Digital Entrepreneurship Ecosystem as a New Form of Organizing: A Case of Zhongguancun

Wenyu Du, Wenjie Li, Jiamin YinWORLD 2018 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Digital entrepreneurship ecosystem (DEE) plays a significant role for generating digital innovations because it contains variable resources and facilitates the collective collaborations. Many regions have established the DEE to support digital innovations in order to improve their economic environment. However, researches on digital innovation at ecosystem level are limited. In addition, the knowledge about “how to organize DEE” is inadequate. To unveil the organizing forms of DEE, we consider DEE as a “new” form of organizing for the absence of traditional organizing elements such as hierarchy and formal authority. Through this theoretical lens, DEE can be analyzed as an organization, rather than a combination of actors. Empirically, we conducted a case study of Zhongguancun (ZGC), a successful DEE in China, and interviewed 51 heterogeneous people. We found that eight activities compose the organizing form of DEE.

Introduction: The Coordination Challenge in Ecosystems

Digital innovation is increasingly shifting from the confines of individual firms to sprawling ecosystems—complex networks of startups, investors, and service providers. While traditional organizational theory provides clear frameworks for how companies manage internal operations through hierarchy and formal authority, our understanding of how these decentralized ecosystems coordinate efforts remains limited.

The fundamental challenge lies in the nature of the ecosystem itself: its members are legally independent entities with often conflicting interests. Without a central "boss" to assign tasks or distribute rewards, how does a digital entrepreneurship ecosystem (DEE) avoid chaos or the "free-rider" problem? This study addresses this gap by treating the DEE as a "meta-organization" that must solve four universal problems of organizing: task division, task allocation, reward distribution, and information flow.

Methodology

To investigate these dynamics, the researchers conducted an in-depth qualitative case study of Beijing’s Zhongguancun (ZGC) district, widely recognized as the "Silicon Valley of China." The study's empirical foundation includes:

  • 51 semi-structured interviews with a diverse group of stakeholders, including entrepreneurs, government officials, accelerator managers, and venture capitalists.
  • Four months of participant observation, during which one researcher was embedded as an intern at a local startup accelerator.
  • Archival data analysis of over 472 pages of interview transcripts, field notes, government documents, and news reports.

The researchers applied the "forms of organizing" framework (Puranam et al., 2014) to categorize how ZGC addresses the core challenges of organizational coordination.

The DEE as a Collectivist Infrastructure

A key insight of the study is the distinction between traditional entrepreneurship and the digital species. A DEE is not merely a cluster of individual business owners; it is a "collectivist infrastructure" where "digital species" (firms leveraging digital technology) integrate resources beyond the firm level.

DEE as a collectivist infrastructure

Unlike previous literature that often dichotomizes organization as either top-down (centralized) or bottom-up (emergent), this research suggests that successful DEEs require a dynamic balance of both. In ZGC, this is achieved through a hybrid model where the government acts as an "architect," setting the stage for decentralized, competitive self-selection among participants.

Organizing Activities in Zhongguancun

The authors identified eight specific activities that allow the ZGC ecosystem to function effectively as a meta-organization. These activities solve the four fundamental problems of organizing:

  1. Task Division: This is addressed through Category Design, where the government defines broad strategic areas, and Co-specialization, where participants find niche sub-tasks, such as specialized legal or financial services tailored for startups.
  2. Task Allocation: The ecosystem utilizes Captain Assignment, where the government designates established IT firms or accelerators to lead specific niches. This is complemented by Self-selection based on competition, ensuring that only the most efficient service providers thrive.
  3. Reward Distribution: Beyond financial subsidies, the ecosystem relies on Value Co-creation (growing the collective "pie") and a robust Entrepreneurial Culture. This culture acts as a social incentive, normalizing risk and providing legitimacy to founders.
  4. Information Flow: Coordination is facilitated through Physical Collocation (e.g., the famous 200-meter "InnoWay" street) and Intensive Conferences, with over 2,000 events held in the first two years of the study period.
Universal problems and solutions in organizing

Conclusion and Future Directions

The ZGC case demonstrates that a DEE can be organized without traditional hierarchy by balancing centralized "architecting" with decentralized emergence. However, the study's focus on a single, government-heavy case in China limits its generalizability. Organizing forms in regions like Silicon Valley or Tel Aviv may rely on different mechanisms with less state involvement.

Future research should explore comparative studies across different cultural and economic contexts to determine if these eight activities are universal. Additionally, longitudinal studies could reveal how these organizing forms evolve as ecosystems mature over decades.

Summary updated

Abstract

Digital entrepreneurship ecosystem (DEE) plays a significant role for generating digital innovations because it contains variable resources and facilitates the collective collaborations. Many regions have established the DEE to support digital innovations in order to improve their economic environment. However, researches on digital innovation at ecosystem level are limited. In addition, the knowledge about “how to organize DEE” is inadequate. To unveil the organizing forms of DEE, we consider DEE as a “new” form of organizing for the absence of traditional organizing elements such as hierarchy and formal authority. Through this theoretical lens, DEE can be analyzed as an organization, rather than a combination of actors. Empirically, we conducted a case study of Zhongguancun (ZGC), a successful DEE in China, and interviewed 51 heterogeneous people. We found that eight activities compose the organizing form of DEE.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{du2018digital,
  author = {Wenyu Du and Wenjie Li and Jiamin Yin},
  title = {{Digital Entrepreneurship Ecosystem as a New Form of Organizing: A Case of Zhongguancun}},
  booktitle = {WORLD},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1142/9789813209138\_0001},
}
Figure