Determinants of Shopping Style in Dual-channel Supply Chain: Grounded Theory from the Consumer Perspective

Yuhan Hou, Jinyuan Song, Yongjun Xu, Xuan YeAtlantis 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Supply chain management is a critical bridge in the global economy. While much research focuses on supplier pricing and decision-making, few studies examine the supply chain from the consumer's perspective. This paper investigates the determinants of shopping patterns within a dual-channel supply chain. Using Grounded Theory, the authors interviewed consumers to analyze, code, and classify data into a theoretical system. Subsequently, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) was applied to weight these factors. Results indicate that product quality and price are the primary considerations for consumers, followed by logistics, customer service, shopping experience, and information access.

Introduction

In the contemporary dual-channel economy, consumers frequently transition between traditional physical stores and online e-commerce platforms. Despite extensive research on optimizing retail pricing strategies, there is a notable deficit in understanding the internal psychological drivers of consumer channel choice. Existing models often fail to capture the nuances of why individuals prefer one channel over another. This research addresses this gap by constructing a theoretical framework grounded in direct consumer feedback and quantifying the relative importance of various influencing factors.

Methodology

The study utilized a hybrid two-phase methodology combining qualitative and quantitative techniques.

Grounded Theory (GT)

The qualitative phase involved semi-structured interviews with 40 consumers across various demographics. The data underwent a rigorous three-stage coding process: open coding to break down transcripts into 20 conceptual categories, axial coding to group these into six main categories, and selective coding to identify the core category.

The iterative research process following Grounded Theory principles.

Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)

To quantify the importance of the identified factors, the researchers surveyed 160 consumers. Participants performed pairwise comparisons of the six main categories. These comparisons were then processed using matrix algebra to determine the specific weight of each factor, ensuring a mathematically rigorous ranking of consumer priorities.

Theoretical Framework and Key Insights

The Grounded Theory analysis revealed that "Shopping Experience" serves as the central axis around which all other factors revolve. The resulting theoretical model identifies six primary determinants: Product Quality, Price Factors, Logistics Factors, Customer Service, Shopping Experience, and Information Access.

Conceptual model illustrating the relationship between shopping style and its influencing factors.

Key insights from the model include:

  • Quality as the Primary Driver: Consumers prioritize product quality above all else, reflecting a growing concern over counterfeit or substandard goods in online channels.
  • The Role of Experience: While "Shopping Experience" is the core theoretical category, it acts as a filter through which other practical factors like price and logistics are perceived.
  • Information Access as a Baseline: Interestingly, the ability to access and compare information was weighted lowest, suggesting it is now viewed as a standard requirement rather than a competitive advantage.

Quantitative Results

The AHP analysis provided a clear ranking of the determinants based on their calculated weights:

Factor Weight ($E(\omega_i)$) Rank
Product Quality 0.3422 1
Price Factors 0.1783 2
Logistics Factors 0.1335 3
Customer Service 0.1285 4
Shopping Experience 0.1118 5
Information Access 0.1057 6

These results confirm that Product Quality (0.3422) and Price Factors (0.1783) are the most significant levers influencing consumer behavior in a dual-channel environment.

Conclusion and Recommendations

The study concludes that retailers must prioritize product quality and competitive pricing to effectively influence consumer shopping styles. While logistics and customer service remain important, they are secondary to the core value proposition of the product itself.

Future research should aim to expand the sample size to mitigate geographic biases and explore how these factor weights might vary across different product categories, such as luxury items versus daily essentials. As the retail landscape continues to evolve, the relative importance of these determinants may shift, requiring ongoing investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Supply chain management is one of the key research topics today, and it is also a bridge connecting the world.At present, most of the relevant research focuses on the pricing and decision-making of suppliers, and there are few articles on the supply chain from the perspective of consumers.Therefore, this paper studies the determinants of shopping patterns under the dual-channel supply chain.According to the grounded theory, interview the respondents, analyze, code and classify the original data, extract the main and sub-categories, and build a theoretical system.Using the grounded theory method, the extracted main categories are taken as important influencing factors.Then, through a questionnaire survey and analytic hierarchy process, the weight of each influencing factor is obtained.Finally, it is concluded that shopping experience, price factors, logistics factors, customer service, product quality and information access have a significant impact on consumers' choice of shopping methods, among which product quality and price factors are the most considered by consumers, and retailers should put forward corresponding suggestions and improvements for the above factors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hou2023determinants,
  author = {Yuhan Hou and Jinyuan Song and Yongjun Xu and Xuan Ye},
  title = {{Determinants of Shopping Style in Dual-channel Supply Chain: Grounded Theory from the Consumer Perspective}},
  booktitle = {Atlantis},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-102-9\_83},
}
Figure