Quantum coherence embodies the superposition principle, a core feature that distinguishes quantum mechanics from classical physics. To utilize coherence as a physical resource in quantum information processing, we must be able to quantify it rigorously.
Mathematically, many robust coherence measures are distance-based: they define the coherence of a quantum state $\rho$ as its minimum distance to the set of all "incoherent" (purely diagonal) states $\mathcal{I}$:
$$C(\rho) = \min_{\sigma \in \mathcal{I}} D(\rho, \sigma)$$
While conceptually elegant, this definition introduces a severe bottleneck. Finding $\sigma$ requires solving a complex optimization problem over a vast space of valid quantum states. Furthermore, evaluating this in a laboratory traditionally requires full quantum state tomography to reconstruct $\rho$, an operational burden that scales exponentially with system size.
To bridge the gap between theory and practice, recent research focuses on simplifying this framework through two complementary strategies: exploiting the geometric structure of specific state families to collapse the optimization space, and using multi-copy collective measurements to bypass state reconstruction entirely.
Collapsing the Optimization Search Space
The primary mathematical challenge in distance-based coherence is the minimization step. However, if we restrict our focus to structured, physically significant families of quantum states, the "closest" incoherent state can often be determined analytically.
In Trace Distance Measure of Coherence for a Class of Qudit States, Yan-Ling Wang et al. investigate multi-level qudit systems using the trace distance metric. They prove that for a specific class of qudit states, the optimal incoherent state $\sigma$ is simply the diagonal part of the state itself ($\sigma = \text{diag}(\rho)$). By zeroing out the off-diagonal elements, you eliminate all quantum coherence while perfectly preserving the state's classical probability distribution. This structural insight collapses an unconstrained optimization problem into a trivial, direct calculation.
General State ρ Closest Incoherent State σ
┌───────────────┐ ┌───────────────┐
│ p₁ c₁₂ c₁₃│ Zero out │ p₁ 0 0 │
│ c₂₁ p₂ c₂₃│ ───────────> │ 0 p₂ 0 │
│ c₃₁ c₃₂ p₃ │ off-diagonals│ 0 0 p₃ │
└───────────────┘ └───────────────┘
Optimization is bypassed because σ is known analytically.
A similar reduction occurs in multi-qubit systems. Ming-Jing Zhao et al. in Coherence concurrence for X states derive an explicit analytical formula for "coherence concurrence" within X-states—states whose non-zero elements arise only along the main diagonal and anti-diagonal. This geometric constraint allows the authors to link coherence directly to entanglement metrics (specifically, the convex roof extended negativity), making quantification straightforward.
For even broader multipartite systems, Chenglu Zhu et al. in Geometric discord for multiqubit systems demonstrate that when N-qubit states are characterized by sums of Pauli operators, calculating geometric quantum discord—a measure of quantum correlations beyond entanglement—becomes computationally tractable, bypassing the need to navigate arbitrary state spaces.
Axiomatic Rigor and Monotonicity
Simplifying the mathematics of a metric is only useful if the metric remains physically meaningful. To be a valid resource quantifier, a coherence measure must satisfy strict physical axioms:
- Faithfulness: Coherence must be strictly positive for superposition states and zero if and only if the state is entirely incoherent.
- Convexity: Mixing two quantum states cannot create more coherence than the average coherence of the individual states.
- Monotonicity: Coherence cannot increase under incoherent operations (classical manipulations cannot generate quantumness out of nothing).
Proving monotonicity can be exceptionally difficult when a measure is modified to simplify its calculation. Meng-Li Guo et al. address this in Quantifying quantum coherence based on the Tsallis relative operator entropy. They introduce a generalized family of coherence measures and rigorously prove that they satisfy strong monotonicity. This means that coherence does not increase on average, even when an experimenter tracks the distinct outcomes of selective sub-channels (post-selection).
Similarly, the trace distance formulations derived by Yan-Ling Wang et al. are proven to satisfy monotonicity under selective incoherent channels, provided the operations are restricted to specific matrix dimensions. This ensures that the simplified mathematical expressions still respect the fundamental physical laws governing quantum resources.
Bypassing Tomography via Collective Measurements
Even with closed-form analytical equations, calculating coherence still requires an experimenter to know the numerical values of the density matrix $\rho$. Traditionally, this demands full quantum state tomography, which requires an impractical number of measurements.
We can bypass state reconstruction entirely by shifting our perspective from measuring a single state to performing collective measurements on multiple copies of a state simultaneously.
State Copy 1 (ρ) ──┐
├─> [ Bell State Measurement ] ──> Probabilities ──> Coherence Value
State Copy 2 (ρ) ──┘
In Optimal Estimation of Quantum Coherence by Bell State Measurement: A Case Study, Xufeng Huang et al. demonstrate an elegant implementation of this concept. By preparing two identical copies of a qubit state ($\rho \otimes \rho$) and sending them into a joint Bell State Measurement (BSM), the quantum interference between the two copies maps the off-diagonal elements of $\rho$ directly onto the probabilities of the measurement outcomes.
Because the measurement probabilities are direct functions of the coherence quantifiers, the experimenter can extract the exact coherence value without ever reconstructing the underlying state. The authors prove that when this data is processed using Maximum Likelihood Estimation, the accuracy hits the Cramér-Rao bound—the absolute theoretical limit for unbiased statistical estimation. This proves that collective measurements offer an optimal, highly efficient path for tracking quantum resources in real-world hardware.
Key Foundational Work
Trace distance measure of coherence for a class of qudit states (2016) — contributed 7 concept elements to this direction.
Quantifying quantum coherence based on the Tsallis relative operator entropy (2020) — contributed 3 concept elements to this direction.
Coherence concurrence for X states (2020) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.