Author Correction: Integrated genomics point to immune vulnerabilities in pleural mesothelioma

Anca Năstase, Amit Kumar Mandal, Shir Kiong Lu, Hima Anbunathan, Déborah Morris-Rosendahl, Yu Zhi Zhang, Xiaoming Sun, Spyridon Gennatas, Robert C. Rintoul, Matthew Edwards, Alex Bowman, Tatyana Chernova, T. Benepal, Eric Lim, Anthony Newman Taylor, Andrew G. Nicholson, Sanjay Popat, Anne E. Willis, Marion MacFarlane, Mark Lathrop, A. Bowcock, Miriam F. Moffatt, William CooksonScientific 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

TL;DR

This document is a formal author correction for a 2021 study investigating the genomic landscape of pleural mesothelioma. The primary update fixes a sign error in a correlation coefficient, clarifying the relationship between cell proliferation markers and genetic deletions associated with tumor progression.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The provided document is an Author Correction notice for the paper "Integrated genomics point to immune vulnerabilities in pleural mesothelioma." In scientific publishing, such notices are critical for maintaining the integrity of the record.

The specific issue addressed is a typographical error in the reporting of statistical correlations. In the original text, the relationship between Ki67 (a protein used as a cellular marker for proliferation) and the MTAP score (often used as a proxy for $CDKN2A$ gene deletion) was listed with a positive correlation coefficient. The correction clarifies that this relationship is actually negative, which aligns with the biological expectation of how these genetic deletions drive disordered cell division.

Methods

Not discussed in this correction notice. (The notice refers to the original study published in Scientific Reports in September 2021, which utilized integrated genomics, but those specific methodologies are not detailed in this one-page update.)

Datasets

Not discussed in this correction notice. (The original research involved genomic data from pleural mesothelioma patients, but specific dataset names or benchmarks are not listed in the correction.)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Correction of Directionality: The most significant "aha moment" here is the shift from a positive correlation ($r = 0.39$) to a negative correlation ($r = -0.39$) between Ki67 and the MTAP score.
  • Biological Consistency: In many cancers, the $CDKN2A$ gene (a tumor suppressor) is deleted. The $MTAP$ gene is located very close to $CDKN2A$ and is frequently co-deleted. A lower MTAP score (indicating deletion) correlating with a higher Ki67 score (indicating high cell proliferation) is a hallmark of aggressive tumor growth. The corrected negative correlation coefficient ($r = -0.39$) correctly reflects this inverse relationship.
  • Impact on Results: The authors note that despite this typo, the overarching conclusion remains the same: these markers are consistent with "disordered cellular division accompanying $CDKN2A$ deletion."

Key Results

The correction updates a specific sentence in the "Results" section of the original paper:

  • Original (Incorrect): Ki67 correlated with MTAP score ($P = 0.04, r = 0.39$).
  • Corrected (Current): Ki67 correlated with MTAP score ($P = 0.04, r = -0.39$).
  • Stable Metrics: The correlation between Ki67 and copy number burden remained unchanged ($P = 0.03, r = 0.42$).

Limitations and Future Work

Not discussed in this correction notice. The notice simply states that "The original Article has been corrected" to reflect these statistical values accurately.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the Results section, under subheading 'High level of VISTA is frequent in epithelioid mesothelioma and its expression level correlates with Hedgehog and immune pathway components' , "Ki67 correlated with copy number burden (P = 0.03, r = 0.42) and with MTAP score (P = 0.04, r = 0.39), consistent with disordered cellular division accompanying CDKN2A deletion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nastase2022author,
  author = {Anca Năstase and Amit Kumar Mandal and Shir Kiong Lu and Hima Anbunathan and Déborah Morris-Rosendahl and Yu Zhi Zhang and Xiaoming Sun and Spyridon Gennatas and Robert C. Rintoul and Matthew Edwards and Alex Bowman and Tatyana Chernova and T. Benepal and Eric Lim and Anthony Newman Taylor and Andrew G. Nicholson and Sanjay Popat and Anne E. Willis and Marion MacFarlane and Mark Lathrop and A. Bowcock and Miriam F. Moffatt and William Cookson},
  title = {{Author Correction: Integrated genomics point to immune vulnerabilities in pleural mesothelioma}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-08800-1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure