The digitalization of modern society has made data ubiquitous, capturing human behavior through every interaction with products, services, and systems. In the field of Human-Computer Interaction (HCI), data is frequently treated as a cold output—a series of metrics used to optimize systems or track users. However, a recent editorial in Frontiers in Human Dynamics advocates for a paradigm shift: treating data not as a mere byproduct, but as a "material" for design—something tangible, messy, and deeply interconnected with human experience.
Redefining Data-Centric Design (DCD)
Data-Centric Design (DCD) leverages data as a material for subjective inquiry, providing an entry point to better understand human dynamics through reflection. This approach moves beyond using data simply to validate finished products; instead, it uses data as a creative medium to understand human behavior during the design process.
The editorial identifies a "messiness" in how researchers work with data in the field, noting a gap between high-level data science and the ground-level reality of human-centered design (HCD). The goal is to transition from treating individuals as "data subjects" (passive sources of information) to "data participants" (active collaborators) while navigating the ethical and technical hurdles of real-world environments.
Diverse Approaches to Data as Material
The editorial synthesizes four distinct research projects that exemplify this shift:
Urban Forestry and Anthropological Theory: Rout et al. explored how visual and spatial data from drone-mounted sensors can inform urban forest design. By combining technical "point cloud" data with anthropological concepts like Tim Ingold’s "Life of Lines," the researchers made abstract ecological information tangible and culturally meaningful for stakeholders.
Sensitive Data Donation: Gómez Ortega provided an auto-ethnographic account of the challenges involved in "data donation." By reflecting on the process of sharing sensitive personal information—such as menstrual logs and speech records—the work emphasizes the need for transparency, data minimization, and participant agency.
Tangible Energy Landscapes: Özge Ağça demonstrated how physical data mapping can increase awareness of energy consumption among teenagers. Through workshops, participants created 3D physical models of their home energy use, showing that tangible interaction helps young people recount patterns and envision behavioral changes.
Data-Enabled Design in Semi-Public Spaces: Raviselvam et al. documented the challenges of implementing Data-Enabled Design (DED) in an amusement park. Their work highlights the importance of contextual immersion and the difficulty of balancing quantitative sensor data with qualitative observations in dynamic, semi-public environments.
Key Insights: Tangibility and Participation
A central theme across these contributions is the importance of making data tangible and accessible to non-experts. Whether through physical models, interactive visualizations, or donation platforms, these approaches seek to bridge the gap between abstract data and lived experience.
Furthermore, the research highlights a shift toward "data participation." This involves empowering individuals to control and explore their own data, moving away from extractive collection models toward those based on transparency and individual agency. By understanding the "grain" of data—its biases, gaps, and expressive potential—designers can create more meaningful encounters that inspire reflection and action.
Future Challenges and Ethical Infrastructure
Despite the successes, several critical challenges remain for the field:
Scale and Transferability: While these "boutique" methods work well in specific contexts, it remains unclear how they can be scaled to larger populations or adapted to different environments.
Technical Accessibility: There is a persistent tension between using sophisticated, high-cost data tools and the need for low-tech, accessible alternatives for resource-limited communities.
Power Dynamics: The choice of how data is represented fundamentally shapes participation. Future work must examine how different representations include or exclude stakeholders and how power influences data interpretation.
Institutional Friction: Current ethical frameworks often clash with the iterative, exploratory nature of designing with live, personal data. There is a pressing need for flexible ethical infrastructures that support innovation while ensuring responsible practice.
Conclusion
Data-centric design is not merely about collecting and visualizing information; it is about creating meaningful encounters between people and data. As the field evolves, maintaining a human-centered focus while addressing technical and ethical challenges will be essential to realizing the transformative potential of data as a design material.
