An In-depth Analysis on Intellectual Property Problems Confronted by Local Area Network Information Resource Sharing in Diverse Industries

Jingjing Li, Juan WangAdvances 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

TL;DR

This paper explores the legal and technical "bottleneck" of intellectual property (IP) rights within Local Area Networks (LANs). It argues that while internal information sharing is vital for organizational growth, it creates significant risks of copyright infringement that must be mitigated through a combination of rigorous contractual strategies and technical safeguards like digital watermarking and encryption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the push for "informatization," organizations across various industries have built robust LANs—internal networks physically isolated from the broader internet—to share digital resources. However, a fundamental contradiction exists: the goal of information sharing is accessibility, while the nature of intellectual property is exclusiveness.

The authors address the legal pitfalls encountered during the three main stages of the digital resource lifecycle:

  1. Database Establishment: How compiling disparate works into a searchable database can violate an author’s rights to publication, authorship, and compilation.
  2. Online Dissemination: The risks involved when an organization provides works to its internal users without explicit "network dissemination" rights.
  3. Long-Term Preservation: The IP challenges inherent in backing up, migrating, or updating digital archives over decades, which often requires modifying the original work’s format or metadata.

Methods

The paper provides a qualitative and legal analysis rather than an experimental study. The authors use a framework that categorizes solutions into two categories:

  • Legal/Management Strategies: They propose a "Strategy of Purchase" (ensuring database developers provide copyright proof and assume liability in contracts) and a "Strategy of Utilization" (educating users and monitoring for illegal copying).
  • Technical Safeguards: The authors review and recommend specific technologies to enforce IP rights, including:
  • Asymmetric Encryption & Digital Signatures: To ensure data authenticity and prevent tampering during transmission.
  • Digital Watermarking: Both visible (to display ownership) and hidden (encrypted strings that prevent unauthorized printing or downloading).
  • Certification Technology: Establishing trust relationships through third-party copyright management agencies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is an analytical review of IP problems and management strategies rather than a data-driven empirical study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Preservation Paradox: Simply saving "pure content" is insufficient for long-term preservation. Without metadata (structure, encryption methods, labeling), data eventually becomes "invalid." However, creating and storing this metadata involves "modification rights," creating a new layer of IP complexity.
  • Liability Shifting: A key recommendation for organizations is to include clauses in purchase contracts that require database developers to provide "copyright proof." This ensures that if a third-party author sues for infringement, the legal and economic responsibility falls on the developer, not the organization hosting the LAN.
  • Storage System Taxonomy: The authors categorize storage systems by their "degree of restoration services" (Hidden, Semi-transparent, and Transparent). Each level carries different IP risks; for instance, "Transparent" systems involve complex rights constraints because they handle various aspects of storage processing rights.
  • The Role of LAN Isolation: The paper highlights that even though these networks are physically isolated from the Internet, they are still legally considered "wired propagation methods" under Chinese Copyright Law, meaning they are not exempt from dissemination regulations.

Key Results

The paper concludes that technical solutions alone cannot solve IP problems. The primary "results" are the proposed frameworks for organizational compliance:

  • Compliance with Article 10: Organizations must respect the five core rights of authors: publication, authorship, modification, integrity, and compilation.
  • Technical Efficacy: Digital watermarking is identified as a particularly effective tool because it persists regardless of whether a file is viewed, copied, or transmitted, acting as a permanent "ID card" for digital works.
  • Strategic Acquisition: The authors emphasize that "Strategy of Purchase" is the most effective way to handle the core of LAN sharing—the database—by ensuring legitimacy at the point of entry.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the construction of digital information resources is an ongoing process that must constantly balance legal measures with technical innovation.

Limitations: * The analysis is heavily centered on the legal framework of the People's Republic of China (specifically the 2001 revision of the Copyright Law), which may limit its direct applicability to international legal contexts. * The paper discusses technologies (like encryption and watermarking) at a high level without addressing the computational overhead or user experience friction these measures might introduce.

Future Work: The authors suggest that future efforts should focus on more deeply integrating legal measures with evolving technical means to ensure the "healthy and sustainable development" of digital libraries and information sharing ecosystems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024depth,
  author = {Jingjing Li and Juan Wang},
  title = {{An In-depth Analysis on Intellectual Property Problems Confronted by Local Area Network Information Resource Sharing in Diverse Industries}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2991/978-2-38476-297-2\_105},
}

Loading related content...

Figure