Comment on essd-2021-176

Alessandro Cicoira, Samuel Weber, Andreas Biri, Ben Buchli, Reynald Delaloye, Reto Da Forno, Isabelle Gärtner‐Roer, Stephan Gruber, Tonio Gsell, Andreas Hasler, Roman Lim, Philippe​​​​​​​ Limpach, Raphaël Mayoraz, Matthias Meyer, Jeannette Noetzli, Marcia Phillips, Eric Pointner, Hugo Raetzo, Cristian Scapozza​​​​​​​, Tazio Strozzi, Lothar Thiele, Andreas Vieli, Daniel Vonder Mã ⁄ hll, Vanessa Wirz, Jan BeutelOpenalex Unknown 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract Monitoring of the periglacial environment is relevant for many disciplines including glaciology, natural hazard management, geomorphology, and geodesy. Since October 2022, Rock Glacier Velocity (RGV) is a new Essential Climate Variable (ECV) product within the Global Climate Observing System (GCOS). However, geodetic surveys at high elevation remain very challenging due to environmental and logistical reasons. During the past decades, the introduction of low-cost global navigation satellite system (GNSS) technologies has allowed us to increase the accuracy and frequency of the observations. Today, permanent GNSS instruments enable continuous surface displacement observations at millimetre accuracy with a sub-daily resolution. In this paper, we describe decennial time series of GNSS observables as well as accompanying meteorological data. The observations comprise 54 positions located on different periglacial landforms (rock glaciers, landslides, and steep rock walls) at altitudes ranging from 2304 to 4003 m a.s.l. and spread across the Swiss Alps. The primary data products consist of raw GNSS observables in RINEX format, inclinometers, and weather station data. Additionally, cleaned and aggregated time series of the primary data products are provided, including daily GNSS positions derived through two independent processing tool chains. The observations documented here extend beyond the dataset presented in the paper and are currently continued with the intention of long-term monitoring. An annual update of the dataset is planned. With its future continuation, the dataset holds potential for advancing fundamental process understanding and for the development of applied methods in support of e.g. natural hazard management.

Introduction

High-mountain periglacial environments—areas characterized by permafrost and shifting landforms—are sensitive indicators of global warming. Rock Glacier Velocity (RGV) has recently been designated an "Essential Climate Variable" (ECV), yet collecting consistent data at high elevations is notoriously difficult. Traditional geodetic surveys are often too infrequent to capture sub-daily or seasonal dynamics, and the harsh environment (extreme cold, heavy snow, lack of infrastructure) makes permanent installations a major engineering challenge. There is a critical need for long-term, high-frequency datasets to understand the fundamental processes driving these movements and to improve early-warning systems for natural hazards like landslides and rockfalls.

Methods

The authors leverage the PermaSense infrastructure, a custom-designed wireless sensor network (WSN) tailored for extreme environments. Key technical highlights include:

  • Low-Cost GNSS: Using commodity L1-GNSS receivers (u-blox LEA-6T) and active antennas to achieve high-precision results at a fraction of the cost of geodetic-grade equipment.
  • Double-Difference Processing: Data is processed using two independent toolchains—the industry-standard Bernese GNSS Software and the open-source RTKLIB—to derive daily static positions with millimeter accuracy.
  • Tilt Correction: A novel integration of MEMS two-axis inclinometers allows researchers to correct for the rotation of the boulders on which sensors are mounted, a common source of error in periglacial monitoring.
  • Near-Real-Time Communication: A hybrid WLAN backbone and low-power WSN enable data retrieval from remote valleys where cellular coverage is non-existent.
Overview of the PermaSense GNSS sensor system and its components.

Datasets

The paper introduces a comprehensive dataset (roughly 2011–2021) available via the PANGAEA repository. It includes:

  • 54 Observation Positions: Located on rock glaciers, landslides, and steep rock walls across five major regions of the Swiss Alps (e.g., Mattertal, Engadine), at altitudes ranging from 2304 to 4003 m a.s.l.
  • Raw and Derived Data: Includes raw GNSS observables (RINEX format), inclinometer readings, and weather data (temperature, pressure, humidity, wind, precipitation, and radiation).
  • Metadata: Detailed protocol sheets for every sensor intervention, ensuring data reproducibility and transparency.
Map of the 54 GNSS sensor locations across the Swiss Alps, categorized by landform type.

