Comment on egusphere-2023-1863

Maren Böse, Laurentiu Danciu, Αθανάσιος Παπαδόπουλος, John Clinton, Carlo Cauzzi, Irina Dallo, Leila Mizrahi, Tobias Diehl, Paolo Bergamo, Yves Reuland, Andreas Fichtner, Philippe Roth, Florian Haslinger, Frédérick Massin, Nadja Valenzuela, Nikola Blagojević, Lukas Bodenmann, Eleni Chatzi, Donat Fäh, Franziska Glueer, Marta Han, Lukas Heiniger, Paulina Janusz, Dario Jozinović, Philipp Kästli, Federica Lanza, Timothy Lee, Panagiotis Martakis, Michèle Marti, Men‐Andrin Meier, Banu Mena Cabrera, Maria Mesimeri, Anne Obermann, Pilar Sánchez‐Pastor, Luca Scarabello, Nicolas Schmid, Anastasiia Shynkarenko, Božidar Stojadinović, Domenico Giardini, Stefan Wiemer, Maren Böse, Nikola Blagojević, Michà ̈le MartiOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Scientists at ETH Zurich from different disciplines are developing a dynamic, harmonised and user-centred earthquake risk framework for Switzerland, relying on a continuously evolving earthquake catalogue generated by the SED using the national seismic networks. This framework uses all available information to assess seismic risk at various stages and facilitates widespread dissemination and communication of the resulting information. Earthquake risk products and services include Operational Earthquake (Loss) Forecasting (OE[L]F), Earthquake Early Warning (EEW), ShakeMaps, Rapid Impact Assessment (RIA), Structural Health Monitoring (SHM), as well as Recovery and Rebuilding Efforts (RRE). Standardisation of products and workflows across various applications is essential for achieving broad adoption, universal recognition, and maximum synergies. In the Swiss dynamic earthquake risk framework, the harmonisation of products into seamless solutions that access the same databases, workflows, and software is a crucial component to ensure standardisation. A user-centred approach utilising quantitative and qualitative social science tools like online surveys and focus groups is a significant innovation featured in all products and services. Here we report on the key considerations and developments of the framework and its components.

Introduction

Switzerland faces a significant "low-probability, high-impact" seismic threat. While not a global hotspot like Japan or California, a major earthquake in Switzerland could result in economic losses exceeding 100 billion Euros. Historically, seismic risk management has relied on static hazard maps and fragmented tools. This paper details a "dynamic" framework developed at ETH Zurich that integrates real-time seismic data with social science-driven communication strategies. The goal is to transform raw seismic data into actionable safety information that spans from split-second early warnings to multi-decade recovery planning.

Methodology and Data Harmonization

The cornerstone of the Swiss framework is the harmonization of data and workflows. Rather than having different agencies utilize disparate datasets, every tool in the framework—from Earthquake Early Warning (EEW) to Rapid Impact Assessment (RIA)—pulls from a "single source of truth."

Key technical components include:

  • Standardized Workflows: All products use consistent site amplification layers and core software platforms such as OpenQuake and SeisComP.
  • Advanced Processing: The system utilizes 3D velocity models and template matching to detect micro-seismicity that traditional algorithms might overlook.
  • Distributed Acoustic Sensing (DAS): This technology converts existing underground fiber-optic telecom cables into a dense network of seismic sensors, particularly useful in urban environments.
  • User-Centered Design: Researchers employed online surveys and focus groups to ensure that risk communication—such as the visual language of maps and alerts—is understandable to the public, specifically addressing how to convey uncertainty and probability.

The framework integrates data from the Swiss Seismic Network (SED), the national Earthquake Risk Model (ERM-CH23) containing over 2 million building objects, and the national Seismic Hazard Model (SUIhaz2015).

Key Insights and Results

One of the primary findings of this initiative is that consistency in data leads to improved safety and trust. By harmonizing soil data across real-time ShakeMaps and national building codes, the framework ensures that emergency responders and engineers operate on the same information.

Social research conducted as part of the framework's development revealed that 70% of the Swiss public desires Early Warning alerts for any earthquake they might feel, even if it is not strong enough to cause structural damage. This insight suggests that EEW serves a critical role in reducing public anxiety in addition to its traditional role in physical safety.

Technically, the system has demonstrated strong performance:

  • EEW Performance: Median alert delays currently range from 7 to 8.7 seconds, with detection occurring in as little as 4 seconds in high-density areas.
  • Rapid Impact Assessment (RIA): The system can generate comprehensive reports on fatalities, building damage costs, and shelter needs within minutes of an event. For a hypothetical Mw 6.0 earthquake near Bern, the model projects costs between 11 and 44 billion CHF.

Discussion and Future Directions

As of mid-2023, the Seismic Network and ShakeMap components are considered fully operational. However, more complex systems like EEW and Operational Earthquake Loss Forecasting (OELF) remain in the beta or demonstrator phase.

Future work will focus on several key areas:

  • Public Integration: Transitioning EEW from testing to public dissemination via established platforms like the Alertswiss app.
  • Multi-Risk Expansion: Extending the framework to account for cascading hazards specific to the Swiss Alps, such as earthquake-induced landslides or lake tsunamis.
  • Structural Health Monitoring (SHM): Fully integrating machine learning-driven SHM data to allow for the automatic "tagging" of building safety status via digital twins during a crisis.

By bridging the gap between seismological data and public action, this dynamic framework represents a significant step forward in national earthquake resilience.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Scientists at ETH Zurich from different disciplines are developing a dynamic, harmonised and user-centred earthquake risk framework for Switzerland, relying on a continuously evolving earthquake catalogue generated by the SED using the national seismic networks. This framework uses all available information to assess seismic risk at various stages and facilitates widespread dissemination and communication of the resulting information. Earthquake risk products and services include Operational Earthquake (Loss) Forecasting (OE[L]F), Earthquake Early Warning (EEW), ShakeMaps, Rapid Impact Assessment (RIA), Structural Health Monitoring (SHM), as well as Recovery and Rebuilding Efforts (RRE). Standardisation of products and workflows across various applications is essential for achieving broad adoption, universal recognition, and maximum synergies. In the Swiss dynamic earthquake risk framework, the harmonisation of products into seamless solutions that access the same databases, workflows, and software is a crucial component to ensure standardisation. A user-centred approach utilising quantitative and qualitative social science tools like online surveys and focus groups is a significant innovation featured in all products and services. Here we report on the key considerations and developments of the framework and its components.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bose2023comment,
  author = {Maren Böse and Laurentiu Danciu and Αθανάσιος Παπαδόπουλος and John Clinton and Carlo Cauzzi and Irina Dallo and Leila Mizrahi and Tobias Diehl and Paolo Bergamo and Yves Reuland and Andreas Fichtner and Philippe Roth and Florian Haslinger and Frédérick Massin and Nadja Valenzuela and Nikola Blagojević and Lukas Bodenmann and Eleni Chatzi and Donat Fäh and Franziska Glueer and Marta Han and Lukas Heiniger and Paulina Janusz and Dario Jozinović and Philipp Kästli and Federica Lanza and Timothy Lee and Panagiotis Martakis and Michèle Marti and Men‐Andrin Meier and Banu Mena Cabrera and Maria Mesimeri and Anne Obermann and Pilar Sánchez‐Pastor and Luca Scarabello and Nicolas Schmid and Anastasiia Shynkarenko and Božidar Stojadinović and Domenico Giardini and Stefan Wiemer and Maren Böse and Nikola Blagojević and Michà ̈le Marti},
  title = {{Comment on egusphere-2023-1863}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/egusphere-2023-1863-rc1},
}
Figure