A Detection of Mispricing in Chinese Option Market

Yucheng Liu, Yanghao Xiao, Yuanyuan Deng, Xingyu Liang, Chunyuan Zheng, Haoxuan LiAtlantis 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract: As a new market established in 2015, the Chinese options market exhibits characteristics of information asymmetry, making the search for general investment patterns critical. This article analyzes Chinese stock index options data to reveal the statistical laws of the "calendar effect." Through regression analysis on implied volatility and the construction of delta-hedged and straddle strategies, we verify that market makers often neglect the influence of the specific number of days between expiration and purchase. While a pricing discrepancy caused by the calendar effect exists, high transaction costs and market randomness prevent simple strategies from yielding robust positive returns, unlike in more mature markets like the U.S.

Introduction

In an efficient market, option prices should accurately reflect the time remaining until expiration. Standard models, such as Black-Scholes, imply that an additional week in an expiration cycle should result in a predictable value adjustment (typically 5% to 10%). However, "calendar effects" emerge when market participants focus on the month of expiration rather than the exact day count. This leads to systematic mispricing between months with four-week versus five-week cycles.

While this phenomenon is well-documented in the U.S., the Chinese options market is relatively young and less liquid. This study investigates whether such mispricing persists in China and evaluates the feasibility of exploiting it through quantitative strategies.

Data and Methodology

The study utilized the WIND database, encompassing approximately 120 months of Chinese stock index options data from 2015 to 2022. The dataset includes Huaxia 50ETF options, Huatai-Pinebridge 300ETF options, Jiashi Hushen 300ETF options, and Hushen 300 options from the CFFEX.

To ensure data quality, the authors filtered for liquidity by removing contracts with zero volume or open interest and restricted the analysis to options with Delta ranges between 0.1 and 0.9. The methodology involved:

  1. Regression Analysis: Testing for mispricing by regressing Implied Volatility (IV) against a dummy variable for the 5-week expiration cycle.
  2. Strategy Testing: Constructing Straddles and Delta-Hedged (DH) Call/Put portfolios to isolate volatility mispricing.
  3. Normalization: Using daily yields to facilitate fair comparisons between different cycle lengths.

Analysis of the Calendar Effect

Implied Volatility Discrepancies

The data confirms a significant calendar effect. Options with a 4-week expiration cycle are consistently more expensive than those with a 5-week cycle. On average, the IV for 4-week cycles was found to be approximately 5% higher than for 5-week cycles, suggesting that market makers underprice the "extra week" in longer cycles.

Descriptive statistics comparing 4-week and 5-week expiration cycles.

Statistical Significance

Regression results further validate this anomaly. The coefficients for the 5-week dummy variable were negative and statistically significant, with t-statistics consistently below -2. This confirms that the presence of a 5-week cycle exerts a downward pressure on IV that is not fully accounted for by standard pricing mechanisms.

Regression analysis of the 5-week expiration cycle dummy variable on option pricing.

Key Insights and Results

  • The Profitability Paradox: Despite the clear mispricing, the study found that simple arbitrage strategies do not yield robust positive returns in the Chinese market. The number of profitable trades in the tested strategies was frequently less than the number of losing trades.
  • Transaction Costs: The primary barrier to profitability is the high cost of trading in China. For instance, CFFEX options carry a fee of 15 yuan per contract, and short-selling costs can reach 8% annually. These frictions often consume the theoretical alpha generated by the calendar effect.
  • IV-HV as a Predictor: A more reliable indicator for returns was the gap between Implied Volatility (IV) and Historical Volatility (HV). Regression analysis showed that options with a narrower IV-HV gap tend to produce higher daily yields, offering a more potent signal than the calendar effect alone.

Conclusion

The Chinese options market exhibits a detectable calendar effect where 4-week options are overpriced relative to 5-week options. However, the market's relative youth, limited variety of instruments, and high transaction costs make it difficult for investors to profit from this specific mispricing using standard U.S.-style strategies. Future research should focus on multi-factor models that integrate the calendar effect with liquidity and volatility indicators to overcome the high barrier of entry in the Chinese market.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a new market in 2015, the Chinese options market has the characteristics of information asymmetry. Therefore, searching for a general investment pattern is important. This article analyzes all Chinese stock index options data and reveals the statistical law of the calendar effect in the option market. The article conducts regression analysis on unreasonable volatility, building delta hedge and straddle option strategies, and using regression analysis on options yield to verify that the market makers neglect the influence of the difference between expiration date and purchase date. The pricing difference caused by the calendar effect of options does exist, but unlike the US options market, investors cannot just use simple strategies to obtain a robust positive return in the Chinese market through the calendar effect.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022detection,
  author = {Yucheng Liu and Yanghao Xiao and Yuanyuan Deng and Xingyu Liang and Chunyuan Zheng and Haoxuan Li},
  title = {{A Detection of Mispricing in Chinese Option Market}},
  booktitle = {Atlantis},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-010-7\_85},
}
Figure