Comment on egusphere-2024-884

Kaiheng Hu, Manish Raj Gouli, Hao Li, Yong Nie, Yifan Shu, Shuang Liu, Pu Li, Xiaopeng ZhangOpenalex Unknown 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

As glaciers worldwide retreat due to climate change, the proliferation of proglacial lakes presents an escalating risk of Glacial Lake Outburst Floods (GLOFs). While the immediate, often catastrophic, geomorphic impacts of these events—such as massive erosion and sedimentation—are well-documented, their long-term ecological consequences frequently remain overlooked. A recent study published as a preprint in EGUsphere provides a detailed forensic reconstruction of a 1991 GLOF at Rijieco (27.963° N, 88.9° E) in the eastern Himalayas, Tibet, China. This research highlights a sobering reality: while the flood itself lasted only hours, the ecological scars on the high-altitude Tibetan landscape have persisted for over three decades.

The 1991 Rijieco Event: Triggers and Timing

The Rijieco GLOF was previously a "publicly lesser-known" event. By analyzing historical Landsat imagery, researchers narrowed the occurrence of the flood to a window between September 21 and October 7, 1991. Before the disaster, the lake's surface area had grown from 0.34 km² in 1977 to 0.43 km² in 1991, directly fueled by a 0.27 km² reduction in the parent glacier.

The study identifies a "priming effect" as the likely trigger. In the two months preceding the outburst, local hydrometeorological data showed precipitation levels 100 mm higher than the multi-year mean. This extreme moisture, combined with an elevated temperature anomaly in the month of the disaster, likely destabilized the surrounding slopes. The most probable immediate trigger was an ice avalanche from the southwest portion of the glacier into the lake, initiating the breach of the moraine dam.

Forensic Methodology: Combining Remote Sensing and Fieldwork

To reconstruct the event, the researchers employed an integrated methodology:

  • Remote Sensing: Landsat imagery (1977–2020) was used to calculate indices such as NDVI (vegetation), NDWI (water), and EVI to track the evolution of the lake, glaciers, and downstream ecosystems.
  • Field Surveys: In June 2023, the team used UAVs and laser rangefinders to measure the physical dimensions of the dam breach, which stands 31 meters high and 75 meters wide.
  • Hydrodynamic Modeling: The HEC-RAS 2D model, utilizing the Froehlich (1995) equation for breach parameters, simulated the flood's progression. A "bulking factor" of 1.3 was applied to account for the transition from clear water to a sediment-heavy debris flow.

Flood Dynamics and Natural Buffering

The reconstruction estimates that approximately 6 million m³ of impounded water was released during the GLOF. The peak discharge at the dam reached a massive 2,900 m³/s. However, the study reveals the critical role of natural landscape features in mitigating downstream damage.

As the flood moved toward the Duoqing Lake, an inland lake approximately 50 km away, the discharge attenuated significantly. It dropped first to around 200 m³/s at the Kazu alluvial fan and finally to 45 m³/s upon entering Duoqing Lake. Despite this attenuation, the sudden influx of water and sediment expanded the Duoqing water area by 12.2% (approx. 8.5 km²) and severely disturbed the vegetation along its margins.

Decades of Ecological Stagnation

Perhaps the most significant finding of the study is the lack of ecological recovery in the flood's wake. The transported sediments silted an area of $1.0 \times 10^6 \text{ m}^2$ across the channel and floodplain. Satellite analysis shows that NDVI values in these areas dropped from 0.1 (indicating sparse vegetation) to -0.07 (representing bare soil or sediment) immediately after the flood.

Remarkably, over 32 years later, new vegetation has yet to recover in these silted zones. In the fragile, high-altitude Himalayan environment, the geomorphic changes induced by a GLOF can lead to effectively irreversible ecological damage on human timescales.

Implications for Future Hazard Assessment

The study underscores the need for a holistic "process chain" approach to GLOF risk assessment, moving beyond immediate geomorphic impacts to include long-term ecological health. The authors note that the lack of real-time monitoring—such as water level sensors and weather stations—in these remote catchments remains a major hurdle for early warning systems. As glaciers continue to detach from their parent reservoirs, installing field-based instruments to monitor high-risk lakes is essential for protecting both downstream communities and sensitive ecosystems.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> We investigate and reconstruct a publicly lesser-known glacial lake outburst flood that happened at a moraine-dammed proglacial lake &ndash; Rijieco (27.963&deg; N, 88.9&deg; E) in the eastern Himalayas, Tibet, China, more than thirty years ago. Satellite images interpret that from 1977 to 1991, the surface area of Rijieco increased from 0.34 km<sup>2</sup> to 0.43 km<sup>2</sup>, along with a reduction of 0.27 km<sup>2</sup> in the glacial area, and subsequently dropped to 0.24 km<sup>2</sup> after the GLOF. Further inspection of the 1991 images narrows down the date of occurrence of the Rijieco GLOF to between 21 September &ndash; 7 October 1991. The most probable triggering mechanism of the GLOF is an avalanche from the south-west part of the glacial lake because the local hydrometeorological data show precipitation of 100 mm higher than the multi-year mean in the preceding two months and an elevated temperature anomaly in the month of the disaster, combined with a sufficient topographic potential of the slope. Based on the field-measured dimension of the dam gap (31 m high and 75 m wide) and local topography, it is estimated that nearly 6 million m<sup>3</sup> of impounded water was released during the GLOF. The reconstruction of the outburst flood with the HEC-RAS 2D hydrodynamic model shows that the flood peak discharge at the dam was 2900 m<sup>3</sup>/s and then attenuated first to around 200 m<sup>3</sup>/s at the alluvial fan and 45 m<sup>3</sup>/s at the entrance to the Duoqing lake, an inland lake about 50 km away from the dam. The sudden release of the impounded water and large volumes of entrained sediment shortly expanded the Duoqing water area by 12.2 % and strongly disturbed its margin vegetation. The transported sediments silted an area of 1.0&times;10<sup>6</sup> m<sup>2</sup> of the channel and flood plain where new vegetation has not yet recovered. The harm of GLOFs to the lake ecosystem in the high-altitude Himalayan region may not be repaired in a short period. This study reveals short-term geomorphic impacts of GLOFs and noticeable but less mentioned long-term ecological impacts on a Tibetan inland lake system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2024comment,
  author = {Kaiheng Hu and Manish Raj Gouli and Hao Li and Yong Nie and Yifan Shu and Shuang Liu and Pu Li and Xiaopeng Zhang},
  title = {{Comment on egusphere-2024-884}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5194/egusphere-2024-884-rc1},
}
Figure