Abstract
This study presents the evaluation results of the “ATANA” research program, which focuses on a platform that integrates the creation and management of narratives associated with cultural tourism applications. The platform leverages augmented reality (AR) and narrative techniques within an ambient-intelligence environment that encompasses a museum and its surrounding landmarks. The case study pertains to the Kotsanas Museum of Ancient Greek Technology (MAET). The methodology enables tourists to traverse the historic center of Athens or the archaeological site of Olympia and explore ancient Greek technological inventions through a mobile application supporting augmented reality. The proposed approach also supported the participation of MAET in an exhibition in Malta by projecting a variety of 3D inventions through AR.
Introduction
Cultural tourism often suffers from a "silo" effect, where visitors explore outdoor archaeological sites (landmarks) and indoor museums as two entirely separate experiences. Furthermore, traditional museum exhibits can feel static, making it difficult for visitors to visualize how complex ancient machinery—such as the inventions of Philo or Heron—actually functioned. The ATANA research program addresses these challenges by creating a seamless, narrative-driven journey that connects the physical city to digital heritage, aiming to increase visitor engagement and footfall for local businesses.
System Architecture and Methods
The researchers developed a Platform for Creating and Managing Stories (PCMS) built on two primary pillars:
1. Ambient Intelligence (AmI) Environment
The system uses GPS coordinates for outdoor navigation and Bluetooth beacons for indoor storytelling. It hosts high-fidelity, photorealistic 3D models of ancient technological exhibits. Unlike static models, these include interactive functional simulations, allowing users to see the "inner workings" of ancient Greek tech via AR on their mobile devices.
2. Personalized Recommendation System
To tailor the experience, the team implemented a multi-stage recommendation engine:
- Initial Matching: Uses the Jaccard similarity index to compare user preference tags with location tags.
- Hybrid Collaborative Filtering (CF): Utilizes the CMFREC library to combine user ratings with metadata, solving the "Cold Start" problem for new users.
- Gamification: The app categorizes users into types (e.g., "Explorer," "Achiever") and offers points for rating sites, which are exchangeable in a virtual store to incentivize data collection for machine learning models.
The City as a Virtual Museum
A core innovation of the ATANA project is the "spatial connection." By linking specific landmarks in the historic center of Athens to 3D simulations of ancient inventions, the city itself becomes an immersive gallery. This functional AR approach addresses a major hurdle in technical heritage: understanding the mechanics of the past through visualization rather than just observation.
Evaluation and Results
The system was evaluated using the System Usability Scale (SUS), where scores above 68 are considered "above average." * Athens Group: Achieved a mean SUS score of 80.3 (Grade A). * Ancient Olympia Group: Achieved a mean SUS score of 78.5 (Grade A). * Ecsite Conference Group: Achieved a mean SUS score of 80.0 (Grade A).
User sentiment analysis revealed that the majority of participants were "Promoters" or "Passive," suggesting the AR interface was intuitive and engaging for a wide demographic.
Conclusion and Future Work
While the pilot results are promising, the authors identify a potential bias as most evaluators were already museum visitors. Future work will focus on testing the app's ability to independently attract "cold" users from app stores and expanding the volume of anonymous user data to refine the recommendation algorithms. Additionally, the next phase will investigate the long-term sustainability of the business model and its direct benefits to local stakeholders surrounding the landmarks.
Summary updated