experimental strategies for imaging bioparticles with femtosecond hard X-ray pulses. Corrigendum

Benedikt J. Daurer, Kenta Okamoto, Johan Bielecki, Filipe R. N. C. Maia, Kerstin Mühlig, M. Seibert, Max F. Hantke, Carl Nettelblad, W. Henry Benner, Martin Svenda, Nicuşor Tı̂mneanu, Tomas Ekeberg, N. Duane Loh, Alberto Pietrini, Alessandro Zani, Asawari D. Rath, Daniel Westphal, Richard A. Kirian, Salah Awel, Max O. Wiedorn, Gijs van der Schot, Gunilla Carlsson, Dirk Hasse, Jonas A. Sellberg, Anton Barty, Jakob Andreasson, Sébastien Boutet, Garth J. Williams, Jason E. Koglin, Inger Andersson, János Hajdu, Daniel S. D. LarssonIUCrJ 2019 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This document provides formal corrections to the article by Daurer et al. [IUCrJ (2017). 4, 251–262]. It rectifies mathematical errors in the fundamental scattering equations and updates photon intensity values in the results table to ensure the accuracy of the experimental model for bioparticle imaging.

Introduction: Addressing Errors in XFEL Imaging Models

In the original 2017 study, Daurer et al. investigated experimental strategies for "diffraction before destruction." This technique utilizes femtosecond X-ray pulses from X-ray Free-Electron Lasers (XFELs) to capture diffraction patterns from biological samples, such as viruses, before radiation damage occurs.

Schematic of the XFEL experimental setup for bioparticle imaging, illustrating the interaction between the X-ray beam and the sample aerosol.

Post-publication review revealed critical mathematical errors in the equations describing scattering intensity and the scattering vector. This corrigendum serves to correct these foundational formulas, which are essential for researchers performing X-ray diffraction simulations or analyzing experimental data.

Mathematical Corrections

The corrections focus on the mathematical framework used to model how X-rays interact with spherical bioparticles. In X-ray imaging, small constants (like a factor of 2 or 3) in an equation can lead to significant discrepancies when scaling experimental data to theoretical models. Correcting these ensures the physical model aligns with the observed diffraction physics.

Scattering Intensity

The formula for scattering intensity ($I_i$) in Equation (1) was corrected by removing an erroneous denominator of ‘3’. The updated equation is:

$$I_i = I^0 QE \left( \frac{\pi^2 d^3 |\Delta n| \Delta x}{D \lambda^2} \right)^2 \left| \frac{\sin(s_i) - s_i \cos(s_i)}{s_i^3} \right|^2$$

Scattering Parameter

The definition of the scattering parameter ($s_i$) in Equation (2) was corrected by removing an extra factor of ‘2’. The updated definition is:

$$s_i = \pi d |q_i|$$

These parameters are vital for calculating how X-rays interact with a spherical particle (like a virus) and how that interaction translates into the recorded diffraction pattern.

Data Integrity and Updated Results

Beyond the mathematical formulas, this corrigendum updates specific values in Table 1, which summarizes photon intensity metrics.

  • Maximum Photon Intensity: The value in the final row was revised downward from 0.41 to 0.25.
  • Standard Deviation: The associated standard deviation was corrected from 0.05 to 0.03.

These revisions indicate that the original reported intensities were slightly overestimated. Such distinctions are critical for researchers calculating signal-to-noise ratios or determining detector requirements for future experiments.

Conclusion

This corrigendum ensures that the physical models used in bioparticle imaging align correctly with observed diffraction physics. It is strictly a formal amendment to the existing scientific record to maintain the accuracy of the published methodology. Researchers are advised to use these updated equations and values for any subsequent work involving Omono River virus (OmRV) imaging or similar diffraction studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Corrections to the article by Daurer et al. [ IUCrJ (2017). 4 , 251–262] are given.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{daurer2019experimental,
  author = {Benedikt J. Daurer and Kenta Okamoto and Johan Bielecki and Filipe R. N. C. Maia and Kerstin Mühlig and M. Seibert and Max F. Hantke and Carl Nettelblad and W. Henry Benner and Martin Svenda and Nicuşor Tı̂mneanu and Tomas Ekeberg and N. Duane Loh and Alberto Pietrini and Alessandro Zani and Asawari D. Rath and Daniel Westphal and Richard A. Kirian and Salah Awel and Max O. Wiedorn and Gijs van der Schot and Gunilla Carlsson and Dirk Hasse and Jonas A. Sellberg and Anton Barty and Jakob Andreasson and Sébastien Boutet and Garth J. Williams and Jason E. Koglin and Inger Andersson and János Hajdu and Daniel S. D. Larsson},
  title = {{Experimental strategies for imaging bioparticles with femtosecond hard X-ray pulses. Corrigendum}},
  booktitle = {IUCrJ},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1107/s2052252519004317},
}
Figure