Correction: Brain Extraction Using Label Propagation and Group Agreement: Pincram

Rolf A. Heckemann, Christian Ledig, Katherine R. Gray, Paul Aljabar, Daniel Rueckert, Joseph V. Hajnal, Alexander HammersPLoS 2015 · DOI · OpenAlex

This article serves as a formal correction to the original publication of the Pincram brain extraction method. The correction addresses a layout error where Figure 1 and Figure 2 were inadvertently swapped. This summary details the Pincram methodology and its validated performance across multiple MRI datasets.

Introduction to Pincram

Brain extraction, or "skull stripping," is a vital initial step in neuroimaging pipelines, isolating brain tissue from non-brain structures like the skull, scalp, and eyes. Pincram (Propagation and Group Agreement) is designed to overcome common issues such as overinclusion (leaving non-brain tissue) and underinclusion (accidentally removing brain tissue) by utilizing a multi-atlas consensus strategy.

Methodology

The Pincram workflow follows a robust multi-step approach to ensure accuracy:

  1. Atlas Registration & Propagation: A library of expert-labeled atlases is registered to the target image, and their brain masks are transformed into the target space.
  2. Ranking and Selection: Propagated masks are ranked based on their fit to the target image.
  3. Fusion and Consensus: A "fuzzy label" is generated by summing the labels from the top-ranked subset of masks.
  4. Refinement: This label is thresholded to produce both "tight" and "wide" margin masks, providing flexibility for various neuroimaging applications.

Evaluation and Results

The Pincram method was evaluated against manual reference masks across four distinct datasets: O, H, L, and X. Performance was quantified using the Jaccard Coefficient (JC), a standard metric for measuring overlap where 1.0 represents a perfect match.

Qualitative brain extraction results for datasets O, H, L, and X. Green indicates overinclusion (extra tissue), and red indicates underinclusion (missing tissue).

The quantitative results confirm the method's high accuracy and consistency:

  • Dataset O: 0.9512 JC
  • Dataset H: 0.9704 JC
  • Dataset L: 0.9647 JC
  • Dataset X: 0.9503 JC

With all scores exceeding 0.95, Pincram demonstrates a high degree of reliability for automated skull stripping across diverse imaging conditions and orientations.

Summary updated

Abstract

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0129211.].
BibTeX
@inproceedings{heckemann2015correction,
  author = {Rolf A. Heckemann and Christian Ledig and Katherine R. Gray and Paul Aljabar and Daniel Rueckert and Joseph V. Hajnal and Alexander Hammers},
  title = {{Correction: Brain Extraction Using Label Propagation and Group Agreement: Pincram}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0135746},
}

Loading related content...

Figure