Comment on nhess-2023-44

Chao Zhou, Yue Wang, Ying Cao, Ramesh P. Singh, Bayes Ahmed, Mahdi Motagh, Yang Wang, Ling ChenOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Landslide susceptibility mapping (LSM) is vital for disaster mitigation and early warning systems. However, traditional machine learning approaches often suffer from poor "non-landslide" sample selection and the limited accuracy of individual classifiers. This study addresses these issues by introducing a constrained sampling strategy using Logistic Regression (LR) and applying ensemble learning techniques—Bagging and Boosting—to Classification and Regression Trees (CART) and Multi-Layer Perceptrons (MLP). Focusing on the Zigui-Badong section of China’s Three Gorges Reservoir Area (TGRA), the research identifies elevation and distance to rivers as primary causal factors. The results demonstrate that the LR-MLP-Boosting model achieved the highest predictive accuracy (AUC = 0.986), significantly outperforming individual classifiers and traditional random sampling methods.

Introduction

Predicting landslide occurrence is a complex challenge involving nonlinear relationships between terrain, geology, and environmental triggers. While machine learning (ML) has become a standard tool for LSM, the quality of the training data—specifically the selection of "non-landslide" (negative) samples—is often overlooked. Randomly selecting negative samples from any non-landslide area can introduce noise, as these areas might possess the geological conditions for failure but haven't yet experienced a landslide. This study proposes a refined workflow to improve both sample quality and model performance.

Methods and Materials

Study Area

The research focused on the Zigui-Badong section of the TGRA, a region characterized by intense human engineering and fluctuating reservoir water levels, which contribute to high landslide frequency. A total of 179 landslides were identified for the study.

Data Preparation

Twelve influencing factors were selected, including altitude, slope, lithology, and proximity to rivers and faults. The dataset was split into 70% for training and 30% for validation.

Modeling Workflow

  1. Constrained Sampling: A preliminary Logistic Regression (LR) model was used to map susceptibility. Non-landslide samples were then exclusively selected from "Very Low" susceptibility zones to ensure high-quality negative training data.
  2. Base Classifiers: Two distinct ML models were employed: CART (decision tree) and MLP (neural network).
  3. Ensemble Techniques: To enhance these base learners, the researchers applied Bagging (parallel processing to reduce variance) and Boosting (sequential processing to reduce bias).

Results and Discussion

Factor Importance

Quantitative analysis using Information Value (IV) revealed that elevation (specifically <240 m) and distance to rivers (<300 m) were the most significant drivers of landslide development in the study area. This underscores the impact of reservoir operations on slope stability.

Model Performance

The integration of constrained sampling and ensemble learning yielded superior results across all metrics. The Area Under the Curve (AUC) values for the primary models were:

  • LR-MLP-Boosting: 0.986 (Highest performance)
  • LR-CART-Boosting: 0.981
  • LR-MLP-Bagging: 0.978
  • LR-CART-Bagging: 0.973

In comparison, models using traditional random sampling (NO-constraint) performed significantly worse. For instance, the basic LR-MLP model achieved an AUC of approximately 0.901, while the ensemble version reached 0.986—an improvement of roughly 8.5%.

Conclusion

The combination of ensemble learning and constrained sample selection effectively addresses the "garbage in, garbage out" problem in landslide susceptibility mapping. By using a simple model (LR) to define a "safe zone" for negative samples and advanced ensemble techniques (Boosting/Bagging) to handle complex terrain data, researchers can produce highly accurate maps. These high-fidelity maps are essential for monitoring and developing early warning systems in landslide-prone regions like the Three Gorges Reservoir.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> In recent years, several catastrophic landslide events have been observed throughout the globe, significantly affecting the loss of lives, infrastructure, everyday life and livelihood. To minimize the impact of landslides and issue early warnings, landslide susceptibility maps (LSM) are essential. Aim to improve the accuracy of LSM, this study applied a random selection of non-landslide samples and low accuracy of individual classifiers using machine learning (ML) techniques, coupled with ensemble learning and ML, for LSM. China's Zigui-Badong section of the Three Gorges Reservoir area (TGRA) was considered a case study. Twelve influencing factors were selected as inputs for modelling, and the relationship between each causal factor and landslide spatial development was quantitatively analyzed. A total of 179 landslides were identified in the present study. About 70 % of the landslide pixels were randomly considered for training, and the remaining 30 % were used for validation. The Logistic Regression model (LR) was applied to produce an initial susceptibility map, and the non-landslide samples were selected within the classified low-susceptibility area. Subsequently, two ML classifiers &ndash; the Classification and Regression Tree (CART), and the Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP), and four coupling models &ndash; the CART-Bagging, CART-Boosting, MLP-Bagging, and MLP-Boosting, were utilized for LSM. Finally, the receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curve and statistical analysis were applied for accuracy assessment. The results show that elevation and distance to rivers were the main causal factors of landslide development in the study area. The modeling accuracy of LR-MLP was calculated approx. 0.901, which is higher than the LR-CART (0.889). The LR-MLP-Boosting performed the best with an accuracy of 0.986 followed by the LR-CART-Bagging (0.973), LR-CART-Boosting (0.981), and LR-MLP-Bagging (0.978). The accuracy has been improved compared with the NO-CART, NO-MLP, NO-CART-Bagging, NO-CART-Boosting, NO-MLP-Bagging, and NO-MLP-Boosting models. Four ensemble models outperformed their corresponding classifiers, while Boosting outperforms Bagging. Overall, the combination of ensemble learning and ML effectively improved the accuracy of LSM. The LR model can effectively constrain the selection range of non-landslide samples and enhance the quality of sample selection. Our results show promise to map susceptible landslides locations which will help to monitor for an early warning of the landside.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2023comment,
  author = {Chao Zhou and Yue Wang and Ying Cao and Ramesh P. Singh and Bayes Ahmed and Mahdi Motagh and Yang Wang and Ling Chen},
  title = {{Comment on nhess-2023-44}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/nhess-2023-44-rc1},
}
Figure