Correction: Corrigendum: Experimental Certification of Random Numbers via Quantum Contextuality

Mark Um, Xiang Zhang, Junhua Zhang, Ye Wang, Yangchao Shen, Dong Deng, L.-m. Duan, Kihwan KimScientific 2018 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract: This corrigendum addresses a critical calculation error in the 2013 study "Experimental Certification of Random Numbers via Quantum Contextuality" (DOI: 10.1038/srep01627). The omission of specific correlation terms ($\langle V_i V_j \rangle$) in the original analysis led to an overestimation of the certified minimum entropy. This update revises the performance metrics downward, adjusting the certified randomness by over 50%. Despite these corrections, the experimental results continue to demonstrate a significant violation of classical bounds, confirming the validity of quantum contextuality as a resource for randomness certification.

Introduction

In quantum information science, the certification of "true" randomness relies on the violation of classical inequalities. The original research utilized the Klyachko-Can-Binicioğlu-Shumovsky (KCBS) inequality to prove that a bitstream generated by a trapped-ion system was inherently unpredictable. However, a subsequent review revealed that certain correlation terms representing measurement setting interactions were omitted from the final calculations of the expectation value $\hat{L}$ and the parameter $\chi'_{KCBS}$. This corrigendum provides the necessary mathematical and experimental adjustments to rectify these omissions.

Methodology and Corrections

The experimental setup involved a single trapped $^{171}\text{Yb}^+$ ion. To correct the previous analysis, the researchers updated the formulas for state preparation and rotation operations ($R_1, R_2$). Notably, the physical angles used in the experiment were corrected; for instance, the angle $\gamma$ was adjusted from $51.83^\circ$ to $103.68^\circ$. These changes directly impact the calculation of the KCBS violation, requiring a more rigorous accounting of the system's contextuality.

In the biased distribution trials, the authors clarified that $2 \times 10^5$ rounds were necessary to observe net randomness after accounting for the corrected parameters, compared to the $1 \times 10^5$ rounds originally reported.

Key Results and Revised Metrics

The inclusion of the previously omitted correlation terms resulted in a significant downward revision of the certified randomness. For a sequence of $10^5$ numbers, the guaranteed minimum entropy dropped from $5.2 \times 10^4$ bits to $2.4 \times 10^4$ bits.

Corrected min-entropy growth and KCBS expectation values for uniform and biased distributions.

As shown in Figure 1, the slopes for entropy growth are now more conservative. The expectation value $\hat{L}$, which quantifies the strength of the quantum violation, was corrected from $3.852 \pm 0.030$ to $3.594 \pm 0.034$. While this represents a decrease in the magnitude of the violation, the statistical significance remains robust at $18\sigma$ (down from the initial $31\sigma$), well above the threshold for classical behavior.

Statistical Validation

Despite the reduction in certified entropy, the generated bitstreams still pass standard statistical tests for randomness. The P-values for various tests (e.g., Frequency, Runs, Rank) remain well above the significance threshold of 0.01 for both uniform and biased settings.

P-values for various random tests, demonstrating that the corrected bitstreams maintain high statistical quality.

Conclusion

This corrigendum serves as a vital update to the field of quantum metrology, highlighting the sensitivity of entropy certification to experimental nuances. While the "certified" output is lower than initially claimed, the core achievement—the experimental demonstration of randomness via quantum contextuality—is preserved. This self-correction underscores the importance of rigorous mathematical accounting in the development of secure quantum technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

This corrects the article DOI: 10.1038/srep01627.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{um2018correction,
  author = {Mark Um and Xiang Zhang and Junhua Zhang and Ye Wang and Yangchao Shen and Dong Deng and L.-M. Duan and Kihwan Kim},
  title = {{Correction: Corrigendum: Experimental Certification of Random Numbers via Quantum Contextuality}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/srep46927},
}

Loading related content...

Figure