Competitive Advantages of Cross-Border M&As to Non-Location-Bound Chinese ICT Firms

Yan Chen, Fei Li, Jaime Ortiz, Wenbo GuoIntechOpen 2020 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In the global race for technological supremacy, emerging market multinational enterprises (EMNEs), particularly from China’s Information and Communications Technology (ICT) sector, have increasingly turned to cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&As). These deals are often framed as a "springboard" strategy—a way to rapidly acquire the advanced technology, brands, and management expertise necessary to compete with established global leaders. However, a critical question remains: do these acquisitions truly enhance a firm's global competitiveness, or do they merely strengthen its position within its domestic market?

Theoretical Framework: HCB vs. NLB Advantage

To understand the impact of M&As, this research distinguishes between two types of competitive advantage:

  1. Home-Country-Bound (HCB) Advantage: Efficiencies, such as economies of scale, that are specific to the firm's operations within its domestic market.
  2. Non-Location-Bound (NLB) Advantage: Technical efficiencies and innovations that are transferable across borders, allowing the firm to compete effectively in any international market.
Conceptual framework of how cross-border M&As influence home-country-bound and non-location-bound competitive advantages.

The study posits that while M&As provide access to external strategic assets, the ultimate impact on a firm's competitive advantage depends on how these assets are bundled with existing regional and non-regional resources.

Methodology and Data

The researchers analyzed a dataset of 98 completed cross-border M&A transactions by Chinese ICT firms between 2010 and 2017. Data was sourced from the BVD (Zephyr) database for deal specifics and CSMAR for the financial performance of listed companies.

Descriptive statistics of the cross-border M&A sample analyzed in the study.

To isolate the causal effect of M&As, the study employed a robust econometric toolkit including Propensity Score Matching (PSM) to create a control group and Differences-in-Differences (DID) to measure the performance shift. Crucially, Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA) was used to mathematically decompose productivity into scale efficiency (HCB) and pure technical efficiency (NLB).

Key Findings

The "Crowding-Out" Effect

The most significant finding is that cross-border M&As often inhibit the development of non-location-bound advantages. This is attributed to a "crowding-out" effect: the immense financial and managerial resources required to execute and integrate an international acquisition often lead firms to reduce their internal Research and Development (R&D) spending. By trading internal innovation for external asset acquisition, firms may inadvertently stall their progress toward global technical leadership.

Home-Field Gains vs. Global Stagnation

While M&As did not significantly boost NLB advantages, they were highly effective at improving HCB advantages. By acquiring foreign assets, Chinese ICT firms were able to better exploit the massive scale of their domestic market. However, these gains were found to be short-lived, typically peaking within two years post-merger and weakening thereafter.

The Role of Ownership and Experience

The study highlights a "State-Owned Enterprise (SOE) Paradox." Despite having superior access to capital and government backing, SOEs were less effective than private firms at translating M&As into competitive advantages. This is likely due to non-economic objectives and challenges in integrating foreign assets. Conversely, firms with prior international experience were the only group that successfully improved their NLB advantages, underscoring the importance of organizational learning in global expansion.

Conclusion

For Chinese ICT firms, cross-border M&As serve more as a tool for domestic consolidation than a guaranteed ticket to global dominance. The findings suggest that managers must be wary of the "crowding-out" effect on R&D and focus on long-term post-merger integration to ensure that acquired strategic assets translate into transferable, non-location-bound advantages.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&As) undertaken by emerging market firms have been associated with competitive advantage. However, little research has focused on the transferability of this enhanced competitive advantage. Even less is known about the role played by state-owned enterprises. This paper investigates whether Chinese information and communications technology firms that undertake cross-border M&As can improve their non-location bound competitive advantage. We used cross-border data between 2010 and 2017 and propensity-score matching and differences-in-differences approaches. We found that cross-border M&As significantly improve the home-country-bound competitive advantage. However, the effect on non-location bound competitive advantage is not significant. From the perspective of impact mechanism, this is due to a crowding-out effect of cross-border M&As on research and development (R&D) investment which inhibits non-location bound advantages. It also results from state-owned enterprises which are generally considered to have institutional advantages, not effectively using cross-border M&As to enhance their competitive advantages. This research distinguishes and quantifies home-country-bound competitive advantage and non-location bound competitive advantage and establishes a framework for how cross-border M&As enhance enterprise competitive advantage. It provides an explanation for the extant research on whether state-owned enterprises can enhance their competitive advantage through cross-border M&As, and what kind of advantage they attain.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2020competitive,
  author = {Yan Chen and Fei Li and Jaime Ortiz and Wenbo Guo},
  title = {{Competitive Advantages of Cross-Border M\&As to Non-Location-Bound Chinese ICT Firms}},
  booktitle = {IntechOpen},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.5772/intechopen.94032},
}
Figure