This document is a formal correction (erratum) to the paper "Experiences with Telemedicine for HIV Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Mixed-Methods Study," originally published in AIDS and Behavior. It provides updated data points and corrects typographical errors regarding the clinical markers used to evaluate patient outcomes.
TL;DR
This correction updates the reported percentage of study participants with undetectable HIV viral loads after the authors standardized their clinical threshold to $\le 50$ copies/mL. While the numerical data for viral suppression shifted upward by approximately 7%, the authors note that the study’s original qualitative interpretations and conclusions remain valid.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The original study investigated how the rapid shift to telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic affected HIV care. However, the initial publication contained two specific errors in Table 1:
- Inconsistent Thresholds: The authors originally reported viral suppression based on a threshold of $\le 20$ copies/mL but decided to update the results to reflect a $\le 50$ copies/mL threshold, which is a common clinical benchmark for "undetectable" status.
- Unit Typo: An explanatory footnote incorrectly listed the units for viral load as "copies/L" (liters) instead of the standard "copies/mL" (milliliters).
Methods
As this is a correction notice, it does not introduce new methods. It revisits the quantitative analysis of the original mixed-methods study. The primary change involves re-calculating the frequency ($n$) and percentage (%) of the patient cohort that met the revised "undetectable" criteria ($\le 50$ copies/mL).
Datasets
Not discussed in the correction. The data refers to the original patient cohort described in the primary study (found at https://doi.org/10.1007/s10461-021-03556-7).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Threshold Sensitivity: The correction highlights how sensitive descriptive statistics can be to clinical definitions. By shifting the threshold from 20 to 50 copies/mL, the number of patients classified as "undetectable" rose from 206 to 226.
- Stability of Interpretations: Despite a 7.3% increase in the reported rate of viral suppression within the sample, the authors emphasize that the core findings regarding the experience of telemedicine remain unchanged. This suggests that the study's conclusions were robust enough that they did not hinge on the specific granularity of the viral load threshold.
Key Results
The correction provides the following updated values for Table 1:
- Undetectable HIV viral load, n (%):
- Incorrect: 206 (75.5%)
- Correct: 226 (82.8%)
- Footnote Correction: The measurement unit was corrected from copies/L to copies/mL.
Limitations and Future Work
Not discussed in the correction notice.
Summary updated