Comment on acp-2021-861

Rebecca J. Murray-Watson, Edward GryspeerdtOpenalex Unknown 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract The effects of aerosols on cloud microphysical properties are a large source of uncertainty when assessing anthropogenic climate change. The aerosol–cloud relationship is particularly unclear in high-latitude polar regions due to a limited number of observations. Cloud liquid water path (LWP) is an important control on cloud radiative properties, particularly in the Arctic, where clouds play a central role in the surface energy budget. Using satellite data, this work investigates the effects of aerosols on liquid Arctic clouds over open ocean by considering the relationship between cloud droplet number concentration ($N_d$) and LWP. The LWP response to $N_d$ varies significantly across the region, with increases in LWP with $N_d$ observed at very high latitudes, particularly during summer months. This result contrasts with the negative response typically seen in global studies. Lower tropospheric stability (LTS) was found to be a dominant control, with high-stability environments favoring LWP increases. As LTS is projected to decrease in a warming Arctic, aerosol increases may shift from enhancing the cooling Twomey effect by 8% to offsetting it by approximately 40%, with significant consequences for sea ice extent.

Introduction

One of the most significant uncertainties in climate science is the interaction between aerosols—tiny particles like soot or sea salt—and clouds. In most regions, adding aerosols increases the number of droplets ($N_d$) but often decreases the total Liquid Water Path (LWP) because smaller droplets evaporate faster and induce turbulence that entrains dry air.

In the Arctic, which is warming at least twice as fast as the global average (Arctic Amplification), the stakes are particularly high. As sea ice melts and industrial activity moves north, aerosol concentrations are expected to rise. Understanding whether these aerosols will cool the region by brightening clouds (the Twomey effect) or warm it by thinning them is critical for predicting future sea ice loss.

Methodology and Data

To investigate these interactions, researchers employed a "mediating variable" approach, focusing on the linear sensitivity of LWP to changes in $N_d$. The study integrated several high-resolution datasets from 2010–2015:

  • MODIS (NASA Aqua): Primary source for $N_d$, optical thickness, and LWP.
  • AMSR-E: Provided an independent microwave-based cross-check for LWP measurements.
  • ERA5 Reanalysis: Supplied meteorological context, specifically Lower Tropospheric Stability (LTS) and specific humidity.
  • Sea Ice Masks: Used to ensure the analysis was limited to liquid-only clouds over the open ocean, avoiding retrieval biases over bright ice and snow.

Spatial Gradients and the Role of Stability

The study revealed a clear spatial gradient in how clouds respond to aerosols. While lower latitudes typically show a negative $N_d$-LWP relationship, the high-latitude Arctic exhibits a unique positive sensitivity, especially during the summer.

Spatial distribution of the sensitivity of LWP to $N_d$ across the Arctic, showing a transition from negative (blue) to positive (red) relationships at higher latitudes.

Lower Tropospheric Stability (LTS) emerged as the "master dial" for this relationship. In the highly stable environments common to the Arctic summer, the atmosphere acts as a lid, preventing dry air entrainment. This allows the suppression of precipitation (caused by more, smaller droplets) to dominate, resulting in thicker, wetter clouds. LTS explained more variance in LWP sensitivity ($r^2 = 0.39$) than any other factor, including humidity or surface temperature.

Future Climate Projections

The findings suggest a concerning feedback loop. Currently, in high-stability conditions, LWP adjustments enhance the cooling Twomey effect by approximately 8%. However, as the Arctic warms, the atmosphere is projected to become less stable. This shift toward lower LTS is expected to flip the $N_d$-LWP relationship from positive to negative. In such a future scenario, LWP adjustments could offset the cooling Twomey effect by roughly 40%, potentially accelerating the warming of the region and the melting of sea ice.

Limitations

Despite these insights, several challenges remain. The "Ice Gap"—the inability of optical satellites to accurately retrieve data over sea ice—means a large portion of the Arctic remains unobserved. Additionally, the study focused on pure liquid clouds, leaving the complex behavior of mixed-phase (ice and water) clouds as a subject for future research using active sensors like LIDAR or in-situ aircraft observations.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> The effects of aerosols on cloud microphysical properties are a large source of uncertainty when assessing anthropogenic climate change. The aerosol–cloud relationship is particularly unclear in high-latitude polar regions due to a limited number of observations. Cloud liquid water path (LWP) is an important control on cloud radiative properties, particularly in the Arctic, where clouds play a central role in the surface energy budget. Therefore, understanding how aerosols may alter cloud LWP is important, especially as aerosol sources such as industry and shipping move further north in a warming Arctic. Using satellite data, this work investigates the effects of aerosols on liquid Arctic clouds over open ocean by considering the relationship between cloud droplet number concentration (<span class="inline-formula"><i>N</i><sub>d</sub></span>) and LWP, an important component of the aerosol–LWP relationship. The LWP response to <span class="inline-formula"><i>N</i><sub>d</sub></span> varies significantly across the region, with increases in LWP with <span class="inline-formula"><i>N</i><sub>d</sub></span> observed at very high latitudes in multiple satellite datasets, with this positive signal observed most strongly during the summer months. This result is in contrast to the negative response typically seen in global satellite studies and previous work on Arctic clouds showing little LWP response to aerosols. The lower tropospheric stability (LTS) was found to be an important control on the spatial variations in LWP response, strongly influencing the sign and magnitude of the <span class="inline-formula"><i>N</i><sub>d</sub></span>–LWP relationship, with increases in LWP in high-stability environments. The influence of humidity varied depending on the stability, with little impact at low LTS but a strong influence at high LTS. The mean <span class="inline-formula"><i>N</i><sub>d</sub></span> state does not dominate the LWP response, despite the non-linearities in the relationship. As the <span class="inline-formula"><i>N</i><sub>d</sub></span>–LWP sensitivity changed from positive to negative when moving from high- to low-LTS environments, this work shows evidence of a temperature-dependent aerosol indirect effect. Additionally, the LWP–LTS relationship changes with <span class="inline-formula"><i>N</i><sub>d</sub></span>, generating an aerosol-dependent cloud feedback. As the LTS is projected to decrease and the boundary layer to become more polluted in a future Arctic, these results show that aerosol increases may produce lower cloud water paths. This shift to more unstable environments implies that LWP adjustments shift from enhancing the Twomey effect by 8 % to offsetting it by around 40 %, with this warming effect having potential consequences for sea ice extent.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{murraywatson2021comment,
  author = {Rebecca J. Murray-Watson and Edward Gryspeerdt},
  title = {{Comment on acp-2021-861}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2021-861-rc1},
}
Figure