Embedding Ethics and Trustworthiness for Sustainable AI in Earth Sciences: Where Do We Begin?

Philipe DiasOSTI 2023 · OpenAlex

TL;DR

Artificial Intelligence is a powerful tool for Earth Sciences, but its rapid adoption comes with hidden environmental and ethical costs. This paper provides a roadmap for "Sustainable AI," arguing that we must move beyond just using AI for sustainability and start focusing on making the AI development process itself ethical, transparent, and ecologically sound.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While AI helps researchers predict crop yields and map urban environments, it is a double-edged sword. Research suggests that while AI could help achieve 79% of the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals, it could also negatively impact 35% of them if left unchecked.

The authors highlight a critical gap: the "sustainability of AI" is often ignored in favor of "AI for sustainability." Developing massive models requires immense energy—sometimes equivalent to the lifetime carbon footprint of five cars—and can inadvertently exacerbate social inequalities or rely on "extractivism" (e.g., mining lithium and cobalt in lower-income regions). In Earth Sciences (ES), where the goal is often to protect the planet, these contradictions are particularly glaring. The paper addresses the need for a framework to embed ethics and trustworthiness into the ES research workflow from day one.

Methods

This paper is a synthesis and position paper rather than an experimental study. The authors conduct a targeted literature review to bridge the gap between AI ethics and Earth Science applications. They propose structuring the path forward around four foundational pillars:

  1. Definitions & Literacy: Establishing a common language across multidisciplinary teams.
  2. Documentation: Adopting rigorous standards for tracking the lifecycle of data and models.
  3. Understandable AI (XAI): Moving away from "black-box" models toward interpretable systems that respect physical laws.
  4. Incentives: Changing the academic and commercial culture to reward transparency and sustainability over "positive results" alone.

Datasets

As a review and position paper, this work does not introduce or use a specific dataset for training. However, it strongly advocates for the adoption of the FAIR principles (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable) and highlights the importance of frameworks like Datasheets for Datasets to document the provenance and intended use of Earth Science data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Defensive Position" Trap: The authors observe that researchers often fall into a defensive stance when questioned about the risks of their tech, using a few positive outcomes as a "shield" to avoid thinking about potential negative impacts.
  • Sustainability is a Lifecycle, Not a Feature: Borrowing from Aimee van Wynsberghe, the authors define Sustainable AI as a movement covering the entire lifecycle—from the initial idea and data collection to training, implementation, and governance.
  • Physics-Informed Interpretability: In Earth Sciences, "post-hoc" explainability (like saliency maps that highlight pixels) isn't enough. The authors argue for models that obey domain knowledge—such as physical laws, monotonicity, or sparsity—to gain true trust from the scientific community.
  • The Accountability Gap: Documentation isn't just "paperwork." Using frameworks like SMACTR (Scoping, Mapping, Artifact Collection, Testing, and Reflection) helps close the gap between a model's development and its real-world deployment, ensuring it doesn't cause harm when applied to new geographic regions or climates.

Key Results

The paper provides a qualitative framework for the ES community rather than quantitative benchmarks. Key takeaways include:

  • Carbon Footprint Awareness: Citing existing research, the authors remind the community that the process of "Neural Architectural Search" (finding the best model structure) is a major contributor to AI’s carbon footprint.
  • The 35% Risk: They emphasize that without proper oversight, AI-based technologies could trigger further inequalities and infringe on citizens' rights, potentially undermining over a third of global sustainability targets.
  • Human-in-the-loop Success: They cite studies showing that users are better at predicting model behavior when they engage in "human-in-the-loop" interactions rather than just receiving static explanations (like confidence scores).

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation identified is the lack of systemic incentives. Currently, there is no reward for a researcher to spend time estimating a model's carbon footprint or writing extensive documentation; peer-reviewed journals and funding agencies still prioritize "state-of-the-art" performance metrics above all else.

Future Work Suggestions: * Funding Diversification: Introducing requirements for funding that balance economic, societal, and environmental interests. * "Breaking the System": Encouraging publication venues to reward authors who detail the limitations and potential risks of their work, rather than just the successes. * Community Literacy: Organizing workshops and tutorials to help Earth Scientists—who may not be AI experts—understand the ethical dimensions of the tools they are increasingly relying on.

Summary updated

Abstract

As in many other research domains, Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques have been increasing their footprint in Earth Sciences to extract meaningful information from the large amount of high-detailed data available from multiple sensor modalities. While on the one hand the existing success cases endorse the great potential of AI to help address open challenges in ES, on the other hand on-going discussions and established lessons from studies on the sustainability, ethics and trustworthiness of AI must be taken into consideration if the community is to ensure that its research efforts move into directions that effectively benefit the society and the environment. In this paper, we discuss insights gathered from a brief literature review on the subtopics of AI Ethics, Sustainable AI, AI Trustworthiness and AI for Earth Sciences in an attempt to identify some of the promising directions and key needs to successfully bring these concepts together.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dias2023embedding,
  author = {Philipe Dias},
  title = {{Embedding Ethics and Trustworthiness for Sustainable AI in Earth Sciences: Where Do We Begin?}},
  booktitle = {OSTI},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure