Erratum: Genome analysis of the platypus reveals unique signatures of evolution

Wesley C. Warren, LaDeana W. Hillier, Jennifer A. Marshall Graves, Ewan Birney, Chris P. Ponting, Frank Grützner, Katherine Belov, Webb Miller, Laura Clarke, Asif Chinwalla, Shiaw-Pyng Yang, Andreas Heger, Devin P. Locke, Pat Miethke, Paul D. Waters, Frédéric Veyrunes, Lucinda A. Fulton, Bob Fulton, Tina Graves, John Wallis, Xosé S. Puente, Carlos López-Otı́n, Gonzalo R. Ordóñez, Evan E. Eichler, Lin Chen, Ze Cheng, Janine E. Deakin, Amber E. Alsop, Katherine Thompson, Patrick Kirby, Anthony T. Papenfuss, Matthew J. Wakefield, Tsviya Olender, Doron Lancet, Gavin Huttley, Arian F. A. Smit, Andrew J. Pask, Peter Temple‐Smith, Mark A. Batzer, Jerilyn A. Walker, Miriam K. Konkel, Robert S. Harris, Camilla M. Whittington, Emily Wong, Neil J. Gemmell, Emmanuel Buschiazzo, Iris M. Vargas Jentzsch, Angelika Merkel, Juergen Schmitz, Anja Zemann, Gennady Churakov, Jan Ole Kriegs, Juergen Brosius, Elizabeth P. Murchison, Ravi Sachidanandam, Carly Smith, Gregory J. Hannon, Enkhjargal Tsend‐Ayush, Daniel A. McMillan, Rosalind Attenborough, Willem Rens, Malcolm Ferguson-Smith, Christophe Lefèvre, Julie A. Sharp, Kevin R. Nicholas, David A. Ray, Michael Kube, Richard Reinhardt, Thomas H. Pringle, James Taylor, Russell C. Jones, Brett Nixon, Jean-Louis Dacheux, Hitoshi Niwa, Yoko Sekita, Xiaoqiu Huang, Alexander Stark, Pouya Kheradpour, Manolis Kellis, Paul Flicek, Yuan Chen, Caleb Webber, Ross C. Hardison, Joanne O. Nelson, Kym Hallsworth-Pepin, Kim D. Delehaunty, Chris Markovic, Pat Minx, Yucheng Feng, Colin Kremitzki, Makedonka Mitreva, Jarret Glasscock, Todd Wylie, P. Wohldmann, Prathapan Thiru, Michael N. Nhan, Craig Pohl, Scott M. Smith, Shunfeng Hou, Mikhail NefedovNature 2008 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This document details formal corrections and amendments published in the journal Nature (Volume 455, September 2008) regarding two high-impact research papers. The updates include a corrigendum for the landmark 2008 platypus genome assembly and an erratum concerning the molecular mechanisms of breast cancer metastasis. These corrections serve to maintain the integrity of the scientific record by addressing an attribution gap in large-scale genomic collaboration and a technical sequence error in molecular signaling data.

Introduction

The maintenance of an accurate scientific record is a cornerstone of research integrity. In the era of "Big Science," characterized by massive datasets and multi-institutional collaborations, the complexity of data management and author attribution can occasionally lead to administrative or technical oversights. This article reviews the formal amendments to two significant studies: "Genome analysis of the platypus reveals unique signatures of evolution" (Nature 453, 175–183; 2008) and "Tumour invasion and metastasis initiated by microRNA-10b in breast cancer" (Nature 449, 682–688; 2007).

Attribution in Large-Scale Genomics

The 2008 analysis of the platypus genome was a monumental effort involving over 100 authors from dozens of global institutions. Due to the administrative complexity of such a large-scale project, two contributors—Mikhail Nefedov and Pieter J. de Jong—were inadvertently omitted from the original author list.

The corrigendum formally restores credit to these individuals, highlighting a common challenge in modern genomics: ensuring that every researcher involved in the generation and analysis of massive datasets is properly recognized. While this change does not alter the genomic findings of the study, it is essential for the professional record of the contributors involved.

