Partitioned Experience Replay for Reinforcement Learning

17 concepts15 papers1 proposal

In deep reinforcement learning (RL), experience replay is the mechanism that breaks the temporal correlation of sequential data. By storing transitions—tuples of states, actions, rewards, and next states—in a memory buffer, an agent can sample past experiences uniformly at random to stabilize neural network training.

However, this monolithic approach assumes a homogeneous data distribution. When an agent encounters highly skewed environments—such as sparse rewards, mixed human-agent interactions, or a blend of simulated and real-world data—a single uniform buffer fails. The critical, high-quality, or rare transitions are quickly diluted by a sea of redundant or low-quality exploratory data.

To solve this, a powerful paradigm has emerged: partitioned experience replay. Instead of pooling all experiences into a single bucket, this approach segregates data into distinct, distribution-specific buffers. By actively managing the sampling ratios between these buffers, developers can precisely control the agent's learning diet, preventing catastrophic forgetting and stabilizing optimization.

Balancing Success and Failure in Sparse Rewards

The most acute failure mode of a monolithic replay buffer occurs in sparse-reward environments. If an agent only receives a positive signal upon successfully completing a complex task, successful trajectories are exceptionally rare. In a standard uniform buffer, these rare successes are treated as statistical noise and are quickly overwritten or rarely sampled.

Monolithic Buffer:
[ Fail, Fail, Fail, Success, Fail, Fail, Fail, Fail ] -> Uniform sampling rarely hits "Success"

Partitioned Buffers:
Buffer A (Failures):  [ Fail, Fail, Fail, Fail, Fail ] 
Buffer B (Successes): [ Success, Success ]             -> Controlled sampling ensures a 50/50 mix

To prevent a learned dynamics model from treating rare, high-reward transitions as outliers, Kaushik et al. introduced a dual-buffer strategy in Multi-objective Model-based Policy Search for Data-efficient Learning with Sparse Rewards. By maintaining separate memory repositories for rewarded and unrewarded interaction trials, the authors ensured that the model retained critical information about successful trajectories even when they occurred infrequently during early exploration.

Similarly, Yuan et al. demonstrated in Rearrangement with Nonprehensile Manipulation Using Deep Reinforcement Learning that actively monitoring the ratio of successful to failed episodes and adjusting storage priorities prevents reinforcement learning models from converging on suboptimal or "lazy" policies.

Isolating successful trajectories into a dedicated positive buffer allows algorithms to explicitly balance exploration and exploitation. For instance, the architecture proposed by Hao et al. in Independent Generative Adversarial Self-Imitation Learning in Cooperative Multiagent Systems pairs a standard buffer for general off-policy learning with a specialized positive buffer for high-reward experiences. In continuous control settings, Futuhi et al. showed in ETGL-DDPG: A Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient Algorithm for Sparse Reward Continuous Control that dynamically increasing the sampling frequency of a dedicated success buffer as training progresses stabilizes learning and prevents the agent from forgetting goal-reaching behaviors.

This categorization can be extended beyond a simple binary split. In complex environments, Wang et al. developed a strategy in Coordinated Power Smoothing Control Strategy of Multi-Wind Turbines and Energy Storage Systems in Wind Farm Based on MADRL that partitions experience replay into positive, negative, and neutral pools based on reward thresholds. This granular division, also leveraged by Hu et al. in Energy-efficient Caching and Task offloading for Timely Status Updates in UAV-assisted VANETs, ensures that the agent avoids local optima by learning effectively from both exceptional successes and critical failures.

Protecting Expert Guidance from Exploratory Noise

When training an agent using human demonstrations or teacher-guided interventions, the data distributions of the expert and the autonomous agent are fundamentally different. Early-stage random exploration produces highly chaotic, low-quality transitions. If these are mixed directly with clean expert demonstrations, the high-quality signal gets obscured by noise.

To protect expert guidance, Chen et al. proposed partitioning the experience replay into separate buffers for expert-guided and autonomous interactions in Agent-Aware Dropout DQN for Safe and Efficient On-line Dialogue Policy Learning. This partitioning ensures that the reinforcement learning agent can learn from expert guidance without the signal being diluted by early-stage random errors.

This separation is equally critical for real-world robotics. In Data-Efficient Learning from Human Interventions for Mobile Robots, Peng et al. maintained separate data repositories for human-corrected transitions and autonomous robot actions, allowing the optimization process to cleanly distinguish between expert corrections and trial-and-error exploration.

Even when the "expert" data is a static offline dataset or a single initial demonstration, keeping it isolated from online exploration data prevents optimization instability. Chaudhary et al. demonstrated this in MOORL: A Framework for Integrating Offline-Online Reinforcement Learning by maintaining separate replay buffers for offline and online data. This allowed the training process to alternate between data distributions during an inner-loop optimization phase, helping the model parameters adapt smoothly without experiencing a jarring distribution shift.

