Correction: Corrigendum: Mechanism of Consistent Gyrus Formation: an Experimental and Computational Study

Tuo Zhang, Mir Jalil Razavi, Xiao Li, Hanbo Chen, Tianming Liu, Xianqiao WangScientific 2017 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This corrigendum provides critical technical updates to the methodology and data descriptions in the original article, "Mechanism of Consistent Gyrus Formation: an Experimental and Computational Study" (Scientific Reports 6, Article number: 37272). The update clarifies the specifications of the Human Fetal Brain Atlas Dataset, including the imaging hardware, sequence parameters, and the specific cohort of 80 fetuses used to construct the spatio-temporal models of cortical development.

Introduction

The study of gyrification—the complex biological and mechanical process by which the human brain develops its characteristic folds—is fundamental to understanding both normal neurodevelopment and the origins of various neurological disorders. In the original publication, the authors explored the "rules" governing gyrus formation through a combination of experimental data and computational simulations. However, several technical details regarding the primary dataset were misreported. This correction ensures that the biophysical models presented in the study are anchored in the correct empirical data, facilitating accurate replication and further research in the field.

Technical Methodology and Imaging Parameters

The accuracy of computational brain models is highly sensitive to the resolution and quality of the input MRI data. The corrigendum clarifies the following technical aspects of the data acquisition process:

Hardware and Pulse Sequences

Contrary to the original report of a 3T system, the data was acquired on a 1.5 T Philips Achieva MRI scanner. The imaging utilized a T2-weighted single-shot Fast Spin Echo (ssFSE) sequence. This sequence is particularly effective for fetal imaging due to its speed, which helps mitigate the effects of fetal motion. The specific timing parameters were a repetition time (TR) of 15000 ms and an echo time (TE) of 160 ms.

Slice-to-Volume Reconstruction

Fetal imaging presents unique challenges because the subject is constantly moving within the womb. To overcome this, researchers acquired multiple 2D image stacks in three orthogonal planes (transverse, sagittal, and coronal). These stacks were then computationally integrated using a slice-to-volume reconstruction technique. This process is essential for creating a coherent 3D volume from fragmented 2D data. The final reconstructed volume achieved an isotropic resolution of 1.18 mm, providing a consistent voxel size for the mechanical simulations of cortical folding.

Human Fetal Brain Atlas Dataset

The corrigendum provides a more precise description of the dataset used to build the 4D probabilistic atlas:

  • Cohort Composition: The atlas was constructed from 80 fetuses (corrected from the initial report of 142) who exhibited normal brain development.
  • Gestational Age Range: The dataset spans a critical period of development from 21.7 to 38.7 weeks of gestation, with a mean age of 29.6 ± 4.6 weeks. This range captures the transition from a relatively smooth brain surface to the highly folded structure seen near term.
  • Corrected Citation: The study relies on the spatio-temporal atlas framework developed by Serag et al. (2012). This work, published in NeuroImage, details the use of adaptive kernel regression to synthesize high-definition templates and tissue probability maps (including the brain mask, cortex, hemispheres, CSF, and ventricles) across the gestational period of 23–37 weeks.

Significance of the Correction

While the fundamental conclusions regarding the mechanisms of gyrus formation remain unchanged, these technical corrections are vital for the scientific community. For researchers in computational morphometry, the difference between 1.5T and 3T data, or the specific voxel resolution, can influence the calculation of cortical thickness and folding indices. By providing the correct reference and technical metadata, the authors ensure that their work remains a reliable benchmark for future studies into the mechanical forces shaping the human brain.

Summary updated

Abstract

Scientific Reports 6: Article number: 37272; published online: 17 November 2016; updated: 07 March 2017. In the methods section, under the subheading ‘Human Fetal Brain Atlas Dataset’ “Generally, this dataset includes T2 templates and tissue probability maps (for the brain mask, cortex, hemispheres,cerebrospinal fluid [CSF], and ventricles) for ages between 23–37 weeks of gestation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017correction,
  author = {Tuo Zhang and Mir Jalil Razavi and Xiao Li and Hanbo Chen and Tianming Liu and Xianqiao Wang},
  title = {{Correction: Corrigendum: Mechanism of Consistent Gyrus Formation: an Experimental and Computational Study}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/srep42269},
}

Loading related content...

Figure