Author response: Running modulates primate and rodent visual cortex differently

John P Liska, Declan P Rowley, Trevor Thai K Nguyen, Jens-Oliver Muthmann, Daniel A. Butts, Jacob L. Yates, Alexander C. HukOpenalex Unknown 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

While locomotion "supercharges" activity in the mouse visual cortex, it has a negligible or even slightly suppressive effect in marmoset primates. This study reveals that the way behavioral states like running influence early sensory processing is not a universal mammalian trait, suggesting a fundamental divergence in how primates and rodents integrate vision and action.

The Role of Locomotion in Visual Processing

For decades, the primary visual cortex (V1) was viewed as a passive image processor—a simple relay station turning retinal input into basic features like edges and orientations. This view was challenged roughly 15 years ago when researchers discovered that in mice, running can double the firing rates of V1 neurons, even when visual stimuli remain constant. This sparked a massive effort to understand how non-visual signals, such as motor activity or arousal, modulate sensory perception. However, as most of this work was conducted in rodents, it remained unclear if this "running boost" was a fundamental mammalian property or a specific quirk of the rodent lineage.

Experimental Design and Cross-Species Comparison

To address this, researchers performed a direct cross-species comparison using the common marmoset (Callithrix jacchus), a small New World primate with a visual system featuring high-acuity foveas and complex specialized networks.

Experimental setup and neural recording overview in the marmoset. Panel (a) shows the treadmill rig, (b) displays example traces of V1 activity alongside behavioral metrics, and (c-l) provide details on receptive fields and orientation selectivity.

Marmosets were head-fixed on a custom toroidal treadmill, allowing them to run or stay stationary while viewing visual stimuli. Using high-density electrode arrays, the team recorded from hundreds of V1 neurons simultaneously, covering both foveal and peripheral vision. To ensure a rigorous comparison, the authors applied the same analysis pipeline to a publicly available mouse dataset from the Allen Institute, employing a "shared-gain" latent variable model to separate stimulus-driven activity from internal population-wide gain fluctuations.

Key Results: The Great Divergence

The most striking finding was the complete lack of a "running boost" in primates. In mice, running acted as a massive "volume knob," increasing V1 firing rates by an average of 52%. In contrast, marmosets showed a negligible response; foveal V1 activity actually decreased by about 10% during running.

The correlation between running speed and population activity further highlighted this divergence. While mice showed a strong positive correlation (0.407), the correlation in marmosets was essentially zero or slightly negative (-0.033). Interestingly, both species showed increased pupil size during running—a proxy for arousal—indicating that while marmosets were in a different internal state, their visual cortex simply did not respond to that state the way a mouse's does.

Implications for Systems Neuroscience

The study also revealed a subtle functional difference within the marmoset brain: foveal V1 was slightly suppressed during running, while peripheral V1 showed a tiny increase in activity. This suggests that primates might prioritize stabilizing their central "high-definition" vision during movement.

These findings serve as a cautionary tale for systems neuroscience. A phenomenon that is robust in mice is not necessarily a universal law of the mammalian brain. Future work will need to explore whether other behaviors—such as reaching, grasping, or focused attention—might be more relevant modulators of the primate visual cortex than simple locomotion.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{liska2024author,
  author = {John P Liska and Declan P Rowley and Trevor Thai K Nguyen and Jens-Oliver Muthmann and Daniel A. Butts and Jacob L. Yates and Alexander C. Huk},
  title = {{Author response: Running modulates primate and rodent visual cortex differently}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.87736.3.sa4},
}
Figure