Technical Precision in Molecular Oncology

The second amendment addresses a technical error in a 2007 study regarding the role of microRNA-10b in breast cancer progression. The original paper identified specific "E-box" motifs—DNA response elements that serve as binding sites for transcription factors—within the promoter architecture of the HOXD10 gene.

In Figure 4e of the original publication, the sequences for two specific E-boxes were swapped in the legend. The corrected data is as follows:

  • E-box 1: Located at -313 bp (proximal to the stem-loop), the actual sequence is CACTTG (previously mislabeled as CACCTG).
  • E-box 2: Located at -2,422 bp (distal), the actual sequence is CACCTG (previously mislabeled as CACTTG).

Significance of the Correction

In the context of gene regulation, even a single nucleotide difference in an E-box can significantly alter the binding affinity of transcription factors such as Twist or Myc. For researchers attempting to replicate these findings or perform site-directed mutagenesis and Chromatin Immunoprecipitation (ChIP) assays, this distinction is critical. Correcting the spatial context (proximal vs. distal) and the specific hexamer sequences ensures that future studies on the HOXD10 promoter or microRNA-10b targets are based on accurate molecular templates.

Conclusion

These amendments do not challenge the fundamental scientific conclusions of the original papers. The platypus genome remains a landmark in evolutionary biology, and the role of microRNA-10b remains a key insight into breast cancer metastasis. However, these corrections underscore the necessity of precision in both administrative attribution and technical data presentation. Future researchers referencing these studies must incorporate these updates to ensure the accuracy of their own experimental designs and citations.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{warren2008erratum,
  author = {Wesley C. Warren and LaDeana W. Hillier and Jennifer A. Marshall Graves and Ewan Birney and Chris P. Ponting and Frank Grützner and Katherine Belov and Webb Miller and Laura Clarke and Asif Chinwalla and Shiaw-Pyng Yang and Andreas Heger and Devin P. Locke and Pat Miethke and Paul D. Waters and Frédéric Veyrunes and Lucinda A. Fulton and Bob Fulton and Tina Graves and John Wallis and Xosé S. Puente and Carlos López-Otı́n and Gonzalo R. Ordóñez and Evan E. Eichler and Lin Chen and Ze Cheng and Janine E. Deakin and Amber E. Alsop and Katherine Thompson and Patrick Kirby and Anthony T. Papenfuss and Matthew J. Wakefield and Tsviya Olender and Doron Lancet and Gavin Huttley and Arian F. A. Smit and Andrew J. Pask and Peter Temple‐Smith and Mark A. Batzer and Jerilyn A. Walker and Miriam K. Konkel and Robert S. Harris and Camilla M. Whittington and Emily Wong and Neil J. Gemmell and Emmanuel Buschiazzo and Iris M. Vargas Jentzsch and Angelika Merkel and Juergen Schmitz and Anja Zemann and Gennady Churakov and Jan Ole Kriegs and Juergen Brosius and Elizabeth P. Murchison and Ravi Sachidanandam and Carly Smith and Gregory J. Hannon and Enkhjargal Tsend‐Ayush and Daniel A. McMillan and Rosalind Attenborough and Willem Rens and Malcolm Ferguson-Smith and Christophe Lefèvre and Julie A. Sharp and Kevin R. Nicholas and David A. Ray and Michael Kube and Richard Reinhardt and Thomas H. Pringle and James Taylor and Russell C. Jones and Brett Nixon and Jean-Louis Dacheux and Hitoshi Niwa and Yoko Sekita and Xiaoqiu Huang and Alexander Stark and Pouya Kheradpour and Manolis Kellis and Paul Flicek and Yuan Chen and Caleb Webber and Ross C. Hardison and Joanne O. Nelson and Kym Hallsworth-Pepin and Kim D. Delehaunty and Chris Markovic and Pat Minx and Yucheng Feng and Colin Kremitzki and Makedonka Mitreva and Jarret Glasscock and Todd Wylie and P. Wohldmann and Prathapan Thiru and Michael N. Nhan and Craig Pohl and Scott M. Smith and Shunfeng Hou and Mikhail Nefedov},
  title = {{Erratum: Genome analysis of the platypus reveals unique signatures of evolution}},
  booktitle = {Nature},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1038/nature07253},
}
Figure