Key Insights

  • The "Moving" Reference: One of the most surprising findings was that some reference stations, initially assumed to be stable, were actually moving. For example, station RL01 moved several centimeters per year, highlighting the extreme difficulty of finding truly "fixed" ground in periglacial zones.
  • Inclinometers are Essential: The authors demonstrate that surface boulders don't just slide; they rotate. Without inclinometer data to correct for mast tilt, displacement measurements can be significantly skewed, leading to false interpretations of landform velocity.
  • Climate Sensitivity: The decennial time series clearly captures how rock glacier velocities respond to seasonal temperature fluctuations and long-term warming trends, reinforcing their utility as climate indicators.
  • Catastrophic Failure Tracking: The system successfully captured the "death" of a sensor (GG02) as the boulder it was on accelerated exponentially before falling into a gully. This provides rare, high-resolution data on the kinematic lead-up to a rockfall event.

Key Results

  • Decade-Long Coverage: Successful operation of a distributed sensor network for over 10 years at altitudes up to 4003 m a.s.l.
  • High Precision: Achievement of millimeter-level accuracy in surface displacement with sub-daily resolution using low-cost hardware.
  • Massive Data Volume: The dataset comprises over 263 million data points, providing an unprecedented look at alpine kinematics.
  • Operational Proof-of-Concept: The study proves that low-cost GNSS technology, when combined with robust processing and tilt correction, is a viable and scalable alternative to expensive geodetic equipment for long-term environmental monitoring.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Interruptions: Heavy snow cover and prolonged periods without sunlight in winter can lead to power failures and data gaps, as solar panels become obscured.
  • Validation Gaps: Due to the extreme and dangerous locations, independent validation measurements (like manual surveys) are often impossible, meaning researchers must rely heavily on internal consistency and quality metrics.
  • Future Directions: The authors plan annual updates to the dataset. Future research will focus on integrating this high-resolution data into mechanical models to better predict landform destabilization and improve natural hazard management strategies for alpine communities.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Monitoring of the periglacial environment is relevant for many disciplines including glaciology, natural hazard management, geomorphology, and geodesy. Since October 2022, Rock Glacier Velocity (RGV) is a new Essential Climate Variable (ECV) product within the Global Climate Observing System (GCOS). However, geodetic surveys at high elevation remain very challenging due to environmental and logistical reasons. During the past decades, the introduction of low-cost global navigation satellite system (GNSS) technologies has allowed us to increase the accuracy and frequency of the observations. Today, permanent GNSS instruments enable continuous surface displacement observations at millimetre accuracy with a sub-daily resolution. In this paper, we describe decennial time series of GNSS observables as well as accompanying meteorological data. The observations comprise 54 positions located on different periglacial landforms (rock glaciers, landslides, and steep rock walls) at altitudes ranging from 2304 to 4003 <span class="inline-formula"><math xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" id="M1" display="inline" overflow="scroll" dspmath="mathml"><mrow class="unit"><mi mathvariant="normal">m</mi><mspace width="0.125em" linebreak="nobreak"/><mi mathvariant="normal">a</mi><mo>.</mo><mi mathvariant="normal">s</mi><mo>.</mo><mi mathvariant="normal">l</mi><mo>.</mo></mrow></math><span><svg:svg xmlns:svg="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="36pt" height="10pt" class="svg-formula" dspmath="mathimg" md5hash="c66ba9c58375fb02029941ba18d549da"><svg:image xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="essd-14-5061-2022-ie00001.svg" width="36pt" height="10pt" src="essd-14-5061-2022-ie00001.png"/></svg:svg></span></span> and spread across the Swiss Alps. The primary data products consist of raw GNSS observables in RINEX format, inclinometers, and weather station data. Additionally, cleaned and aggregated time series of the primary data products are provided, including daily GNSS positions derived through two independent processing tool chains. The observations documented here extend beyond the dataset presented in the paper and are currently continued with the intention of long-term monitoring. An annual update of the dataset, available at <a href="https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.948334">https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.948334</a> <span class="cit" id="xref_paren.1">(<a href="#bib1.bibx6">Beutel et al.</a>, <a href="#bib1.bibx6">2022</a>)</span>,​​​​​​​ is planned. With its future continuation, the dataset holds potential for advancing fundamental process understanding and for the development of applied methods in support of e.g. natural hazard management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cicoira2021comment,
  author = {Alessandro Cicoira and Samuel Weber and Andreas Biri and Ben Buchli and Reynald Delaloye and Reto Da Forno and Isabelle Gärtner‐Roer and Stephan Gruber and Tonio Gsell and Andreas Hasler and Roman Lim and Philippe​​​​​​​ Limpach and Raphaël Mayoraz and Matthias Meyer and Jeannette Noetzli and Marcia Phillips and Eric Pointner and Hugo Raetzo and Cristian Scapozza​​​​​​​ and Tazio Strozzi and Lothar Thiele and Andreas Vieli and Daniel Vonder Mà ⁄ hll and Vanessa Wirz and Jan Beutel},
  title = {{Comment on essd-2021-176}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5194/essd-2021-176-rc2},
}
Figure