Abstract
The protein dynamical transition at ∼ 200 K, where the biomolecule transforms from a harmonic, non-functional form to an anharmonic, functional state, has been thought to be slaved to the thermal activation of dynamics in its surface hydration water. Here, by selectively probing the dynamics of protein and hydration water using elastic neutron scattering and isotopic labelling, we found that the onset of anharmonicity in the two components around 200 K are decoupled. The one in protein is an intrinsic transition, whose characteristic temperature is independent of the instrumental resolution time, but varies with the biomolecular structure and the amount of hydration, while the one of water is merely a resolution effect.
Introduction
At approximately 200 K (-73°C), hydrated proteins undergo a "dynamical transition," shifting from a rigid, biologically inactive state to a flexible, functional one. A long-standing biophysical theory, the "slaving" hypothesis, posits that this transition is entirely dictated by the surface hydration water. Under this model, protein motion is only possible once the surrounding water molecules activate. However, experimental inconsistencies regarding whether these transitions coincide have fueled a debate: is the protein transition an inherent property or a consequence of its environment?
To resolve this, researchers utilized Elastic Neutron Scattering (ENS) combined with Isotopic Labeling. By exploiting the difference in neutron sensitivity between Hydrogen (H) and Deuterium (D), they isolated the signals of the protein (using $D_2O$ hydration) and the water (using perdeuterated proteins in $H_2O$). Observations were conducted across multiple timescales (10 ps to 1 ns) using three different neutron spectrometers (HFBS, DNA, and OSIRIS) and validated with Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC).
Results and Discussion
The study focused on four globular proteins: Lysozyme (LYS), Myoglobin (MYO), Cytochrome P450 (CYP), and Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP), with varying hydration levels ($h$).
Protein Dynamics are Intrinsic
A key finding was that the onset temperature ($T_{on}$) of the protein transition is independent of the instrument's resolution but varies with the protein's specific structure. For instance, at a hydration level of $h=0.3$, $T_{on}$ was measured at 198 K for Myoglobin and 213 K for Lysozyme.
This resolution independence suggests a real physical transition—the "unfreezing" of structural relaxations—rather than an observational artifact. In Cytochrome P450, the transition remained consistent at approximately 228 K across resolutions ranging from 1 $\mu$eV to 100 $\mu$eV.
Water as a Plasticizer
In contrast to the protein, the apparent transition of surface water shifted significantly (from 200 K to 250 K) as the instrument's resolution changed. This indicates that the water transition is a "resolution effect" where continuous thermal motion simply becomes detectable at higher temperatures. Rather than "slaving" the protein, water acts as a plasticizer. Increasing hydration lowers the protein's $T_{on}$, facilitating flexibility at lower temperatures, much like plasticizers affect industrial polymers.
Conclusion
The findings demonstrate that the protein dynamical transition is physically decoupled from the behavior of its surface water. While water is necessary to lubricate the protein structure, the transition itself is an intrinsic, glass-like unfreezing of the polypeptide chain. Future research may further explore the relationship between this transition and specific catalytic steps, as well as the potential heterogeneity within the hydration shell itself.
Summary updated