Summary updated
Abstract
The digitalisation of our societies has made data ubiquitous, capturing the behaviours of individuals through their interactions with products, services, and systems. As design and HCI researchers increasingly integrate data throughout human-centred and participatory design processes, the highly dynamic nature of behavioural data reveals its deep interconnection with people, their behaviours, and experiences. Data-Centric Design leverages data as material for subjective inquiry--an entry point to better understand human dynamics through deeper reflection in research and design processes. This research topic aims to collect emerging, illustrative projects from the community, share the messiness of research and design processes with data, and surface good practices for effective and responsible data use. This need emerged from the guest editors' engagement in a series of Special Interest Group (SIG) meet-ups \citep{sig2023} and workshops \citep{workshopCHI2023} at the ACM conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI).%%ContributionsThe four papers in this collection exemplify diverse approaches to data as human-centred design material, each offering unique perspectives on how data transforms design processes and stakeholder relationships. They are a selection from a broader set of contributions from the community who gathered at the Data-centric Design Symposium\footnote{Data-Centric Design symposium website: \url{https://datacentricdesign.org/symposium.html}} in December 2023 in Delft (NL).\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2025.1391255}{Rout et al.} present ``One tree matters: reflections on data as a design material in urban forestry'', exploring how visual and spatial data from drone-mounted sensors can inform urban forest design. Through interviews with urban forestry experts examining prototype data visualisations, they demonstrate how combining point cloud data with anthropological theories (particularly Ingold's concepts of ``Life of Lines'' and ``Imagining for Real'') can bridge analytical and cultural perspectives. Their work highlights how data physicalisation can make abstract ecological information tangible, enabling stakeholders to explore energy-consuming habits and identify opportunities for change.\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2025.1404855}{Gómez Ortega} contributes ``Sensitive data donation in practice: unforeseen challenges and lessons learned'', offering critical reflections on implementing data donation across three case studies involving menstrual tracking logs, speech records, and physical activity data. This auto-ethnographic account reveals practical challenges in data donation processes, from parsing changing data structures to supporting donors in exploring their own data. The work emphasises the importance of transparency, data minimisation, and empowering participants to set boundaries around their sensitive data~\citep{gomezortega2024}.\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2024.1406364}{Özge Ağça} presents ``Tangible consumption data landscapes of teenagers'', demonstrating how physical data mapping can increase teenagers' awareness of energy consumption. Through workshops in which participants created physical models that represent their home energy use, the study shows how tangible interaction with data enables young people to recount consumption patterns and envision behavioural changes. The integration of questionnaires, layout drawings, and three-dimensional data landscapes illustrates how multiple data representations can support different levels of engagement and understanding.\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2024.1406974}{Raviselvam et al.} explore ``Rollercoasters and research: applying data-enabled design to a semi-public context'', documenting the challenges of implementing Data-Enabled Design (DED) \citep{Funk2024}) in an amusement park setting. Through a two-week design workshop with student researchers, they identify how the open nature of semipublic spaces affects data collection practices, stakeholder engagement, and the balance between quantitative and qualitative approaches. Their findings highlight the importance of contextual immersion and the challenges of technical implementation in dynamic environments.%% Connections and ContrastsThese articles collectively demonstrate that data as design material requires careful consideration of context, participants, and representation methods. A striking connection across all contributions is the emphasis on making data tangible and accessible to non-experts. Whether through physical models (\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2024.1406364}{Özge Ağça}), interactive visualisations (\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2025.1391255}{Rout et al.}), donation platforms (\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2025.1404855}{Gómez Ortega}), or contextual probes (\href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2024.1406974}{Raviselvam et al.}), each approach seeks to bridge the gap between abstract data and lived experience. The papers also highlight an array of approaches to collaboration, moving from data subject to data participant. While \href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2025.1404855}{Gómez Ortega} emphasises individual agency in controlling personal data, \href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2024.1406974}{Raviselvam et al.} focus on collective experiences in public spaces. \href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2024.1406364}{Özge Ağça}'s work with teenagers highlights generational perspectives on data engagement, while \href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2025.1391255}{Rout et al.} demonstrate professional stakeholder involvement in interpreting environmental data. Overall, these are practical examples relating to emerging data mindsets and philosophies from data humanism \citep{lupi2017} to data feminism \citep{d2023data} and data locality \citep{loukissas2019all}.%% Future ChallengesSeveral practical yet critical challenges emerge from this collection. First, the ethical infrastructure of research institutions clashes with these approaches to research. \href{https://doi.org/10.3389/fhumd.2025.1404855}{Gómez Ortega}'s experiences with institutional review boards and changing data formats highlight the need for more flexible ethical frameworks that can accommodate exploratory data work while protecting participants. How can we develop ethical infrastructure that supports innovation while ensuring responsible data practices? Second, along with the high effort and contextualisation comes the challenge of scale and transferability: While these studies demonstrate successful applications in specific contexts, questions remain about scaling data-centric approaches. Can methods developed for urban forestry be transferred to other environmental contexts? How do approaches designed for semipublic spaces adapt to private or fully public settings? Third, these papers highlight challenges around technical accessibility. The tension between sophisticated data collection tools and the need for accessible, low-tech alternatives appears throughout these papers. How can the field develop toolkits that balance technical capability with broad accessibility, particularly for communities with limited resources? Finally, the issue of power dynamics around data representation becomes more apparent. The choice of data representation, whether physical, visual, or interactive, fundamentally shapes participation and understanding. Future work must critically examine how different representations include or exclude stakeholders and how power dynamics influence data interpretation and use.These contributions demonstrate that data-centric design is not just about collecting and visualising data but about creating meaningful encounters between people and data that can inspire reflection, understanding, and action. As the field evolves, maintaining this human-centred focus while addressing technical, ethical, and contextual challenges will be essential to realise the transformative potential of data as design material.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bourgeois2025editorial,
author = {Jacky Bourgeois and Mathias Funk and Sandy J. J. Gould and Albrecht Kurze},
title = {{Editorial: Data-centric design: data as a human-centred material}},
booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Dynamics},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.3389/fhumd.2025.1674782},
}