Comment on egusphere-2024-129

Rebecca J. Murray-Watson, Edward GryspeerdtOpenalex Unknown 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Abstract. Clouds formed during marine cold-air outbreaks (MCAOs) exhibit a distinct transition from stratocumulus decks near the ice edge to broken cumuliform fields further downwind. The mechanisms associated with ice formation are believed to be crucial in driving this transition, yet the factors influencing such formation remain unclear. Through Lagrangian trajectories co-located with satellite data, this study investigates the development of mixed-phase clouds during these outbreaks. Clouds formed in MCAOs are characterized by a swift shift from liquid to ice-containing states, contrasting with non-MCAO clouds also moving off the ice edge. These mixed-phase clouds are predominantly observed at temperatures below -20 °C near the ice edge. However, further into the outbreak, they become dominant at temperatures as high as -13 °C. This shift is consistent with the influence of biological ice nucleating particles (INPs), which become more prevalent as the air mass ages over the ocean. The evolution of these clouds is closely linked to the history of the air mass, especially the length of time it spends over snow- and ice-covered surfaces—terrains that may be deficient in INPs. This connection also accounts for the observed seasonal variations in the development of Arctic clouds, both within and outside of MCAO events. The findings highlight the importance of understanding both local marine aerosol sources near the ice edge and the overarching INP distribution in the Arctic for modeling cloud phase in the region.

Introduction

Predicting the phase of Arctic clouds—whether they are liquid, ice, or a "mixed-phase" mixture of both—is a significant challenge in climate modeling. Mixed-phase clouds are critical because they act as a radiative blanket, modulating the heat exchange at the Arctic surface. A specific phenomenon of interest is the Marine Cold-Air Outbreak (MCAO), where frigid air from the ice pack sweeps over the relatively warm ocean, creating "cloud streets" that transition into open cells. While ice formation is known to drive this transition, the specific factors influencing why some air masses produce ice more readily than others remain poorly understood. This study investigates the "memory" of these air masses, examining how their history over land, snow, and ice dictates subsequent cloud development.

Methodology

The researchers employed a Lagrangian trajectory approach to track specific parcels of air as they moved across the Arctic, starting from the moment they crossed the sea-ice edge. This was achieved using ERA5 reanalysis wind data. A key metric developed was "Time Since Ice" (TSI), which tracks the duration an air parcel has spent over the open ocean versus over ice-nucleating particle (INP)-deficient surfaces like snow and pack ice.

The study integrated several high-resolution datasets:

  • DARDAR v2: Combined CloudSat radar and CALIPSO lidar data to identify cloud phase (liquid vs. ice vs. mixed).
  • MODIS (MYD06_L2): Provided cloud top temperature and droplet effective radius ($r_e$).
  • ERA5 Reanalysis: Supplied wind fields for trajectory modeling and temperature profiles.
  • IMS (Interactive Multisensor Snow and Ice Mapping System): Offered 1km resolution data on snow and ice cover to determine air mass history.
  • CAMS (Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service): Provided Aerosol Optical Depth (AOD) to estimate air mass cleanliness.

An MCAO index ($\theta_{skt} - \theta_{800}$) was used to distinguish between unstable MCAO events and stable non-MCAO conditions.

Results and Discussion

The study reveals a "clean slate" effect: air masses originating over the central Arctic ice pack or snow-covered land are extremely depleted of INPs. Ice formation is delayed until the air mass can "pick up" new particles from the ocean. Near the ice edge, mixed-phase clouds only appear at very cold temperatures (below -20°C). However, after approximately 7 hours of fetch over the ocean, mixed-phase clouds become dominant at temperatures as high as -13°C. This shift is consistent with the influence of marine biological INPs lofted via sea spray, which are more effective at nucleating ice at warmer temperatures than mineral dust.

Key findings include:

  • Rapid Glaciation: MCAO clouds show a sharp decline in liquid fraction, dropping to just 20% within 6 hours of leaving the ice edge. In contrast, non-MCAO clouds remain predominantly liquid.
  • Droplet Size Influence: Clouds with larger droplets ($r_e > 14 \mu m$) were more likely to produce mixed-phase conditions at warmer temperatures. This provides satellite-based evidence for Secondary Ice Production (the Hallett-Mossop process), where existing ice crystals splinter upon colliding with large liquid drops.
  • Seasonal Mimicry: In winter (DJF), even "normal" (non-MCAO) clouds behave like MCAO clouds. This occurs because the surrounding land is covered in snow, which blocks terrestrial INPs and forces those air masses to start from the same "clean slate" as those coming off the sea ice.

Conclusion

The evolution of Arctic clouds is closely linked to the history of the air mass, particularly the time spent over INP-deficient surfaces. While the study provides strong satellite-based evidence for these processes, limitations remain, such as the potential for sea-ice data to miss small "leads" (cracks in the ice) acting as local aerosol sources and retrieval biases in radar/lidar products that might misidentify supercooled drizzle as ice. Future research should prioritize in-situ measurements of biological INPs in the Arctic to validate these observations and improve the parameterization of MCAO clouds in climate models.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Clouds formed during marine cold-air outbreaks (MCAOs) exhibit a distinct transition from stratocumulus decks near the ice edge to broken cumuliform fields further downwind. The mechanisms associated with ice formation are believed to be crucial in driving this transition, yet the factors influencing such formation remain unclear. Through Lagrangian trajectories co-located with satellite data, this study investigates into the development of mixed-phase clouds using these outbreaks. Cloud formed in MCAOs are characterized by a swift shift from liquid to ice-containing states, contrasting with non-MCAO clouds also moving off the ice edge. These mixed-phase clouds are predominantly observed at temperatures below -20 &deg;C near the ice edge. However, further into the outbreak, they become the dominant at temperatures as high as -13 &deg;C. This shift is consistent with the influence of biological ice nucleating particles (INPs), which become more prevalent as the air mass ages over the ocean. The evolution of these clouds is closely linked to the history of the air mass, especially the length of time it spends over snow- and ice-covered surfaces, terrains may that be deficient in INPs. This connection also accounts for the observed seasonal variations in the development of Arctic clouds, both within and outside of MCAO events. The findings highlight the importance of understanding both local marine aerosol sources near the ice edge and the overarching INP distribution in the Arctic for modelling of cloud phase in the region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{murraywatson2024comment,
  author = {Rebecca J. Murray-Watson and Edward Gryspeerdt},
  title = {{Comment on egusphere-2024-129}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5194/egusphere-2024-129-cc1},
}
Figure