[Corrigendum] Comparison of the biological characteristics of human mesenchymal stem cells derived from exfoliated deciduous teeth, bone marrow, gingival tissue, and umbilical cord

Jing Li, Shiqing Xu, Yuming Zhao, Yu Shi, Lihong Ge, Baohua XuMolecular 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In 2018, a study published in Molecular Medicine Reports compared the biological properties of human Mesenchymal Stem Cells (MSCs) derived from four distinct sources: exfoliated deciduous teeth (SHEDs), gingival tissue (GMSCs), bone marrow (BMSCs), and the umbilical cord (UCMSCs). This research is pivotal for regenerative medicine, as it evaluates the multipotency of cells from accessible tissues compared to the traditional bone marrow standard.

The Nature of the Correction

Following publication, a reader identified an error in Figure 3. Specifically, the data panels representing osteogenesis for GMSCs and BMSCs appeared to overlap, suggesting a duplication of the same source image. Upon internal review, the authors confirmed that the GMSC osteogenesis panel had been incorrectly selected. This corrigendum provides the corrected visual data, ensuring the integrity of the study's results without altering its fundamental conclusions.

Comparative Analysis of MSC Sources

The study focused on characterizing the "multipotency" of MSCs—their ability to differentiate into various specialized cell types. The four sources evaluated represent a spectrum of accessibility and therapeutic potential:

  • SHEDs: Harvested from baby teeth.
  • GMSCs: Derived from gum tissue.
  • BMSCs: The established "gold standard" from bone marrow.
  • UCMSCs: Sourced from the umbilical cord.

Differentiation Potential and Staining Techniques

To verify successful differentiation, the researchers employed three primary histological staining methods:

Osteogenic Differentiation

Cells were induced to form bone matrix, confirmed by Alizarin Red staining. This dye identifies calcium deposits, a definitive marker of bone formation. The corrected Figure 3 ensures that each cell source is represented by its unique experimental data.

Representative image of osteogenic differentiation showing robust Alizarin Red staining of calcium deposits.

Chondrogenic Differentiation

Induction into cartilage cells was verified using Alcian Blue staining, which reacts with the acidic polysaccharides (proteoglycans) characteristic of cartilage matrix.

Representative image of chondrogenic differentiation showing positive Alcian Blue staining of the extracellular matrix.

Adipogenic Differentiation

The formation of fat cells was confirmed via Oil Red O staining, highlighting lipid vacuoles within the cells.

Conclusion

The corrected data reaffirms that all four MSC sources—SHEDs, GMSCs, BMSCs, and UCMSCs—possess the requisite multipotency for classification as mesenchymal stem cells. While the corrigendum addresses a manual selection error in the original publication, the qualitative findings regarding the functional equivalence of these cell sources remain robust. This correction underscores the importance of rigorous data management in high-throughput imaging studies and the value of post-publication peer review in maintaining scientific accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Subsequently to the publication of this paper, an interested reader drew to the authors' attention that, in Fig. 3 on p. 4973, the data panels shown for the "Osteogenesis" row of data for the GMSC and BMSC experiments appeared to be overlapping, such the data may have been derived from the same original source. After having examined their original data, the authors have realized that the data panel selected for the GMSC "Osteogenesis" experiment was inadvertently chosen incorrectly. The corrected version of Fig. 3 is shown below. Note that this error did not significantly affect the results or the conclusions reported in this paper, and all the authors agree to this Corrigendum. The authors are grateful to the editor of <i>Molecular Medicine Reports</i> for allowing them the opportunity to publish this corrigendum, and apologize to the readership for any inconvenience caused.[Molecular Medicine Reports 18: 4969‑4977, 2018; DOI: 10.3892/mmr.2018.9501].
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022corrigendum,
  author = {Jing Li and Shiqing Xu and Yuming Zhao and Yu Shi and Lihong Ge and Baohua Xu},
  title = {{[Corrigendum] Comparison of the biological characteristics of human mesenchymal stem cells derived from exfoliated deciduous teeth, bone marrow, gingival tissue, and umbilical cord}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3892/mmr.2022.12919},
}
Figure