Correction to: Debiasing versus knowledge retrieval checklists to reduce diagnostic error in ECG interpretation

Matthew Sibbald, Jonathan Sherbino, Jonathan S. Ilgen, Laura Zwaan, Sarah Blissett, Sandra Monteiro, Geoffrey R. NormanAdvances 2019 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

Diagnostic error remains a significant challenge in clinical practice, particularly in tasks requiring rapid pattern recognition such as Electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation. Medical educators have proposed various interventions to mitigate these errors, often focusing on either "debiasing" strategies—encouraging metacognition to avoid cognitive pitfalls—or "knowledge retrieval" (content) checklists that provide structured clinical prompts. This article presents a correction to a previous study, restoring critical data visualization that compares these two approaches across different levels of learner expertise.

Methods

The study employed an experimental design to evaluate the efficacy of instructional interventions on ECG interpretation accuracy. Participants were categorized into two groups: Novices and Experienced learners. They were tasked with interpreting a series of ECG cases under one of three conditions:

  1. Control: Standard interpretation without additional aids.
  2. Debiasing Checklist: A prompt-based intervention designed to help clinicians avoid common cognitive biases like premature closure.
  3. Content Checklist: A structured list of specific ECG features (e.g., PR interval, ST-segment morphology) to ensure systematic knowledge retrieval.

The primary outcome measure was the average number of diagnostic errors per ECG.

Results

The restored data (Figure 1) highlights the interplay between instructional aids and clinical experience.

Figure 1: Number of errors per ECG across different conditions and learner levels.

The most prominent finding is the substantial "expertise gap." Experienced learners consistently outperformed novices, maintaining an error rate of approximately 0.5 to 0.6 errors per ECG across all conditions. In contrast, novices in the control group averaged approximately 1.6 errors per ECG.

While both the debiasing and content checklists provided a measurable benefit for novices—reducing their error rate to approximately 1.4 errors per ECG—these interventions did not significantly impact the performance of experienced clinicians. Furthermore, the checklists were unable to bridge the performance gap between the two groups, suggesting that foundational clinical experience remains the primary determinant of diagnostic accuracy.

Discussion

The results suggest that while structured checklists can offer marginal gains for less experienced learners, they may have diminishing returns for experts whose intuitive processing is already highly refined. For novices, the slight improvement indicates that checklists may assist in systematic review, but they cannot substitute for the deep pattern recognition skills developed through clinical experience.

Future research should explore whether more specialized or context-sensitive checklists might be more effective in complex or ambiguous diagnostic scenarios where pattern recognition is less straightforward. Additionally, the timing of such interventions—whether used during or after initial interpretation—merits further investigation to optimize their pedagogical value.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sibbald2019correction,
  author = {Matthew Sibbald and Jonathan Sherbino and Jonathan S. Ilgen and Laura Zwaan and Sarah Blissett and Sandra Monteiro and Geoffrey R. Norman},
  title = {{Correction to: Debiasing versus knowledge retrieval checklists to reduce diagnostic error in ECG interpretation}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1007/s10459-019-09884-7},
}
Figure