Abstract
This formal correction notice addresses bibliographic omissions and data attribution errors in the article "From water to land: Evolution of photoreceptor circuits for vision in air" (DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.3002422). The updates ensure the accuracy of references regarding ancestral photoreceptor diversity and the specific datasets used to model avian visual sensitivity.
Introduction
Maintaining a precise scholarly record is essential in evolutionary biology, where tracing the lineage of complex traits like vision requires meticulous documentation. This correction serves to rectify specific gaps in the original publication's bibliography and figure legends, ensuring that the foundational data for modeling the transition of vision from aquatic to terrestrial environments is properly credited.
Addressing Bibliographic Gaps
The primary correction involves the completion of a foundational reference. In the original manuscript, a key work by Baden (2024) concerning ancestral photoreceptor diversity was cited without its full publication details. This correction provides the complete citation and DOI (10.1038/s41559-023-02291-7), which is critical for understanding the ancient roots of complex visual behaviors.
Data Attribution and Avian Modeling
A significant portion of the original study's modeling of "vision in air" relied on the spectral sensitivity of avian (chicken) cones. The correction clarifies the sources for these datasets:
- Spectral Sensitivity: Data for single cones and the principal member of double cones are now correctly attributed to references [125] and [126], respectively.
- Retinal Optics: The parameters for avian retinal optics, specifically the role of oil droplets as long-pass filters, are now properly cited as originating from the 2015 PhD thesis of D. Wilby at the University of Bristol.
Conclusion
By resolving these omissions, the correction reinforces the integrity of the original review. It ensures that researchers investigating the evolutionary transition of photoreceptor circuits have access to the correct primary sources and modeling parameters, facilitating future replication and extension of this work.
Summary updated