Similarly, Libardi et al. utilized a dual-buffer system in Guided Exploration with Proximal Policy Optimization using a Single Demonstration to isolate a single human demonstration and subsequent agent successes from failed attempts that merely showed potential.

Managing Real versus Synthetic Distributions

A third major failure mode occurs when mixing data from different generation sources, such as physical environments and simulators, or real trajectories and data-augmented trajectories.

In sim-to-real applications, simulators can generate synthetic data at a massive scale, while real-world data is sparse and expensive to collect. If pooled together, the high-frequency synthetic data completely overwhelms the real-world observations. Di-Castro Shashua et al. resolved this imbalance in Sim and Real: Better Together by maintaining dedicated replay buffers for simulation and reality. By decoupling the collection rate from the sampling rate, the authors ensured that the learning algorithm maintained a balanced representation of both simulated and physical dynamics.

Data Generation Rates:
Simulation: [====== High Frequency ======] -> Buffer Sim
Real World: [= Low Frequency =]             -> Buffer Real

Downstream Learning Component:
Samples 50% from Buffer Sim + 50% from Buffer Real

A similar distribution mismatch occurs when using data augmentation to teach agents symmetrical behaviors. In MAER-Nav: Bidirectional Motion Learning Through Mirror-Augmented Experience Replay for Robot Navigation, Wang et al. maintained separate storage for real-world interactions and synthetically generated mirrored experiences. This dual-buffer approach ensured that the agent sampled equally from both forward and backward motion patterns, preventing the policy from becoming biased toward a single direction.

Separation is also vital when an agent generates "refreshed" experiences by re-evaluating past states under its newest policy. Du et al. showed in Lucid dreaming for experience replay: refreshing past states with the current policy that isolating refreshed, high-reward trajectories into a dedicated secondary replay buffer yields significantly better learning performance than merging all experiences into a single, larger buffer.

Why It Works: The Intuition of Controlled Gradient Mixing

Why does partitioning the experience replay work so much better than a single buffer with prioritized sampling? The answer lies in how neural networks optimize their weights based on gradient updates.

  1. Guaranteed Representation in Every Batch: In a monolithic buffer, the probability of sampling a rare transition approaches zero as the buffer grows. Prioritized Experience Replay (PER) attempts to fix this using Temporal Difference (TD) error, but high TD-error can cause the network to over-focus on noisy outliers or unfeasible states. Partitioned buffers bypass this by enforcing a structural constraint: every training batch is guaranteed to contain a fixed percentage of transitions from each distribution (e.g., 50% success, 50% failure).
  2. Preventing Catastrophic Overwriting: In multi-agent or non-stationary environments, optimal strategies might be discovered but rarely executed due to coordination failures. As Palmer et al. noted in Negative Update Intervals in Deep Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning, maintaining separate buffers for distinct high-level actions prevents data from optimal but less frequent strategies from being overwritten by common sub-optimal transitions, protecting against catastrophic forgetting.
  3. Isolating Distribution Shifts: When mixing expert/autonomous or sim/real data, the underlying transition dynamics or policy distributions differ. Forcing a single neural network to optimize over a blended, unpredictable distribution can destabilize the value function. Partitioned buffers allow structured alternating updates or explicit weighting, giving the optimization process a predictable, balanced diet of data.

By treating experience replay as a structured collection of distinct data streams rather than a single chaotic pool, partitioned experience replay provides a simple, robust architectural solution to some of the most persistent stability challenges in deep reinforcement learning.

Key Foundational Work

Agent-Aware Dropout DQN for Safe and Efficient On-line Dialogue Policy Learning (2017) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.
Multi-objective Model-based Policy Search for Data-efficient Learning with Sparse Rewards (2018) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.
Rearrangement with Nonprehensile Manipulation Using Deep Reinforcement Learning (2018) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.
History & citationVersion 1 · 2026-10-04

Current · Permanent link

View frozen version 1

Cite this direction

Latest version (a living page):

@misc{lacuna_dual_buffer_experience_replay_bb01b650,
  title = {dual-buffer experience replay},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/dual-buffer-experience-replay/rdr_bb01b6502b184a8d97a6b211bf233800},
  note = {Latest version of a living research direction; cite a version for a fixed text. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}

This exact version (version 1, frozen text):

@misc{lacuna_dual_buffer_experience_replay_bb01b650_v1,
  title = {dual-buffer experience replay},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/dual-buffer-experience-replay/rdr_bb01b6502b184a8d97a6b211bf233800/v/1},
  note = {Version 1, frozen 2026-10-04. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}
About

These directions overlap with this one through shared papers.

See something wrong? Report a mistake