An Information Security Risk Management Model for Smart Industries

Nader Sohrabi Safa, carsten maple, Tim WatsonAdvances 2017 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The Internet of Things (IoT) has been acknowledged as a new revolution in technology, playing an important role in the flourishing of smart manufacturing and supply chains. However, information security is a controversial issue in this domain. In this paper, a novel information security management model is presented that shows how an appropriate threat model and risk model can mitigate the risk of information security breaches in an industrial environment. Risk identification based on organizational assets, analysis, evaluation, and treatment along with scope specification considering risk management in ISO/IEC 27005, HTRA, CORAS, and OCTAVE Allegro have been considered in the framework development. The presented model mitigates the risk of information security for both service providers and service consumers in this environment. At the end of the paper, we highlight the ways in which the current research supplies us with a direction for future research in this domain.

Introduction

As industries transition to "Smart Manufacturing" (Industry 4.0), they become heavily reliant on the Internet of Things (IoT) and seamless data exchange across supply chains. While this connectivity boosts productivity, it opens a massive attack surface. Traditional security models often fail to account for the unique intersection of cyber-physical systems and human behavior. A breach in a smart supply chain isn't just a data leak; it can result in the theft of industrial designs, loss of competitive advantage, or even total bankruptcy. The challenge lies in creating a model that is rigorous enough for engineers but practical enough for managers to implement across diverse organizational layers.

Methodology and Threat Modeling

The authors developed a novel information security management model by synthesizing elements from several established frameworks, including ISO/IEC 27005, HTRA, CORAS, and OCTAVE Allegro. A core component of this methodology is the identification of assets, which are categorized into five groups: Individuals, Governance, Process, Technology, and Information. Notably, the framework defines security controls themselves as "assets," recognizing that if a control fails, the business functionality is directly compromised.

Threat modeling in this framework involves identifying "threat agents"—whether human or technological—and mapping their potential impact based on cause-and-effect relationships. This conceptual flow is essential for understanding how vulnerabilities lead to measurable risks.

Conceptual framework of the relationship between threat agents, assets, and risk outcomes.

Risk Analysis and the Human Element

To ensure the model's reliability, the authors utilized the Delphi method, an iterative process of gathering and refining feedback from a panel of domain experts in information systems and supply chain management. The resulting quantitative risk analysis utilizes a 3x3 matrix to score risks. Numerical values are assigned to Likelihood (2, 4, 6) and Impact (3, 6, 9), resulting in a risk score ranging from 5 (Very Low) to 15 (Critical).

A key insight of this research is that the "human element" remains the weakest link. As technical defenses improve, attackers shift focus toward human psychology. The authors argue that a strong information security culture is a more effective mitigation strategy for insider threats than technical controls alone. Furthermore, IoT devices are highlighted as dangerous "jumping-off points" for attackers due to their lack of native malware detection.

The Proposed Risk Management Framework

The primary output of this research is a validated Risk Management Model that moves from scenario identification to task execution. Rather than just listing vulnerabilities, the framework advocates for scenario-based modeling to uncover hidden aspects of threats that only emerge within the specific context of supply chain interactions.

The proposed iterative information security risk management model.

This iterative model ensures that risk classification and rating lead directly to prioritized task execution, creating a feedback loop that adapts to the evolving threat landscape of smart industries.

Conclusion and Future Work

The presented model provides a structured approach to mitigating information security risks for both service providers and consumers. While the framework is structurally sound and expert-validated, it remains a high-level model.

Future research directions include the investigation of specific risk detection algorithms to automate parts of this framework, the application of Multicriteria Decision Making (MCDM) tools to help managers prioritize resource allocation, and exploring how Information Security Response Teams (ISRTs) can use the model's data to flag potential breaches in real-time across production systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Internet of Things (IoT) has been acknowledged as a new revolution in technology. IoT play an important role in the flourishing of smart manufacturing and in supply chains. However, information security is a controversial issue in this domain. In this paper, a novel information security management model is presented that shows how an appropriate threat model and risk model can mitigate the risk of information security breaches in an industrial environment. Risk identification based on organisational assets, analysis, evaluation, and treatment along with scope specification considering risk management in ISO/IEC 27005, HTRA, CORAS and OCTAVE Allegro have been considered in the framework development. The presented model mitigates the risk of information security for both service providers and service consumers in this environment. At the end of the paper, we highlight the ways in which the current research supplies us with a direction for future research in this domain.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{safa2017information,
  author = {Nader Sohrabi Safa and carsten maple and Tim Watson},
  title = {{An Information Security Risk Management Model for Smart Industries}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3233/978-1-61499-792-4-257},
}
Figure