Corrigendum: Genome-wide association study of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma in Chinese subjects identifies susceptibility loci at PLCE1 and C20orf54

Lidong Wang, Fuyou Zhou, Xuemin Li, Liangdan Sun, Xin Song, Yan Jin, Li Jiang-man, Guo-Qiang Kong, Hong Qi, Juan Cui, Lian-Qun Zhang, Jiezhi Yang, Jilin Li, Xing-Chuan Li, Jingli Ren, Zhicai Liu, Wenjun Gao, Ling Yuan, Wei Wu, Yanrui Zhang, Weipeng Wang, Ilyar Sheyhidin, Feng Li, Bao-Ping Chen, Shu‐Wei Ren, Bin Liu, Dan Li, Jian-Wei Ku, Zong-Min Fan, Shengli Zhou, Zhigang Guo, Xueke Zhao, Na Liu, Yong-hong Ai, Fang‐Fang Shen, Wenyan Cui, Shuang Song, Tao Guo, Jing Huang, Chao Yuan, Jia Huang, Yue Wu, Wenbin Yue, Feng Changwei, Honglei Li, Yan Wang, Jin-Ya Tian, Yue Lu, Yi Yuan, Wenliang Zhu, Min Liu, Wenjing Fu, Yang Xia, Han-Jing Wang, Suo-Li Han, Jie Chen, Min Soo Han, Haiyan Wang, Peng Zhang, Xiu-Min Li, Jincheng Dong, Guo-Lan Xing, Ran Wang, Ming Guo, Zhiwei Chang, Hailin Liu, Li Guo, Zhiqing Yuan, Qin Lu, Liu-Qin Yang, Fu-Guo Zhu, Xiufeng Yang, Xiaoshan Feng, Zhou Wang, Yin Li, Shegan Gao, Qirenwang Qige, Long-Tang Bai, Wenjun Yang, Guangyan Lei, Zhong‐Ying Shen, Longqi Chen, En‐Min Li, Li‐Yan Xu, Zhi‐Yong Wu, Wei-Ke Cao, Jianpo Wang, Zhi-Qin Bao, Ji‐Li Chen, Guang-Cheng Ding, Xiang Zhuang, Yingfa Zhou, Hou‐Feng Zheng, Zheng Zhang, Xianbo Zuo, Ziming Dong, Dongmei Fan, Xin He, Jin WangNature Genetics 2014 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In 2010, a high-profile Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS) identified several genetic variants (SNPs) purportedly linked to an increased risk of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) in Chinese populations. This corrigendum provides a critical re-evaluation of those findings, revealing that several major genetic associations previously linked to the disease were likely "statistical ghosts." The authors demonstrate that these false positives were the result of inadequate control for population stratification—a classic and persistent pitfall in genomic research.

The Problem: Population Stratification

The validity of any GWAS hinges on the fundamental assumption that the case group (individuals with the disease) and the control group (healthy individuals) are genetically similar in every respect except for the trait being studied. If the cases are inadvertently drawn from a different ancestral sub-group than the controls, any genetic variation between those sub-groups will appear to be a disease marker, even if it is merely a marker of regional ancestry. This phenomenon, known as population stratification, led to the identification of susceptibility loci that did not hold up under more rigorous ancestral matching.

Methodology and Re-analysis

To address these potential errors, the authors performed a comprehensive re-analysis of their original data while incorporating several new datasets to validate the previous findings. The primary methodological shift involved the use of genetically matched subsets.

Instead of analyzing the broad original pool of subjects, the researchers employed principal component analysis (PCA) and other ancestry-matching techniques to ensure the cases and controls were truly comparable. This refined group consisted of 1,789 subjects (1,076 cases and 713 controls) selected for ancestral homogeneity. These results were then cross-referenced against:

  1. A New Henan Cohort: 669 new subjects (229 cases, 370 controls).
  2. NCI GWAS Data: An independent dataset from the National Cancer Institute.
  3. Beijing GWAS Data: A dataset representing a "low-risk" population used for comparative replication.

