Corrigendum: Interdecadal variation of precipitation over Yunnan, China in summer and its possible causes

Zeyu Dong, Shu Gui, Ruowen Yang, Jinxin Cheng, Huan Yang, Ji MaFrontiers in Environmental Science 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

This document is a Corrigendum for the research paper "Interdecadal variation of precipitation over Yunnan, China in summer and its possible causes," originally published in Frontiers in Environmental Science.

TL;DR

This corrigendum addresses graphical printing errors in a study investigating the long-term (interdecadal) drivers of summer rainfall in Yunnan, China. By correcting the spacing of atmospheric wind and moisture flux vectors in key figures, the authors ensure the visual data accurately reflects the underlying atmospheric dynamics without altering the study's original scientific conclusions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Yunnan province, located in Southwest China, experiences significant fluctuations in summer precipitation that occur over decades (interdecadal variation). Understanding these patterns is critical for regional water resource management and agriculture.

The original research sought to identify the atmospheric and oceanic "teleconnections"—such as Sea Surface Temperature (SST) configurations and the behavior of the Western North Pacific subtropical high—that drive these shifts. However, the published version contained technical errors in Figure 3 and Figure 5, where the spacing between neighboring vectors (arrows representing wind and moisture flow) was distorted. This corrigendum provides the corrected visualizations necessary to properly interpret the region's climate mechanics.

Methods

While the corrigendum focuses on the corrected figures, it highlights the primary analytical techniques used in the study:

  • Regression Analysis: The authors regressed atmospheric variables against the ID-PC1 (the first Principal Component of the interdecadal precipitation index) to identify patterns that correlate with rainfall changes.
  • Composite Analysis: They compared atmospheric states (winds and moisture) between specifically defined "wet" and "dry" periods to isolate the differences in circulation.
  • Atmospheric Modeling Concepts: The study references the Gill-Matsuno response, a standard theoretical framework used to explain how heating in the tropics (like the Bay of Bengal or Western Pacific) creates specific atmospheric pressure and wind patterns.

Datasets

Not discussed in the corrigendum. (The original paper likely utilized global reanalysis data for winds and moisture, and regional station data for precipitation, but these are not specified in this correction notice).

Key Insights and Ideas

The corrected figures provide the visual evidence for several "aha moments" regarding Yunnan's climate:

  • Vertical Atmospheric Structure: By comparing 200 hPa (upper atmosphere) and 700 hPa (lower atmosphere) winds in Figure 3, the researchers show how anomalies at different heights work together to create a "pump" for moisture.
  • Moisture Pathways: Figure 5 illustrates the Column Integrated Water Vapor Flux (CIWVF). The "aha" here is seeing exactly how moisture is funneled from the Bay of Bengal and the Western Pacific warm pool into Yunnan during wet decades.
  • Significance Testing: The use of black vectors and stippling (dots) in the figures indicates areas where the results are statistically significant (95% confidence level), allowing researchers to distinguish true climate signals from random noise.

Key Results

The corrigendum presents the corrected quantitative visualizations:

  • Wind Anomalies (Figure 3): The corrected maps show distinct cyclonic and anticyclonic centers (labeled A, B, and C) that dictate the flow of air over Yunnan. In the 200 hPa regression, wind speeds are measured in $ms^{-1}$, providing a clear picture of the jet stream's influence.
  • Moisture Transport (Figure 5): The CIWVF units are given in $kg \cdot m^{-1} \cdot s^{-1}$, and the divergence (CIWVFD) is shown in $10^{-5} kg \cdot m^{-2} \cdot s^{-1}$. The corrected shading clearly shows areas of moisture convergence (where air piles up and rains) versus divergence (where air spreads out and stays dry).
  • Scientific Integrity: The authors explicitly state that despite the graphical errors in the original printing, the scientific conclusions of the article remain unchanged.

Limitations and Future Work

Not discussed in the corrigendum.

Summary updated

Abstract

CORRECTION article Front. Environ. Sci., 11 October 2023Sec. Atmosphere and Climate Volume 11 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fenvs.2023.1304145
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2023corrigendum,
  author = {Zeyu Dong and Shu Gui and Ruowen Yang and Jinxin Cheng and Huan Yang and Ji Ma},
  title = {{Corrigendum: Interdecadal variation of precipitation over Yunnan, China in summer and its possible causes}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Environmental Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenvs.2023.1304145},
}

Loading related content...

Figure