Comment on wes-2021-157

Sarah Barber, Julien Deparday, Yuriy Marykovskiy, Eleni Chatzi, Imad Abdallah, Gregory Duthé, Michele Magno, Tommaso Polonelli, Raphael Fischer, Hanna Mã ⁄ llerOpenalex Unknown 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract As the wind energy industry is maturing and wind turbines are becoming larger, there is an increasing need for cost-effective monitoring and data analysis solutions to understand the complex aerodynamic and acoustic behaviour of the flexible blades. Published measurements on operating rotor blades in real conditions are very scarce due to the complexity of the installation and use of measurement systems. However, recent developments in electronics, wireless communication and MEMS (micro-electromechanical systems) sensors are making it possible to acquire data in a cost-effective and energy-efficient way. In this work, therefore, a cost-effective MEMS-based aerodynamic and acoustic wireless measurement system that is thin, non-intrusive, easy to install, low power and self-sustaining is designed and tested in a wind tunnel. The measurement system does not require an electrical connection to the wind turbine and can be mounted and removed without damaging the blade. The results show that the system is capable of delivering relevant results continuously, although work needs to be done on calibrating and correcting the pressure signals as well as on refining the concept for the attachment sleeve for weather protection in the field. Finally, two methods for using the measurements to provide added value to the wind energy industry are developed and demonstrated: (1) inferring the local angle of attack via stagnation point detection using differential pressure sensors near the leading edge and (2) detecting and classifying leading edge erosion using instantaneous snapshots of the measured pressure fields. Ongoing work involves field tests on a 6 kW operating wind turbine in Switzerland.

Introduction

As wind turbines scale to unprecedented sizes, their blades become increasingly flexible, leading to complex aerodynamic and acoustic behaviors that are difficult to predict with standard models. To optimize performance and mitigate noise, high-fidelity data from operating rotors is essential. However, traditional measurement systems are often intrusive, requiring structural modifications like drilling holes for pressure taps or installing heavy internal cabling. These methods are labor-intensive, expensive, and potentially damaging to the blade's structural integrity.

To bridge the gap between simulation and real-world measurement, researchers have developed "Aerosense," a thin, wireless, MEMS-based "smart skin." This system is designed to provide a low-power, "plug-and-play" solution for monitoring turbine blades without permanent modifications.

System Design and Methodology

The Aerosense system centers on a sensor node integrated into a 4mm-thick flexible 3D-printed sleeve (PolyJet) that wraps around the blade. This non-intrusive design ensures that the sensors do not significantly disrupt the airflow they are intended to measure.

The Aerosense sensor node integrated into a flexible 3D-printed sleeve mounted on an airfoil section.

Hardware and Connectivity

The node features a comprehensive suite of MEMS sensors:

  • 40 absolute barometers for pressure mapping.
  • 10 wide-range microphones for acoustic monitoring.
  • Differential pressure sensors for stagnation point detection.
  • Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU) for motion tracking.

Data is transmitted via Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) 5.0. To overcome BLE's bandwidth limitations (1 Mbps) when handling high-frequency acoustic data, the system employs 512MB of on-board flash memory and data compression algorithms. The system is self-sustaining, utilizing a solar energy harvester and battery to eliminate the need for external power connections.

System architecture showing the data flow from the sensor node on the blade to the base station and cloud-based digital twin.

Digital Twin Integration

The data pipeline connects the physical sensors to a cloud-based "digital twin." This twin uses inverse solvers (such as XFOIL and OpenFOAM) and Machine Learning (ML) models to translate raw pressure readings into actionable aerodynamic insights.

Validation and Datasets

The system was validated using three primary data sources:

  1. Small-scale Wind Tunnel (OST): A vertical axis wind turbine model tested the system's rotation and wireless transmission capabilities in a dynamic environment.
  2. High-fidelity Wind Tunnel (ETH Zurich): A 3D-printed NACA0018 airfoil section validated the Angle of Attack (AoA) estimation against high-precision flush-mounted pressure taps.
  3. Synthetic CFD Data: Approximately 300 CFD simulations (OpenFOAM) were used to train a PointNet neural network to recognize the pressure signatures associated with various stages of leading-edge erosion (LEE).

Key Insights

Stagnation Point Detection

Determining the local angle of attack on a moving blade is challenging because the blade's own motion influences the incoming flow. Aerosense bypasses the need for a far-field reference by analyzing the pressure gradient at the leading edge to locate the stagnation point. This method allows for accurate, local AoA inference.

Erosion Classification

Leading-edge erosion alters surface roughness and subtly modifies the pressure field. The study demonstrated that ML models can identify these patterns in instantaneous pressure snapshots, offering a potential path for early damage detection before energy production is significantly impacted.

Results and Performance

  • Operational Reliability: The system successfully demonstrated continuous data recording and transmission from a rotating airfoil.
  • AoA Accuracy: The stagnation point method achieved an estimation error of less than $\pm 2.5^\circ$ for pre-stall conditions.
  • Erosion Detection: The ML approach showed high promise in classifying erosion severity, though accuracy decreased at higher angles of attack where flow separation occurs.
  • Aerodynamic Profile: The 4mm sleeve thickness remains below 0.3% of the chord for large-scale turbines, minimizing its aerodynamic footprint.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While promising, several challenges remain. MEMS barometers exhibit sensitivity to centrifugal forces and temperature, requiring a correction factor (approximately 5 Pa per g of acceleration). Furthermore, the 3D-printed sleeve requires further refinement for long-term durability against UV, rain, and lightning in field environments. Ongoing work includes field testing on a 6 kW turbine in Switzerland to evaluate the system's performance in real-world conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> As the wind energy industry is maturing and wind turbines are becoming larger, there is an increasing need for cost-effective monitoring and data analysis solutions to understand the complex aerodynamic and acoustic behaviour of the flexible blades. Published measurements on operating rotor blades in real conditions are very scarce due to the complexity of the installation and use of measurement systems. However, recent developments in electronics, wireless communication and MEMS (micro-electromechanical systems) sensors are making it possible to acquire data in a cost-effective and energy-efficient way. In this work, therefore, a cost-effective MEMS-based aerodynamic and acoustic wireless measurement system that is thin, non-intrusive, easy to install, low power and self-sustaining is designed and tested in a wind tunnel. The measurement system does not require an electrical connection to the wind turbine and can be mounted and removed without damaging the blade.The results show that the system is capable of delivering relevant results continuously, although work needs to be done on calibrating and correcting the pressure signals as well as on refining the concept for the attachment sleeve for weather protection in the field. Finally, two methods for using the measurements to provide added value to the wind energy industry are developed and demonstrated: (1) inferring the local angle of attack via stagnation point detection using differential pressure sensors near the leading edge and (2) detecting and classifying leading edge erosion using instantaneous snapshots of the measured pressure fields. Ongoing work involves field tests on a 6 kW operating wind turbine in Switzerland.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{barber2022comment,
  author = {Sarah Barber and Julien Deparday and Yuriy Marykovskiy and Eleni Chatzi and Imad Abdallah and Gregory Duthé and Michele Magno and Tommaso Polonelli and Raphael Fischer and Hanna Mà ⁄ ller},
  title = {{Comment on wes-2021-157}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5194/wes-2021-157-rc2},
}
Figure