Key Insights: The Vanishing Signal

The most significant finding of this corrigendum is the dramatic evaporation of statistical significance once population matching was applied.

  • The C20orf54 Locus: In the original study, the SNP rs13042395 at the C20orf54 locus showed a highly significant p-value of $1.51 \times 10^{-11}$, well beyond the standard threshold for discovery. However, in the combined analysis of matched and new subjects, the Odds Ratio (OR) shifted from 0.66 to 0.88, and the p-value plummeted to a non-significant $0.09$ ($9.12 \times 10^{-2}$).
  • Other Retracted Loci: The authors found no evidence to support the association for three other previously highlighted SNPs: rs17761864 (17p13), rs6503659 (17q21), and rs2847281 (18p11).

These results serve as a stark reminder that large sample sizes (N) cannot compensate for poor population control. The failure of the rs13042395 variant to replicate in either high-risk (NCI) or low-risk (Beijing) populations confirms that the original signal was a statistical artifact rather than biological reality.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This corrigendum updates the scientific record by providing corrected estimates for these SNPs, effectively removing them from the list of confirmed ESCC susceptibility factors. The study highlights a fundamental limitation in early GWAS: the reliance on geographic proximity as a proxy for genetic similarity.

For the bioinformatics and genomics communities, this work underscores the necessity of using robust ancestral informative markers (AIMs) and stricter population stratification controls. Furthermore, it demonstrates the vital role of the "post-publication" phase of science, where independent replication and rigorous re-analysis serve as essential self-correcting mechanisms for the field.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2014corrigendum,
  author = {Lidong Wang and Fuyou Zhou and Xuemin Li and Liangdan Sun and Xin Song and Yan Jin and LI Jiang-man and Guo-Qiang Kong and Hong Qi and Juan Cui and Lian-Qun Zhang and Jiezhi Yang and Jilin Li and Xing-Chuan Li and Jingli Ren and Zhicai Liu and Wenjun Gao and Ling Yuan and Wei Wu and Yanrui Zhang and Weipeng Wang and Ilyar Sheyhidin and Feng Li and Bao-Ping Chen and Shu‐Wei Ren and Bin Liu and Dan Li and Jian-Wei Ku and Zong-Min Fan and Shengli Zhou and Zhigang Guo and Xueke Zhao and Na Liu and Yong-hong Ai and Fang‐Fang Shen and Wenyan Cui and Shuang Song and Tao Guo and Jing Huang and Chao Yuan and Jia Huang and Yue Wu and Wenbin Yue and Feng Changwei and Honglei Li and Yan Wang and Jin-Ya Tian and Yue Lu and Yi Yuan and Wenliang Zhu and Min Liu and Wenjing Fu and Yang Xia and Han-Jing Wang and Suo-Li Han and Jie Chen and Min Soo Han and Haiyan Wang and Peng Zhang and Xiu-Min Li and Jincheng Dong and Guo-Lan Xing and Ran Wang and Ming Guo and Zhiwei Chang and Hailin Liu and Li Guo and Zhiqing Yuan and Hai Liu and Qin Lu and Liu-Qin Yang and Fu-Guo Zhu and Xiufeng Yang and Xiaoshan Feng and Zhou Wang and Yin Li and Shegan Gao and Qirenwang Qige and Long-Tang Bai and Wenjun Yang and Guangyan Lei and Zhong‐Ying Shen and Longqi Chen and En‐Min Li and Li‐Yan Xu and Zhi‐Yong Wu and Wei-Ke Cao and Jianpo Wang and Zhi-Qin Bao and Ji‐Li Chen and Guang-Cheng Ding and Xiang Zhuang and Yingfa Zhou and Hou‐Feng Zheng and Zheng Zhang and Xianbo Zuo and Ziming Dong and Dongmei Fan and Xin He and Jin Wang},
  title = {{Corrigendum: Genome-wide association study of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma in Chinese subjects identifies susceptibility loci at PLCE1 and C20orf54}},
  booktitle = {Nature Genetics},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1038/ng0914-1041},
}
Figure