Analysis of classroom teaching innovation characteristics of science and engineering teachers

J. Jiang, Ling LuoAtlantis 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Classroom teaching is a key factor affecting the quality of teaching in colleges and universities. This study adopts a qualitative research method, using NVivo11 software, to analyze the teaching strategies in the final debriefing video of the National College Teachers' Teaching Innovation Competition in terms of process and method dimensions, and to sort out the details of teaching implementation of the 11 award-winning science and technology teachers, aiming at optimizing the design of teaching links, enriching the means of teaching and practically improving the quality of teaching.

Introduction: Moving Beyond Unidirectional Transmission

Traditional science and engineering education often falls into the trap of "unidirectional transmission"—a model where instructors deliver lectures while students passively record information. This approach is increasingly seen as insufficient for developing the "higher-order abilities" required in modern engineering. This study addresses the challenge of how to practically implement "student-centered" teaching in technically dense subjects by analyzing the strategies used by the most successful, award-winning teachers in China’s premier teaching innovation competition.

Methodology: Qualitative Data Mining with NVivo

The researchers employed a qualitative research methodology known as Grounded Theory to analyze 37 sets of materials from 11 award-winning teachers. Using NVivo11 software, the team performed a three-stage coding process:

  1. Open Coding: Breaking down raw data into 1,030 discrete "reference points."
  2. Spindle (Axial) Coding: Categorizing these points into the main theme of "Process and Method."
  3. Selective Coding: Distilling the main theme into five specific sub-nodes: collaborative learning, teacher-student interaction, after-class homework, blended learning platforms, and assessment/evaluation.

Word frequency analysis and "vocabulary clouds" were used to visualize dominant concepts, finding that "students," "problems," and "thinking" were the most prevalent terms in innovative teaching scripts.

Word frequency analysis showing the dominant concepts in innovative teaching materials.

The Five Pillars of Innovative STEM Pedagogy

The qualitative analysis revealed a clear hierarchy of where innovation is happening in the classroom, categorized into five dimensions under the "Process and Method" theme.

Treemap showing the distribution of reference points across the five dimensions of teaching innovation.

1. Collaborative Learning (23.8%)

This is the most emphasized area, focusing on small-group problem-solving. To prevent "clique" formation and the "soy sauce effect" (where some students do not contribute), teachers used random grouping methods and intra-group peer evaluations.

2. Appraisal and Feedback (21.8%)

Innovative teachers move away from high-stakes final exams toward holistic, stage-by-stage evaluation. This often includes "enterprise cooperation," where industry tutors or "first parties" participate in project debriefings and roadshows to provide real-world scoring.

3. Teacher-Student Interaction (20.4%)

Interaction is enhanced through mobile tools like "Rain Classroom" for real-time Q&A and data analysis. Techniques such as "word matching" using colored slips help students engage with complex terminology actively rather than passively.

4. Hybrid Teaching Platforms (18.9%)

Digital tools like Python123, Huawei Network Simulation (ENSP), and cloud platforms bridge the gap between theory and practice, allowing for "unlimited iterative testing" in a safe, virtual environment.

5. After-Class Assignment (15.1%)

Learning is extended beyond the classroom walls through mind maps and pre-study questions, ensuring students are prepared for active participation during live sessions.

Discussion: The Teacher-Led, Student-Centered Paradox

A key insight from the study is that innovation does not mean the teacher's role is diminished. Instead, the teacher acts as an architect, designing a "stage" where students can take the lead. This is reflected in the high frequency of collaborative learning reference points and the use of gamified grouping to ensure diverse interaction.

Conclusion and Future Work

By decoding the strategies of top-tier educators, this study provides a concrete roadmap for STEM faculty looking to modernize their pedagogy. While the current focus is on the characteristics of the teaching methods, future research should involve longitudinal studies to determine if these innovative "process and method" dimensions lead to better-prepared engineers in the workforce compared to traditional lecture-based cohorts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Classroom teaching is a key factor affecting the quality of teaching in colleges and universities.This study adopts a qualitative research method, using NVivo11 software, to analyze the teaching strategies in the final debriefing video of the National College Teachers' Teaching Innovation Competition in terms of process and method dimensions, and to sort out the details of teaching implementation of the 11 award-winning science and technology teachers, aiming at optimizing the design of teaching links, enriching the means of teaching and practically improving the quality of teaching.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2023analysis,
  author = {J. Jiang and Ling Luo},
  title = {{Analysis of classroom teaching innovation characteristics of science and engineering teachers}},
  booktitle = {Atlantis},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-264-4\_76},
}
Figure