China

Chen Bao-ming, Can Huang, Peng Chun-yan, Minglei Ding, Ning Huang, Xia Liu, Yang JuanCambridge 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This chapter analyzes the progress that Chinese universities and public research institutes have made in the fields of research and education as well as the factors that hinder the growth of knowledge transfer from universities and public research institutes to firms in China. The chapter describes how the role of universities and public research institutes in China has evolved in recent decades with the transition to a market economy. It reviews the laws and policies governing knowledge transfer activities in China. It examines the various channels of knowledge transfer that universities and public research institutes in China use to transfer technology such as making new knowledge publicly available at no cost and through cooperative arrangements, including contract research and collaboration, licensing, and establishing spinoff enterprises. The chapter concludes that while Chinese universities and public research institutes have been dramatically transformed in order to meet government policy goals of producing cutting-edge scientific and technological developments to support economic and social advancement since the 1980s, there are challenges in the areas of limited licensing opportunities for leading technologies, lack of long-term financial support, ambiguous corporate governance and regulations, and underdeveloped intermediary agencies resulting in high transaction costs that remain to be addressed.

Introduction: Bridging the "Valley of Death"

China has rapidly transitioned from a state-planned model to a global R&D powerhouse, now ranking as the world’s second-largest producer of scientific publications and patent applications. However, a significant challenge remains: the "exploitation rate" of this knowledge—the actual application of research in industry—lags behind other advanced economies. Historically, a centrally planned system disconnected research from market needs, and a rigid legal framework treated intellectual property as a state asset, making technology transfer risky for institutions.

Recent reforms, particularly the 2015 amendments to the Law on Promoting the Transformation of Scientific and Technological Achievements (PTSTA), represent a "Bayh-Dole" moment for China. These changes grant universities greater autonomy and incentivize researchers by mandating that at least 50% of net profits from knowledge transfer go to the inventors.

The Shifting R&D Landscape

The structure of China's innovation system has changed dramatically since 2000. Gross expenditure on R&D (GERD) surpassed 1 trillion CNY in 2012 and reached 1.76 trillion CNY by 2017. A defining feature of this growth is the increasing dominance of enterprises in R&D spending.

Figure 1: Share of R&D expenditure by sector in China (2000–2016).

As shown in Figure 1, enterprises now account for approximately 77% of total R&D spending, while the share of public research institutes (PRIs) has declined significantly. Universities maintain a stable but smaller share of total expenditure, typically between 7% and 10%.

The Functional Division of Labor

Despite the dominance of corporate spending, universities remain the bedrock of the innovation ecosystem due to their role in fundamental science. There is a clear functional division: while enterprises focus almost exclusively on experimental development, universities are the primary performers of basic research.

Figure 2: Composition of R&D activities by sector in China.

Figure 2 illustrates that universities dedicate a substantial portion of their R&D efforts to basic research, compared to a negligible amount by enterprises. This creates a natural dependency; industry relies on academic breakthroughs for the "seed corn" of future commercial technologies.

Knowledge Transfer and the Efficiency Gap

Knowledge transfer (KT) occurs through various channels, including licensing, spinoffs, and science parks like Zhongguancun. While university patent transfers grew from 1,810 in 2010 to 4,839 in 2016, a stark "efficiency gap" persists. In 2014, the patent exploitation rate for enterprises was roughly 68%, while for universities, it was only 9.9%.

Interestingly, formal patent licensing is often overshadowed by non-patent KT. Contract research and consulting remain significantly larger income sources for universities, suggesting that informal collaborations are currently more effective than formal IP transactions.

Persistent Bottlenecks and Future Outlook

Several barriers continue to hinder the full potential of China's S&T system:

  • Absorptive Capacity: Many domestic firms, particularly SMEs, lack the internal R&D capability to utilize sophisticated university patents.
  • Intermediary Shortage: There is a critical lack of professional Knowledge Transfer Offices (KTOs) and "technology brokers" capable of navigating the intersection of science, law, and business.
  • Legal and Governance Ambiguity: Defining "net profit" for rewards and managing "state-owned assets" in spinoffs remains complex.

The 2015 reforms are a major step forward, but their full impact will take years to manifest. Future success will depend on professionalizing the transfer process and enhancing the ability of the private sector to absorb academic innovation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This chapter analyzes the progress that Chinese universities and public research institutes have made in the fields of research and education as well as the factors that hinder the growth of knowledge transfer from universities and public research institutes to firms in China. The chapter describes how the role of universities and public research institutes in China has evolved in recent decades with the transition to a market economy. It reviews the laws and policies governing knowledge transfer activities in China. It examines the various channels of knowledge transfer that universities and public research institutes in China use to transfer technology such as making new knowledge publicly available at no cost and through cooperative arrangements, including contract research and collaboration, licensing, and establishing spinoff enterprises. The chapter concludes that while Chinese universities and public research institutes have been dramatically transformed in order to meet government policy goals of producing cutting-edge scientific and technological developments to support economic and social advancement since the 1980s, there are challenges in the areas of limited licensing opportunities for leading technologies, lack of long-term financial support, ambiguous corporate governance and regulations, and underdeveloped intermediary agencies resulting in high transaction costs that remain to be addressed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{baoming2021china,
  author = {Chen Bao-ming and Can Huang and Peng Chun-yan and Minglei Ding and Ning Huang and Xia Liu and Yang Juan},
  title = {{China}},
  booktitle = {Cambridge},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1017/9781108904230.017},
}
Figure