Author Correction: Zebras of all stripes repel biting flies at close range

Kaia J. Tombak, Andrew S. Gersick, Lily V. Reisinger, Brenda Larison, Daniel I. RubensteinScientific 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This article presents a formal correction to the 2022 study "Zebras of all stripes repel biting flies at close range," originally published in Scientific Reports. The correction addresses a significant typographical error regarding the physical scale of the experimental stimuli and provides persistent identifiers (DOIs) for the study's raw data and analysis scripts to ensure open-science compliance. While the reported surface area of the skin samples has been updated, the fundamental conclusions regarding the fly-deterrent properties of zebra stripes remain unchanged.

Introduction

The "fly deterrence hypothesis" is a leading explanation for the evolutionary development of zebra stripes. It suggests that the high-contrast patterns disrupt the visual systems of biting flies, such as tabanids, preventing them from making successful landings. In the original research, investigators tested this hypothesis by presenting flies with skin samples from three species: the plains zebra (Equus quagga), Grevy’s zebra (Equus grevyi), and the impala (Aepyceros melampus), which served as a non-striped control.

Methodological Correction: Scaling the Experiment

A critical component of sensory ecology experiments is the scale of the visual stimulus. The original publication contained a typographical error in the reported dimensions of the skin samples used in field trials.

The original text stated that researchers used skin pieces approximately 30 cm² in size. However, the corrected record clarifies that the samples were actually ~400 cm² (roughly 20x20 cm). These pieces were harvested from the rumps of zebras and the flanks of impalas found dead in the field. The samples were prepared by scraping away muscle and fat, curing them with salt, and sun-drying them at the research center before use in behavioral trials.

This correction is vital for the scientific record, as the total surface area of a pattern significantly influences how it is perceived by an insect's compound eyes at close range. Future researchers attempting to replicate these findings or model fly visual responses now have the accurate parameters required for their work.

Data Accessibility and Transparency

In addition to the methodological correction, the authors have updated the Data Availability section to provide direct, permanent links to the study's underlying assets. This move enhances the transparency and computational reproducibility of the research.

Conclusion

The formal update to the manuscript does not alter the study's primary findings. The data continues to support the conclusion that zebra stripes, regardless of their specific configuration (plains vs. Grevy's), effectively repel biting flies at close range compared to solid-colored hides. By rectifying the reporting error and providing open-access data links, the authors have strengthened the integrity and utility of the original research for the broader scientific community.

Summary updated

Abstract

We took a ~ 30 cm 2 piece from the side of the rump from one plains zebra and one Grevy's zebra (SI1), and one section from the flank of an impala (since the rump of the impala was not large enough to match the skin sections from the zebras), all found dead in the field.Each of these squares was scraped free of any attached muscle and fat, cured with salt, and sun-dried at the research center." now reads: "We took a ~ 400 cm 2 piece from the side of the rump from one plains zebra and one Grevy's zebra (SI1), and one section from the flank of an impala (since the rump of the impala was not large enough to match the skin sections from the zebras), all found dead in the field.Each of these squares was scraped free of any attached muscle and fat, cured with salt, and sun-dried at the research center."In addition, in the Data availability section,
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tombak2023author,
  author = {Kaia J. Tombak and Andrew S. Gersick and Lily V. Reisinger and Brenda Larison and Daniel I. Rubenstein},
  title = {{Author Correction: Zebras of all stripes repel biting flies at close range}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-28782-y},
}
Figure